Poinsettia Park Homes for Sale

Poinsettia Park Homes for Sale

$1,495,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ A4703284 MLS
Classic Sarasota charm takes on a fresh, sophisticated spirit in this beautifully updated residence, where relaxed interiors, thoughtful details and lush outdoor spaces create an inviting retreat designed for modern Florida living. At the heart of the home, an open and inviting floor plan creates an easy flow for everyday living and entertaining alike. The spacious great room transitions naturally into the kitchen and continues onto the expansive screened lanai, blurring the line between indoors and out and creating a welcoming space to enjoy throughout the year. The primary suite is a private sanctuary with a beautifully appointed, spa-inspired bath. An ensuite guest bedroom, along with a second guest room featuring a Murphy bed and adjacent full bath, offers versatility for hosting family and friends. Outside, a lushly landscaped and fully fenced backyard feels like a private resort. The newly added pool is complemented by an outdoor shower and tropical surroundings, creating an intimate setting for quiet afternoons or evenings spent entertaining. A detached, air-conditioned studio, currently used as an artists workspace, adds a unique dimension to the property and can easily serve as a home office, fitness studio, or flexible bonus space. Thoughtful updates include a newer metal roof, A/C units, a tankless water heater, and a whole-house generator. An oversized one-car garage with abundant storage adds another layer of everyday functionality. Completing the home is a location that puts the best of Sarasota minutes away. From the powder-soft sands of Siesta Key, the boutiques and neighborhood favorites of Southside Village, and the vibrant dining, shopping and cultural scene of Downtown Sarasota, this residence offers all that makes Sarasota special.

1907 Magnolia Street, Central Sarasota

Listing courtesy of MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY. 941-951-6660
$3,790,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ A4702123 MLS
Welcome to this exceptional new construction, upgraded residence located West of Trail, featuring 5 bedrooms, 5 full bathrooms, and 3,640 square feet of thoughtfully curated living space. Designed with a refined modern aesthetic, the home blends clean architectural lines with elevated finishes and seamless indoor-outdoor living. Upon entry, soaring 20-foot ceilings, warm designer lighting, and an expansive open-concept floor plan create an immediate sense of scale and refinement. The chef’s kitchen is appointed with premium GE Café appliances, quartz countertops, and custom cabinetry, flowing effortlessly into the main living and entertaining spaces. The residence also includes a spacious two-car garage equipped with an installed electric vehicle charger for added convenience and modern functionality. Walls of sliding glass doors open to a beautifully enhanced outdoor retreat featuring lush upgraded landscaping, a resort-style pool with a newly added waterfall feature, a fully equipped outdoor kitchen, and a covered dining area complete with remote-controlled mosquito and sun screens for year-round comfort and effortless entertaining. The primary suite serves as a private sanctuary, filled with natural light and designed for both comfort and elegance. The space features a generous walk-in closet, direct access to the outdoor living area, and a spa-inspired bath with a soaking tub and separate glass-enclosed shower. A newly installed stainless steel Bosch built-in coffee system adds an additional layer of luxury, while designer wallpaper and remote-controlled screens throughout the home provide a refined finish and enhanced comfort. Upstairs, three spacious guest suites each feature their own en-suite bathroom, creating ideal accommodations for family and visitors alike, in addition to a spacious media room designed for relaxed living and entertaining. A large rooftop terrace overlooking the pool provides an exceptional setting for relaxing or entertaining. Perfectly positioned between Siesta Key and Downtown Sarasota, this residence offers convenient access to world-class beaches, dining, shopping, and cultural attractions. Thoughtfully designed with timeless architecture, elevated finishes, and exceptional attention to detail throughout, this home delivers an elevated yet comfortable living experience for modern luxury living.

