Willoughby Highlands Sub Homes for Sale - Willoughby, Ohio

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5209487 MLS

Welcome to 37518 ARLINGTON DR., a Spacious 4-Level Split in DESIRABLE SOUTH WILLOUGHBY. Recently updated with FRESH PAINT and NEW CARPET!! *Huge Family Room with Laminate flooring* *Updated Full Bath* *Vaulted Ceilings with exposed beams* *Eat In Kitchen with tons of Oak Cabinets* *Built in Buffet* *All Appliances* * Finished Lower Level with Bath* *Crawl space offering tons of storage* *2 Car Attached Garage with Nature Stone Flooring* *1.5 Garage addition with heat* *Huge, partially covered, 2-Tier Deck* *Pella Windows* *Full House Exhaust Fan* *Storage Shed* This home has been well maintained, schedule your showing today!

37518 Arlington Drive, Willoughby

Listing Courtesy of: Michael Kaim, kaimteam@gmail.com With Real of Ohio

Selling Office: Real of Ohio.

$250,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5144739 MLS

Welcome to this spacious ranch in the heart of beautiful Willoughby! This home boasts large rooms and generous storage throughout. All rooms feature hardwood floors that, with a little TLC, can truly shine. The living room, dining room, and kitchen flow seamlessly together, creating an inviting space for everyday living and entertaining. Enjoy the charm of a sunroom with a unique brick floor and views of the backyard. Car enthusiasts—or those in need of extra space for a workshop or hobbies—will appreciate the oversized garage with tandem additional rear garage space. The basement is impressively large, offering endless possibilities for recreation, storage, or finishing to suit your needs. All appliances remain, and for added peace of mind, the seller is including a one-year home warranty. Don’t miss the opportunity to make this ranch your own!

5018 Willoughcroft Road, Willoughby

Listing Courtesy of: Jody J Finucan, jodyfinucan@gmail.com With Platinum Real Estate

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realty.

$407,500

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5141745 MLS

Welcome to 4939 Shankland Rd in Willoughby, a classic Colonial offering 4 bedrooms, 3.5 baths, and 2,576 square feet of inviting living space on a peaceful half-acre lot. Set back from the road and framed by mature trees, this home blends timeless character with comfort in all the right places. Step inside to discover a spacious great room with vaulted ceilings and a striking floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace—the perfect backdrop for cozy evenings or weekend entertaining. A second fireplace adds charm to the formal dining room, setting the stage for holiday meals or quiet dinners at home. The kitchen offers ample space for cooking and gathering, and it flows seamlessly into a glass-enclosed three-season room overlooking the backyard, ideal for enjoying morning coffee or crisp fall evenings. Upstairs, four generously sized bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms provide plenty of space for everyone to spread out. The partially finished basement gives you flexible options for a playroom or hobby space—plus extra storage. Outside, an expansive deck extends your living space into the backyard, where towering trees offer privacy and shade. Whether you're hosting summer BBQs, relaxing under the stars, or letting pets and kids roam, the yard is full of potential. A side-entry two-car garage keeps the street view clean while adding extra functionality Conveniently located just minutes from schools, Lake Metroparks, and charming Downtown Willoughby, this home offers space to grow, room to gather, and a setting that feels just right.

4939 Shankland Road, Willoughby

Listing Courtesy of: Sean Stewart, sstewart@kw.com With Keller Williams Greater Cleveland Northeast

Selling Office: HomeSmart Real Estate Momentum LLC.

$390,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5074964 MLS

Welcome to 37550 Arlington Drive, a thoughtfully remodeled ranch located in the highly desirable Highland Estates neighborhood of Willoughby. Offering easy one-floor living, this home has been updated with modern features while maintaining a comfortable, welcoming atmosphere. The living room greets you with large windows that overlook the peaceful backyard, filling the space with natural light. The chef’s kitchen is designed for both function and style, with ample counter space, high-end appliances, and an open flow that makes it perfect for both casual meals and entertaining. Just off the kitchen, the family room offers a cozy space to relax by the fireplace, while the sunroom, located just beyond, is ideal for quiet mornings or unwinding after a long day. For those working from home, a dedicated office provides the perfect spot to stay productive. The primary bedroom is a true retreat, featuring a remodeled en suite bathroom with modern finishes. Two additional bedrooms and an updated full bathroom offer plenty of space for family or guests. Outside, a well-maintained garden sits on the side of the house, adding to the overall charm of the property. A two-car garage provides convenient storage and parking. With its prime location near shopping, schools, hospitals, and highways, this home combines modern updates with the convenience of nearby amenities. Move-in ready and designed for comfort, this home is not to be missed!

37550 Arlington Drive, Willoughby

Listing Courtesy of: Greg Marlowe, gregmarlowe@kw.com With Keller Williams Greater Cleveland Northeast

Selling Office: Keller Williams Living.

