Sherman Lakes - Galena Ohio Homes for Sale

Exceptional in scale, design, and quality, 5564 Aster Way offers a distinctive custom floor plan in desirable Sherman Lakes. An open two-story foyer introduces an impressive interior with 10'+ main-level ceilings, a formal living room, and flexible formal dining room/office. The massive great room features custom built-ins and a fireplace, while the expansive kitchen is a true centerpiece with a vaulted ceiling, skylights, abundant workspace, and an oversized casual dining area. A dramatic vaulted office occupies its own level on the way to the second floor--one of many architectural details that set this home apart. Upstairs, rare 9'+ ceilings enhance the sense of scale. The vaulted primary suite features skylights and custom built-ins, complemented by an impressive bath with an oversized walk-in shower and spacious walk-in closet. Two generous bedrooms share a Jack-and-Jill bath, while the fourth bedroom is a private guest suite with its own full bath. The finished lower level offers exceptional additional living space, a full bath, and an egress window providing natural light. Recent improvements include the furnace, almost all windows, main-level flooring, and roof. An impressive 3-car garage adds to the functionality. Perfectly positioned with tranquil pond views, the patio opens to a generous yard. Located within Olentangy Schools and just minutes from Alum Creek State Park and Reservoir, the home offers convenient access to boating, trails, recreation, shopping, dining, and everyday amenities, with easy connections to Galena, Westerville, Polaris, and major roadways. Simply move in and enjoy!

5564 Aster Way, Galena

Listing Courtesy of : Benjamin Thomas Hemmert ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs

$650,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 226007685 MLS

Space, flexibility, and major updates--all in one exceptional home. Just minutes from Alum Creek State Park, beaches, boating, golf, and scenic walking trails, this former Parade of Homes model offers over 5,000 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space with a floor plan that's difficult to find. Whether you're looking for room to grow, space for extended family, long-term guests, or simply the flexibility to fit your lifestyle, this home delivers. From the moment you step inside, you'll be greeted by rich hardwood floors, a dramatic entry staircase, and light-filled living spaces designed for both everyday comfort and effortless entertaining. The heart of the home is the spacious kitchen, featuring abundant cabinetry, a large center island with seating, and a butler's pantry that flows seamlessly into the open living and dining areas. The versatile layout includes three generously sized bedrooms and a loft upstairs, a main-level bedroom perfect for guests or a home office, and a beautifully finished lower level complete with its own bedroom, full bath, kitchen, and living space. Whether you're accommodating extended family, creating a private retreat for visitors, or looking for additional entertaining space, the possibilities are endless. Major updates provide peace of mind for years to come, including a new roof (2025), new HVAC and furnace (2025), two brand-new air conditioning systems, and a newer sump pump. Outside, a 9-zone irrigation system helps keep the beautifully landscaped yard looking its best all season long. Offering an unbeatable combination of space, versatility, and major recent improvements in a prime Galena location, this move-in ready home is an incredible opportunity you won't want to miss.

1160 Forsyth Lane, Galena

Listing Courtesy of : Ashley T Henry ---- Keller Williams Consultants

$645,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 225043565 MLS

Stunning former Parade of Homes 5-level split located in the beautiful Sherman Lakes community. Entertain friends in the lower-level bar or relax on the serene covered patio. This home is filled with exceptional features including a 2-story great room, gourmet kitchen, workout room, elegant stone accents, architectural pillars, and a California closet in the primary suite. Recent updates include French door to office and 2 doors on the side of home in 2025, Rosati windows, new sliding door to patio, new gutters, siding, and trim, all replaced in 2024, carpet in 2023, and newer roof. All 5 levels beautifully finished. Close to Alum Creek-welcome home!

1138 Forsyth Lane, Galena

Listing Courtesy of : Leslie M Nartker ---- Coldwell Banker Realty

Selling Office: The Brokerage House .