1805 Goldenrod Street, Central Sarasota

Listing courtesy of THE STUTZMAN REALTY GROUP, LLC. 941-260-0709
$4,490,000
4 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ A4702122 MLS
Nestled in the heart of West of the Trail, this luxury single-story estate represents the pinnacle of modern living. Encompassing 3,262 square feet, the home features 4 bedrooms, 4 full bathrooms, and 2 half baths, all thoughtfully designed for both comfort and functionality. Set on an expansive 15,930-square-foot lot, the residence offers tranquility just moments from the shops and dining of Southside Village. Enjoy the convenience of a circular driveway with a custom paver design and garage space for three cars. With striking architecture, impeccable craftsmanship, and beautiful, thoughtfully curated finishings—showcasing detailed trim work and refined design throughout—this residence delivers sophistication and all-inclusive resort-style living in one of the area’s most desirable locations. Inside, soaring 18-foot vaulted ceilings and custom tray ceilings enhance the open-concept layout, while 12-foot full pocket sliders seamlessly connect indoor and outdoor living spaces. The living room is anchored by a sleek fireplace, creating a warm yet modern focal point. The chef’s kitchen is equipped with professional-grade gas appliances, a waterfall-edge quartz island, custom cabinetry, and an expansive butler’s pantry for effortless entertaining. A glass-enclosed wine display and tray ceiling details add dramatic appeal. The primary suite features 14-foot ceilings and a spa-inspired bath with a freestanding soaking tub, dual vanities, and a luxurious walk-in shower. All bedrooms include custom California Closets. A designated large office, spacious laundry room, and private gym complete the interior amenities. The home also has a full security system installed. Outdoors, the resort-style backyard showcases a heated saltwater pool and hot tub spa with elegant water features. The back patio, finished with a Brazilian hardwood ceiling, is enhanced with remote-controlled mosquito blinds with sun protection for year-round comfort, as well as a full sound system that can be app controlled. A fully equipped outdoor kitchen, fire pit, and outdoor SunBrite TV create the ultimate entertaining space, while a private putt-putt golf course adds a one-of-a-kind touch to this exceptional property. Please let us know how we can help and give us a call to set up a tour of this beautiful home. Thank you.

1800 Webber Street, Central Sarasota

Listing courtesy of THE STUTZMAN REALTY GROUP, LLC. 941-260-0709
$3,230,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ A4697493 MLS
Poised on one of the prettiest tree-lined West of Trail streets, this modern coastal residence offers the ideal blend of casual elegance, thoughtful design, and everyday livability. In like-new condition and custom built in 2020 by award-winning Allegra Homes—recognized by the Building Industry Association for outstanding craftsmanship and innovative home design—this 3,220-square-foot residence with 4 bedrooms and 3 baths showcases impeccable quality and attention to detail throughout. The dramatic great room features soaring 16-foot ceilings, clerestory windows that bathe the space in natural light, designer lighting, a striking electric fireplace, and a custom entertainment wall with a stone façade and illuminated glass display shelves. Triple sliding glass doors create a seamless transition to the covered and screened lanai features a 40-foot heated saltwater pool, 2 covered seating and dining areas, a fully equipped grilling station, and convenient access to a full pool bath—creating the ultimate year-round Florida lifestyle. The culinary-influenced kitchen impresses with a professional Sub-Zero and Wolf appliance package, custom cabinetry, and a dramatic quartz waterfall island with comfortable seating for 4. The full-height matching backsplash creates a stunning focal point while adding a sophisticated designer touch. The private owner's wing comes with direct lanai access, 2 customized walk-in closets, a dedicated den or home office, and the all-white bath is a refreshing oasis with its freestanding soaking tub, oversized walk-in shower, separate vanities, ample counter and cabinet space, and a water closet. A first-floor guest suite provides ideal accommodations for family and visitors, while the second level offers two additional bedrooms, a full bath, and an oversized bonus room perfect for a media room, playroom, fitness space, or additional gathering area. The home's sophisticated interior is complemented by a calming palette of whites, creams, and light-toned beiges, creating a neutral backdrop for any design style. Modern conveniences include whole-house audio with lanai speakers, a comprehensive 360-degree exterior camera system, and a low-maintenance fenced yard complete with powder-coated aluminum gates, rock walkways, artificial turf, and a private irrigation well. The striking front elevation showcases stone-wrapped columns, a brick paver driveway, and beautifully designed landscaping that creates exceptional curb appeal. You'll enjoy the convenience of walking to Southside Village with its boutique shopping, gourmet markets, acclaimed restaurants, sidewalk cafés, and vibrant local gathering spots. Downtown Sarasota, the area's renowned cultural attractions and world-famous Gulf beaches are all just minutes away. Families will appreciate the highly regarded Southside School District, known for its strong academic programs, innovative educators, and enriching arts opportunities. This exceptional residence offers the rare opportunity to enjoy luxury, comfort, and an unmatched Sarasota lifestyle in one of the city's most desirable West of Trail locations.

