West Salem Ohio Homes for Sale

1956 Homes for Sale - West Salem, Ohio

$6,500
5033592 MLS
Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

3241-3242 Madrona Court, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

$7,900
5033471 MLS
Lots on this listing have 2 separate addresses: 1313 Brandy Ln. & 1314 Maderia Dr. -- both lots are side by side -- see plot map. Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

1313 Brandy Lane, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

$6,000
5032037 MLS
Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

5119 Sangria Road, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

$255,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 5025924 MLS
Welcome to this renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home in the Cinnamon Lake community. Convenient, one-floor living is enhanced by updated surfaces and color palette, as well natural lighting throughout the home. As you enter through the cheerful front door, you are greeted by a comfortable family room, accented by a fireplace and built-ins. The adjacent kitchen boasts ample workspace and cabinets, a wine bar, range of lighting options, and stainless appliances. The spacious owner’s suite has an appealing accent wall and nice-sized closet and flows into the large bath with two sinks, storage options, and eye-catching flooring. A second generously-sized bedroom also has a sizable closet. Possibilities abound for a home office, craft room, or reading nook in the third bedroom. A second full bath is conveniently located in the middle of the home. The laundry room includes a sink and housing for utilities; it also provides access to the garage and the home’s exterior. The oversized garage also includes a bonus work area for those ongoing projects. Additional storage for lawn equipment and tools is available in the backyard shed. Relax on the front porch, entertain family and friends on the spacious deck, and enjoy gardening and outdoor activities in the yard. Amenities abound in the community, including a pool, tennis courts, lodge and, of course, the beautiful lake! See the attached list of home updates. One-year home warranty is provided. Make an appointment today!

1147 Laurel Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Stephen N Gates, StephenGates@KW.com With Keller Williams Elevate

Selling Office: RE/MAX Showcase.

$309,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 5026687 MLS
Very private w/beautiful trees, house sits far back from the road. Beautiful views of the lake from most windows. Enjoy looking at the lake while at the kitchen sink. Kitchen was remodeled w/new counters with oak trim, new appliances, new cooktop, oven, & refrigerator. Next to the kitchen is the dining area w/sliders to upper deck which gives a beautiful view of lake while dining. Master bath totally gutted, everything new w/beadboard walls, granite countertop & new fixtures. Lower level family room has a nice fireplace and sliding doors lead to a lower deck. There is a new metal roof and sump pump (2021) and several new windows (2015). There are steps down to the water and a boat dock. Amenities of a community pool, clubhouse, tennis courts and sand volleyball and of course the lake make this a great family neighborhood. Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake. Amenities include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge, a beach & swimming pool, basketball court, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked w/bass, walleye, saugeye, crappie, & bluegill to name a few!

5107 Sangria Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: Century 21 Carolyn Riley RL. Est. Srvcs, Inc..

$10,000
5024582 MLS
Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

6056-6057 Live Oak Court, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

$13,900
5023318 MLS
Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

1135-1136 Cinnamon Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

$5,000
5020930 MLS
Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

2148 Tarragon Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

$362,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 5008306 MLS
Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42. See supplements for improvements and what stays.

4100 Teak Place, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: Howard Hanna.

$316,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 4489051 MLS
Property is located on a 135 acre, private, well stocked Lake in Northern Ashland County. House has own private dock, open floor plan with a walk out partially finished basement with new luxury vinyl plank flooring. This 2088 sq ft plus 250 sq ft sunroom home was built in 1995. Enter right into a 2 story foyer with beautiful oak flooring. You will love the spacious kitchen with stunning oak cabinets, large island, granite countertops, large pantry with pull out shelves, new stainless steel appliances (frig, microwave, dishwasher). The 1st floor is warm & inviting with the oak flooring! This level of the home includes dining room, family room, living room, large master bedroom with walk in closet & full master bath, kitchen, laundry room & 1/2 bath. Beautiful sun room with plenty of windows off family room overlooking backyard & the lake. Upper floor has 2 spacious bedrooms with ceiling fans & a full bath. Basement is partially finished, ideal for entertaining, work out room or kids play area. Large storage room with built in shelves as well as heavy duty steel storage racking & an additional room with wood burning furnace. Home was converted to natural gas Sept 2016. Newly paved roads make Cinnamon Lake a very peaceful community featuring a pool, tennis & pickle-ball courts, basketball court & a playground. Lodge & pavilion rentals available. Pontoon boats, kayaking, paddle boards & sail boating all allowed on the lake! New roof installed August 2023.

1271 Tupelo Lane, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associate

Selling Office: Kelly Warren and Associates RE Solutions.

$350,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 4487556 MLS
Stunning property with large patio that sits on one of the largest lots in Cinnamon Lake with beautiful views of the lake. Kitchen with newer granite counter tops, glass tile backsplash and vinyl flooring. Fridge, stove, microwave, dishwasher and garbage disposal less than 4 yrs old. Downstairs bath has vinyl flooring, new vanity/sink/faucet, new lights and a new skirted toilet. Bath up has new vanity with stone top, new faucets and a new skirted toilet, all new lights. Most of the lighting in the house and outside has been replaced. Lennox furnace installed 5 years ago. Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

4145 Cedar Lane, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associate

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

$2,250
4481779 MLS
Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

1383 Saffron Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

1956 Homes for Sale - West Salem, Ohio

Call or Text (614) 683-5116 to schedule a showing on any 1956 West Salem, OH home for sale or to sell your 1956 West Salem Ohio home!