$337,500

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5049874 MLS

Fabulous Home ~ Well Maintained! Situated on .47 acre in beautiful Willoughby, Ohio. Offering 2204 sq. ft. of Living Space and featuring Hardwood floors, Vaulted Beam ceiling, Woodburning Fireplace and Custom Built-ins. Natural light filters through the large Picture window and Bay window in the spacious Living and Dining rooms. You'll Love the gorgeous Quartz countertops and Glass tile backsplash, a very convenient Coffee/Beverage Station and White cabinets in the Kitchen. The main floor also offers a spacious Full bathroom with Walk-in Shower and additional storage space. The upper level offers 3 nice sized Bedrooms with Hardwood floors, Custom Built-in, and Closet Organizer in the Primary Bedroom. The second Full Bathroom features Porcelain tile floor, Custom Subway tiles in the tub/shower, Quartz double sink vanity and Custom mirror. The lower level has more amazing space with tons of natural light, Porcelain woodgrain tile flooring and limitless options for use! The Laundry/utility room is conveniently located in the lower level as well. The Recreation/Family room is located off the Kitchen and features beautiful views and access to your Backyard Oasis with Stamped Concrete Patio(2022). This home offers Architectural character with Modern updates throughout. Other updates: New Driveway (2022) Stamped Concrete Patio(2022), HVAC (2018), Roof and Siding (2012), Windows/doors (2006). Well Maintained throughout! All appliances stay include; refrigerator, range, dishwasher, microwave as well as the washer, dryer and fridge in garage. Seller offering a 1 year Cinch Home Warranty. Don't Miss this One! Welcome Home!

4971 Shankland Road, Willoughby

Listing Courtesy of: Maureen D Brennan, mobrennanrealtor@gmail.com With HomeSmart Real Estate Momentum LLC

Selling Office: Howard Hanna.

$276,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5029787 MLS

Location, Location, Location! Walking distance to Downtown Willoughby. Welcome to the neighborhood! This 3 bed, 2 full and half bath is ready for you to make it your own. A Fully fenced yard is perfect for your pets or kids to play in. Additional shed out back for storage. Two areas for entertaining, a paver patio and a porch that has a ceiling fan. Sliding doors off the kitchen lead to the porch as well as the family room. Enjoy fires in the living room gas/wood fireplace that is open to the dining area. Three bedrooms, a full bath on the main level, the primary suit has an attached half bath. There are hardwood floors throughout the first floor of bedrooms, living room and dining area. All appliances stay with the sale of the home. The lower level has a designated work shop, a full bath, laundry area, a recreation area with a bar, the pool table can stay in the basement if buyers would like to keep it. The house has a whole house exhaust fan that removes heat quickly. Home is POS compliant.

37777 Harlow Drive, Willoughby

Listing Courtesy of: Yvonne M Leduc, yvonneleducrealtor@gmail.com With HomeSmart Real Estate Momentum LLC

Selling Office: Plum Tree Realty, LLC.

$295,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5028275 MLS

Spacious Ranch home in Willoughby close to Downtown Willoughby offers many features. Oversized Eat in Kitchen with Breakfast Bar, large Island, SS appliances, recessed lighting, ceramic flooring, backsplash, tons of counter space and white cabinetry with crown molding is open to the Dining Room with extra space to make a family room or sitting area. Ceramic flooring in the Foyer opens to the Living Room with Hardwood floors, ornate fireplace mantel accent, big picture window letting in natural light and a cute bump out currently set up for a dog oasis that can make a great space for a desk set up too. Spoil yourself with the Primary Bedroom en-suite featuring Hardwood flooring that continues into the walk in closet, Private Full bathroom with oversized Tiled shower, ceramic tiled flooring and large vanity. Three additional bedrooms all have Hardwood flooring and nice closet spaces close to the second Full bathroom. Plus a bonus half bathroom with lots of storage spaces and first floor laundry including washer and dryer. This could be removed to add a tub or shower too. Head downstairs for a second laundry set up, sump pump, B-Dry waterproofing system with warranty, a mass amount of storage options with shelving and options to finish off areas for more living spaces. Don't miss the bonus craft room with locking door, cabinets, counter spaces and peg walls. The outside has so much to offer too. From the huge sunroom with two sets of sliding doors to a large front deck, back deck with flower boxes and big fenced yard with firepit area and shed. This yard offers amazing outdoor space. Attached 2 car garage with opener, vinyl siding, and Central air. All of this sits on a triple lot in a wonderful location close to shopping, hospitals, city pool and parks.

37731 Arlington Drive, Willoughby

Listing Courtesy of: Jennifer L Allen, jennifer.allen@clevelandteam.com With Keller Williams Greater Cleveland Northeast

Selling Office: RE/MAX Results.

$190,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5013042 MLS

Welcome to 4854 Highland Dr., a cozy 2-bed, 1.5-bath bungalow situated on a double-lot in the heart of South Willoughby. This home features original hardwood floors, a fireplace, and crown molding for timeless charm. The brick exterior adds character, while the garden-like backyard offers a peaceful retreat. The home is ideal for a hands-on homeowner, and the partially finished basement provides creative potential for personal touches. Situated in a quiet neighborhood, this home is a short distance from parks, shopping, dining and much more—blending tranquility with convenience. Don't miss the chance to call this house your home.

4854 Highland Drive, Willoughby

Listing Courtesy of: Greg Marlowe, gregmarlowe@kw.com With Keller Williams Greater Cleveland Northeast

Selling Office: RE/MAX Innovations.

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

Willoughby Highlands Sub Homes for Sale - Willoughby, Ohio

Call or Text (614) 683-5116 to schedule a showing on any Willoughby Highlands Sub Willoughby, OH home for sale or to sell your Willoughby Highlands Sub Willoughby Ohio home!