1838 Oleander Street, Central Sarasota

Listing courtesy of GRECO REAL ESTATE. 941-685-0449
$650,000
8 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths ⋅ A4699168 MLS
Investor alert!! Grandfathered Duplex located West of the Trail in Poinsettia Park. You have a few options with this property. You can keep it as duplex and rent it out long term or short term because it's in the city limits. But please note the property needs work and it's prime for a remodel. Currently it's a 2 bedroom and two bath on each side. Alternatively tear it down and put up a single family home. The real value is in the dirt. Million dollar homes surround the property on every side.

1824 Webber Street, Central Sarasota

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX ALLIANCE GROUP. 941-954-5454
$2,100,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ A4697162 MLS
Virtually Staged. In the heart of Southside Village, this exceptional home offers one of Sarasota’s sought-after lifestyles. Just west of Tamiami Trail in Poinsettia Park’s charming Flower Streets, the neighborhood is known for its tree-lined streets, diverse architectural character, and proximity to restaurants, boutiques, gourmet markets, Sarasota Memorial Hospital, Southside Elementary, downtown Sarasota and the Siesta Key bridge. From 1920s bungalows to newly built residences, the area reflects the character and appeal that continues to attract buyers year after year. This home combines spacious living areas with thoughtful design and inviting outdoor spaces. The first floor features 10-foot ceilings, plank tile flooring, and a great room with tray ceilings, an electric fireplace, and triple sliders that open to the patio and pool area. The kitchen is centered around a large island and includes marble countertops, stainless steel appliances and a butler pantry. A den with a Murphy bed and an adjacent full bath offers flexibility for guests, a home office or multi-purpose use. Upstairs, four bedrooms, three baths, and a family room with built-in cabinetry and a beverage refrigerator provide comfortable space for everyday living. The primary suite includes two walk-in closets, dual vanities, a soaking tub and a separate shower. Outdoor living is equally inviting, with a heated saltwater pool and spa, covered entertaining areas and open patio spaces designed for enjoying Sarasota’s year-round sunshine. With easy access to downtown Sarasota, Siesta Key, shopping, dining, healthcare and schools, this home offers an outstanding opportunity in one of the city’s desirable neighborhoods.