$750,000

4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 225034273 MLS

Beautiful Former Parade of Homes 2 story home on huge cul-de-sac lot.. 4 bedrooms 4 full baths plus powder room on 1st floor. Cooks dream kitchen with eat-in area plus formal dining off kitchen area. Living area with fireplace. 3 large bedrooms upstairs each with full baths.. Primary Suite has a study/ office area, Large walk-in closet, Deluxe Bath with free standing tub. there is also a beautiful deck off Primary suite to enjoy evening/ morning coffees.. Utility room with washer/dryer upstairs for easy convenience. Lower level has 4th bedroom, full bath and sauna area. There is also a large storage area. Outside space is perfect for entertaining or just relaxing. 3 car attached garage (2 front load and 1 side load garage) Professional photo's coming soon!

1094 Forsyth Lane, Galena

Listing Courtesy of : Jeffrey W Cutler ---- J W Cutler & Assocs., Inc

Selling Office: Howard Hanna Real Estate Services.

$740,000

4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 225019980 MLS

This former Parade of Homes beauty offers 5,100+ square feet of luxury living and unforgettable views in one of the area's most sought-after locations. Nestled by Alum Creek, just a mile south of Rt. 36 and I-71 off Africa Road—and only 10 minutes from Polaris—this custom-built stunner features panoramic pond views, elegant finishes, and incredible outdoor living spaces. Inside, you'll be greeted by rich Brazilian cherry hardwood floors flowing through a spacious open-concept layout. The gourmet kitchen is a chef's dream, with granite countertops, 42'' cabinetry, breakfast bar and stainless steel appliances—all seamlessly connected to the vaulted great room. Enjoy a cozy evening by the gas fireplace, or soak in serene waterfront views from a wall of windows. The first-floor owner's retreat is a true sanctuary, featuring hardwood floors, two elegant en-suite bathrooms, private fireplace and dual walk-in closets for the ultimate in comfort and privacy. Just off the kitchen and dining area, a peaceful screened-in porch invites you to enjoy quiet mornings or relaxing evenings with tranquil water views. Upstairs, you'll find two spacious bedrooms connected by a Jack-and-Jill bath, plus a versatile loft area. The finished lower level expands your living space dramatically, with a full bar/kitchenette, family room with gas fireplace, two recreation areas, and a fourth bedroom—perfect for guests, teens, or multigenerational living. Step outside to your private backyard oasis, featuring a custom paver patio, pergola, and beautifully landscaped grounds overlooking the pond—ideal for entertaining or simply unwinding. Additional highlights include a heated, oversized 2-car garage, ample storage, and top-rated Olentangy schools. With over 5,100 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, this home checks every box for comfort, style, and functionality—don't miss your chance to make it yours!

5753 Aster Way, Galena

Listing Courtesy of : Julian Montunnas ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs

Selling Office: Keller Williams Greater Cols.

$500,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 225019109 MLS

Move right in and enjoy this turnkey first floor master home located in one of the areas hottest communities. Sherman Lakes and neighboring Alum Creek State Park make this a must consider area. Soaring two story great room with stone fireplace. Beautiful kitchen with water view. Nice size first floor owner suite with tub/shower and walk-in closet. A 2nd floor guest bathroom Two additional guest bedrooms on the second floor. unfinished lower level already set up for a 3rd full bath and would add over 1000 sq.ft. of living space. Just move right in and enjoy just in time for all the summer family get togethers. only about a mile away from Boating, hiking, camping, fishing, mountain bike riding. The Roof and Gutters are new in May of 2024 and all furniture in the home is negotiable for sale.

1279 Forsyth Lane, Galena

Listing Courtesy of : Scott A Marvin ---- Team Results Realty

Selling Office: Team Results Realty.