1850 Magnolia Street, Central Sarasota

Listing courtesy of PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY. 941-364-4000
$4,100,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ A4695800 MLS
Experience the timeless charm and distinctive elegance of this West of Trail luxury cottage, with modern finishes that remain true to its original allure, at 1829 Bougainvillea Street. Occupying three lots, it is nestled gracefully in Sarasota's most cherished neighborhood. Set on a tranquil, tree-lined avenue, moments from vibrant Southside Village, Sarasota Memorial Hospital, and the renowned sands of Siesta Key, this thoughtfully enhanced residence exudes a rare character and allure that newer homes simply cannot replicate. From the moment you step inside, you're captivated by a refined blend of historic charm and contemporary luxury. Rich hardwood flooring, detailed crown moldings, and designer lighting create a warm and refined ambiance throughout the spacious, open-concept layout. Anchoring this home is a beautifully reimagined gourmet chef's kitchen, showcasing high-end stainless steel appliances, luminous granite countertops, bespoke cabinetry, and an expansive island—ideally suited for gatherings both grand and intimate. The luxurious master suite is a serene retreat, illuminated by abundant natural light and offering generous closet space alongside a spa-inspired ensuite with a sumptuous walk-in shower and dual vanities. Additional bedrooms and versatile living areas effortlessly accommodate family, guests, or a tailored home office. Unique to this remarkable residence is the thoughtfully designed separate living quarters, complete with a private entrance, an inviting bedroom, a fully equipped kitchen, and a full bathroom. Ideal for hosting guests, housing extended family, or offering privacy to long-term visitors, these quarters are unique. Outside, the magic only continues—enchanting gardens burst with colorful bougainvillea, and mature greenery surrounds an inviting patio that effortlessly extends the living space outdoors, perfect for sunlit gatherings or quiet moments beneath Sarasota's famous skies. With meticulous care and modern upgrades, including a newer roof, advanced HVAC systems with two newly installed air conditioning units, recently replaced front-facing windows, and fully updated plumbing and electrical infrastructure, this home blends historic character with contemporary convenience, ensuring comfort, efficiency, and peace of mind. 1829 Bougainvillea Street represents more than just a renowned address; it offers a rare opportunity to own a property rich in Sarasota history and charm, distinctively set apart from uniformity and infused with authentic character. Welcome home to an extraordinary residence awaiting your personal story. Its roots run deep into our community. The prior owners have all remained friends to this day, and the resurgence of the modern cottage is now at the forefront of interior design and architecture. This property embodies that trend in a way no other home can. A true one-of-a-kind that will never be replicated.

1829 Bougainvillea Street, Central Sarasota

Listing courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER REALTY. 941-383-6411
$650,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ A4691535 MLS
Investor / Builder Alert! Exceptional WEST OF TRAIL opportunity in one of Sarasota’s desirable neighborhoods, Poinsettia Park. Located just steps from top-rated Southside Elementary School, this property offers incredible potential for redevelopment. The existing structure is a grandfathered duplex that is in very poor condition and best suited for teardown. The true value lies in the land — a 50’ x 118’ lot ideally positioned for a stunning new custom home. But if you prefer, you can keep it as a duplex and rent it. Consider it a blank canvas. Located within the city limits so short term rentals are acceptable. Enjoy a highly sought-after location just minutes to the shops and dining of Southside Village, the world-renowned beaches of Siesta Key, and the vibrant arts, dining, and waterfront lifestyle of Downtown Sarasota. Whether you’re a builder, investor, or end user looking to create a dream home, this is a rare chance to build new in an established, high-demand area surrounded by luxury properties. Opportunities like this are becoming increasingly scarce—don’t miss your chance to capitalize on this premium location! Sold as is with right to inspect.

1824 Webber Street, Central Sarasota

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX ALLIANCE GROUP. 941-954-5454
$1,890,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ A4687005 MLS
Under contract-accepting backup offers. A rare fusion of modern luxury, designer finishes, and an unbeatable Sarasota location, this stunning 2023-built residence at 3319 S Osprey Ave delivers the ultimate move-in-ready lifestyle just moments from Siesta Key Beach and Downtown Sarasota. Tucked within the highly sought-after Southside School District, this exceptional home by M&J Pham Development showcases impeccable craftsmanship, elevated design, and seamless indoor-outdoor living—perfectly tailored for those who appreciate both sophistication and comfort. From the moment you arrive, the home’s striking curb appeal, lush tropical landscaping, and expansive paver driveway set the tone for what awaits inside. Step through the front entry into a light-filled, open-concept floor plan where wide-plank luxury flooring, soaring ceilings, and a soft, coastal-modern palette create an airy and refined ambiance. The heart of the home is a show-stopping chef’s kitchen, thoughtfully designed with an oversized waterfall island, sleek custom cabinetry, quartz countertops, and a premium Fulgor Milano stainless steel appliance package, all illuminated by elegant designer lighting—creating the perfect space for both everyday living and elevated entertaining. The spacious living area flows effortlessly to the outdoor oasis through expansive glass doors, blending indoor and outdoor living with ease. Upstairs and throughout the home, generously sized bedrooms each feature private ensuite bathrooms and custom California Closets, offering both comfort and privacy for family and guests alike. The primary suite is a true retreat, boasting a spa-inspired bathroom with dual vanities, a soaking tub, a glass-enclosed walk-in shower, and a beautifully designed custom closet system. A versatile main-floor den provides the flexibility for a private office, formal dining space, or additional lounge, while the upstairs bonus loft with wet bar and wine refrigerator creates the perfect setting for entertaining, media nights, or hosting guests. Step outside to your private resort-style backyard, where a newly completed custom pool and spa (2024) takes center stage. Surrounded by lush tropical landscaping and expansive patio space, this outdoor retreat offers the perfect backdrop for relaxing in the sun, entertaining under the stars, or enjoying Sarasota’s year-round coastal climate. A covered lanai and second-story balcony further enhance the home’s outdoor living experience, providing multiple spaces to unwind and take in the serene surroundings. Additional highlights include a 2-car garage, dedicated laundry room, high-end finishes throughout, and meticulous attention to detail at every turn, making this home truly turnkey and move-in ready. Ideally located just minutes from Siesta Key’s world-renowned beaches, vibrant Downtown Sarasota, Sarasota Memorial Hospital, premier dining, shopping, and top-rated schools, this residence offers not just a home—but a lifestyle defined by luxury, convenience, and the very best of coastal Florida living.

3319 S Osprey Avenue, Central Sarasota

Listing courtesy of COMPASS FLORIDA LLC. 941-279-3630
$1,595,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ A4676645 MLS
BEST VALUE WEST OF THE TRAIL! HUGE PRICE IMPROVEMENT! This dazzling custom-built, single-level pool home is situated in the desirable "flower streets”, west of the trail in Sarasota. Featuring a new, 3 color clay tile roof and Mediterranean style design this home has timeless style combined with modern luxury. Upon entering the double doors of this one-story retreat, you will notice the open layout and quality appointments that abound with tray and coffered ceilings, custom built-ins and niches, gas fireplace, gorgeous and rare coquina stone floors. This 4 bedroom (one a custom designed office), 3 bath, 3-car garage home features a new island kitchen with custom and glass front cabinets, stainless steel appliances, decorative backsplash and beautiful quartz counters. The tranquil primary retreat overlooks the lanai and pool and features a walk-in closet with built in closet system, wood floors and an incredible ensuite bath. This newly renovated primary bath exudes luxury with custom cabinetry, upscale finishes, and features a walk-in shower for a spa-like experience. The split floor plan showcases two additional guest bedrooms (one with a custom Murphy bed and office) each with access to newly renovated bathrooms. The high ceilings and 3 sets of sliding glass doors flood the open floor plan with natural light, while custom finishes and soft contemporary décor create an atmosphere of effortless sophistication. The very private lanai with a screened pool, new pool heater, fiber optic lighting, Pebble tec finish, pool bath and outdoor shower is surrounded with lush vegetation, perfect for entertaining and outdoor relaxation. The paver driveway and side-entry 3 CAR garage adds additional built-in storage, a 2nd refrigerator and fabulous curb appeal. Within city limits, this residence offers the option of a part-time stay, allowing for potential short term rental income. When you want to enjoy the neighborhood, you are minutes away from downtown Sarasota’s cultural scene, Siesta Key Beach, Southside Village shops and restaurants. World-class health care is located steps away at Sarasota Memorial Hospital’s main campus. This home has it all -- a sanctuary feel AND all the amenities you desire at your fingertips.

1864 Goldenrod Street, Central Sarasota

Listing courtesy of BETTER HOMES AND GARDENS REAL ESTATE ATCHLEY PROPE. 941-556-9100
Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

Poinsettia Park - Central Sarasota Florida Homes for Sale

Search all homes for sale in Poinsettia Park, Central Sarasota Florida. View photos, prices, maps and more for Poinsettia Park in Central Sarasota FL.

Call or Text (239) 880-8873 to schedule a showing on any home in Poinsettia Park Today!