$560,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 225012922 MLS

Custom Built two story in desirable Sherman Lakes with beautiful water views throughout. Exceptional open concept layout. Towering entry with beautiful hardwoods, First floor office with built-ins. Columned formal dining area highlights the openness of this home. Soaring great room highlighted by the wall of windows, wrought iron railings, and gas fireplace. Granite kitchen with beautiful oak cabinets, plenty of additional eating space and another built in work space. Upstairs is home to huge primary suite with a beautiful water view from the garden tub and sizeable walk in closet. Perfect guest suite with it's own en-suite, two other huge bedrooms share a Jack - n -Jill. Full basement with 9'ft ceilings could add additional living space. Brand new Roof (September '24), Water tank (2022), New Sump Pump & Battery Back-up added (2023), recently painted exterior trim. Solid wood interior doors throughout. Home has been very well cared for, and is squeaky clean.

1341 Forsyth Lane, Galena

Listing Courtesy of : Samuel Krafty ---- Weichert, Realtors Triumph Group

Selling Office: NON MEMBER OFFICE.

$685,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 225005995 MLS

Discover luxury living in this stunning home with exquisite details throughout. Luxury vinyl laminate floors flow through the expansive first floor, complemented by 9ft ceilings, crown molding, and wood privacy blinds. Enjoy effortless climate control with Google Nest on each level. The chef's kitchen features a large island, glass front cabinetry, quartz countertops, soft-close cabinets, and a double oven. A grand 2-story entry leads to the vaulted master suite with dual closets and a spa-like bath with a soak tub, walk-in shower, and separate toilet room. The backyard oasis offers serene fountain pond views. With 4 beds, 2.5 baths, a finished basement with extra living space, rough-in for a bath, and a radon system, this home is the perfect blend of elegance and comfort.

5660 Aster Way, Galena

Listing Courtesy of : Tammy L Marquardt ---- e-Merge Real Estate

Selling Office: NextHome Experience.

$699,900

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 224031367 MLS

Absolutely stunning custom built former Parade of Homes w/ BREATHTAKING WATER VIEWS & outdoor living space, in Olentangy Schools! Step inside & admire the gorgeous walnut & marble flooring sprawling throughout the open floor plan! Head back to the gourmet kitchen w/ granite countertops, stainless steel appliances & 42'' cabinetry. Adjacent, an impressive great room w/ gas fireplace & wall of windows offering enchanting views of the lake. Private den w/ built ins, dining & living room offers abundant living space on the 1st floor. Wake up to the sunrise over the water from the large owners retreat w/ hardwood floors, luxurious spa bath & walk-in closet. Oversized, deep 2.5 car garage (heated & cooled)! Massive full basement. Out back, private, unbelievable multi-tier living w/ 13' swim spa

1179 Forsyth Lane, Galena

Listing Courtesy of : Julian Montunnas ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs

Selling Office: EXP Realty, LLC.

$655,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 224026972 MLS

Step inside to discover your new home in this previous model filled with upgrades! Gourmet kitchen is a chef's delight, featuring stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and a large island perfect for gatherings. The master suite is a true sanctuary, complete with a luxurious en-suite bathroom, dual custom walk-in closets, and bonus reading or relaxation nook. The additional bedrooms are generously sized, providing comfort and privacy for guests. The large finished basement is an entertainers dream, equipped with a private theatre room, extra playroom or gym space, full bath, and ample gathering space. Located in highly coveted Olentangy school district. This is the perfect home to create lasting memories, make it yours today! Irrigation system, high ceilings, new roof-2023

5755 McClellon Drive, Galena

Listing Courtesy of : Nitesh Patel ---- iRealty Experts, LLC.

Selling Office: RE/MAX Achievers.

$560,100

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 224025363 MLS

This stunning 4-bedroom, 3-full bath, 1-half bath custom built home is the epitome of luxury living. As you step through the entry, the grandeur of this residence unfolds. The main level boasts a cozy fireplace, perfect for gathering on chilly evenings. In the heart of the home, the kitchen offers beautiful views of a peaceful pond wildlife and backs up to Alum creek. Work from Home in the first floor office that has plenty of natural light. Additional living space in the partially finished basement. Additional features: New HVAC 2023, Hot water tank (2022), Built in surround sound on main level and deck, built in speaker in master bedroom/bath, working central vacuum, invisible fence, irrigation system and security system. HSP Home warranty included for $669.

5555 Aster Way, Galena

Listing Courtesy of : Victoria Christy ---- RE/MAX Connection

Selling Office: Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs.

$575,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 224020377 MLS

So much space! You have to walk through to understand! Right around the corner from Alum Creek, this huge 5 bed 4.5 bath in Sherman Lakes has all the space you're looking for! Private office and front living/dining room, huge kitchen open to the main living space and breakfast/sunroom! With the ultra private patio and mature landscaping you can hang with your neighbors at the firepit or ignore them in the hot tub depending on your mood! And this house has what so many of the new builds in this price range lack, a fireplace in the living space and a bathtub in the primary suite! Tons of space downstairs in the finished basement with egress window and full bathroom and even more on the second floor with an additional four bedrooms and two full baths. And the house has SO much storage!

5743 Aster Way, Galena

Listing Courtesy of : Stephen Jones ---- Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs

Selling Office: Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs.

$640,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 224003260 MLS

This stunning 4-bedroom, 3-full bath, 1-half bath home built by Ryan Homes is the epitome of luxury living. As you step through the impressive 2-story entry, the grandeur of this residence unfolds. The main level boasts a cozy fireplace, perfect for gathering on chilly evenings. The heart of the home, the kitchen, showcases maple cabinets, granite counters, a dual oven, stainless sink, and a suite of stainless steel appliances. The aesthetic is completed by a beautiful backsplash that adds a touch of sophistication. Entertainment knows no bounds in the finished lower level, where a wet bar awaits your mixology skills, a theater area invites cinematic experiences, and a full bath and recreational space ensure every need is met. So many details await your tour!

5693 Aster Way, Galena

Listing Courtesy of : Tera Barker ---- Century 21 Excellence Realty

Selling Office: Beckett Realty Group.

$670,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 223025067 MLS

This Former Parade of Homes showstopper is waiting for it's new owner. The home boasts five levels of living space with 4 beds & 4 baths. Primary has a large ensuite with walk in closet which includes California Closet built-in shelving. Great for entertaining from the large custom cabinet kitchen, formal dining room, large paver patio or 2 large great rooms. Home also features a Movie Room and work out space. Work from Home in the first floor office that has plenty of natural light. Close to Alum Creek with easy access to 36/37 & 71

1138 Forsyth Lane, Galena

Listing Courtesy of : Melissa R Holmes-Gregory ---- Coldwell Banker Realty

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Realty.

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

Sherman Lakes - Galena, OH Homes for Sale

Are you looking to buy or sell a home in Sherman Lakes Galena Ohio? Call or Text (614) 683-5116 to schedule a showing on any Sherman Lakes Galena, OH home for sale or to sell your Sherman Lakes Galena Ohio home! As Realtors specializing in the Sherman Lakes Galena area, we can take care of all of your Sherman Lakes Galena OH real estate needs including buying pre-existing homes, new construction homes, condominiums, land, commercial and multi-family homes in Sherman Lakes Galena Ohio. We can also help you find distressed properties in Sherman Lakes Galena including HUD Homes, Short Sales and REO Bank Foreclosures. If you need help financing a home in Sherman Lakes Galena, we have access to some of the best lenders that service the Sherman Lakes Galena Ohio area, including lenders that offer credit repair to buy a home and work with home builders in and near the Sherman Lakes Galena area to help you build your home while building up your credit. If you are going to buy or sell a home in Sherman Lakes Galena Ohio, then be sure to Call or Text (614) 683-5116 Today! We are a real estate team specializing in the Sherman Lakes Galena, OH area! Displayed are homes for sale in Sherman Lakes Galena, OH, a Subdivision located in Galena Ohio. These Sherman Lakes Galena Listings are updated every 15 minutes from the Galena MLS.