Eustis Florida Multi-Family for Sale

Fully remodeled in 2026, this 4-unit quadraplex offers turnkey investment appeal with extensive updates throughout. The front building features a new roof, all new windows, fresh interior and exterior paint, and upgraded electric and plumbing. The back building includes new exterior paint, select new windows, a new white vinyl privacy fence, and modernized interiors. Units showcase a blend of beautifully restored hardwood floors, new luxury vinyl plank flooring, updated kitchens and baths, and new window A/C units with heat in select spaces. A well-executed renovation delivering strong rental potential and long-term durability. Broker/Owner.

19 W Pendleton Avenue, Eustis

Listing courtesy of LEGACY REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT. 352-267-7758

* 202 W Idlewild Ave & 506 Fahnstock St, Eustis

$595,000

6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ O6433064 MLS

Excellent investment opportunity featuring two newer-construction single-family homes, both currently tenant-occupied and producing immediate rental income. Please do not disturb the tenants. The first home was built in 2022 and is currently leased for $2,400 per month, with the lease expiring August 31, 2026. The second home was built in 2023 and is currently leased for $2,430 per month, with the lease expiring July 31, 2026. Both tenants have occupied their respective homes since construction was completed, providing a strong history of long-term occupancy. The homes feature attractive modern finishes, including wood-look tile flooring, quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, tray ceilings, and spacious open-concept living areas. These newer homes combine stylish design with durable, low-maintenance finishes that appeal to both tenants and investors. Together, the properties generate $4,830 per month in gross rental income, or $57,960 annually at the current lease rates. The seller prefers to sell both properties together as a package, offering an excellent opportunity to acquire two stabilized rentals at once, but may consider selling the homes individually. With newer construction, established tenants, similar finishes and locations, and upcoming lease flexibility, this is an attractive opportunity for an investor seeking dependable rental income with long-term upside.

* 202 W Idlewild Ave & 506 Fahnstock St, Eustis

Listing courtesy of SIM REI. 352-508-5870

$939,800

13 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths ⋅ G5117528 MLS

ATTENTION INVESTORS: (2) QUAD-PLEX BUILDINGS FOR SALE, (8) APARTMENT UNITS + (4) STORAGE UNITS PROVIDING $97,000.00+ IN ANNUAL CASH FLOW, EUSTIS, FL 32726. Located at 422 & 426 E. Citrus Avenue in the historic district of Eustis and just (3) Blocks from downtown. This is a "turnkey" investment opportunity, 100% occupancy, annual tenants, and provides a blended 6.925% CAP-RATE. These two separate quadplex buildings sit on .62 acres (115'x 232') with "NO HOA" and includes a combined heated 5,203 s/f and total size of 5,797 s/f. Both building are on City of Eustis water & sewer services. Building 422 Profile: (3-qty) 1-Bedroom, 1-Bath and (1-qty) 2-Bedroom, 1-BathUnits. All units were fully remodeled and updated in 2018. Building 426 Profile: (4-qty) 2-Bedroom, 1-Bath Units. All units were fully remodeled and updated in 2019. Building 426 also has a detached (4-qty) Rental Storage Units with Roll-Up Doors that also generate cash flow to the property. All units have (2) dedicated parking spaces each. Additionally, the property is located within close proximity & walking distance to Downtown Eustis & Bay Street, Lake Eustis lakefront, lots of restaurants, shops, city parks & just 5-minutes to the Lake County Mall, Target, Walmart, etc. and a variety of other conveniences for the tenants and their guests. Floor Plans & Seller Disclosures for each building & units are attached in the MLS, or available to be emailed. Detailed financials available to "Qualified Buyers" and includes full Unit Profiles, Upgrades/Improvements/Maintenance Info, Current & Past Income History, Expense Breakdown, Rental Comps Analysis for 1/1 & 2/1 rentals in the entire Eustis market. PLEASE DO NOT ENGAGE OR DISTURBANY OF THE TENANTS. NO SIGN at the property and all inquiries are to be directed "ONLY" to the Listing Broker. For reference, the purchase price includes the following properties: 422 E. Citrus Ave, Parcel ID#11-19-20-0100-076-00401, Alt Key#1759641 "and" 426 E. Citrus Ave, ParcelID#11-19-26-0100-076-00403, Alt. Key#1243122. Call directly for more information.

422 & 426 E Citrus Avenue, Eustis

Listing courtesy of ROCK SPRINGS REALTY, LLC. 877-333-2811

$460,000

6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ O6438450 MLS

Discover exceptional modern living in this brand-new duplex located at 525 Pine Lane in Eustis, Florida. Each spacious unit features 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, offering a comfortable and functional layout perfect for homeowners or investors seeking strong rental potential

525-527 Pine Lane, Eustis

Listing courtesy of YOUNG REAL ESTATE. 407-904-0069

$1,200,000

G5116967 MLS

Pre-Construction. To be built. 48 Unit Apartment Community - Fully Entitled - All Permits in hand including City Approvals, SJRWMD Permit, DEP Water & Wastewater Permits, Site Work Permit, a Water/Sewer Impact Fee Waiver, and Approved Signed Engineered Construction Plans. This 4.1 acres is adjacent to the Publix Supermarket at Woodland Center in Eustis, FL. This Pubix is scheduled to be torn down starting December 26, 2026 and rebuilt. The current site plan includes (2) 24 Unit 3-Story Buildings for a total of 48 units.

1925 County Road 19a, Eustis

Listing courtesy of EXPERT REAL ESTATE ADVISORS. 352-577-5201

$469,900

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ G5108016 MLS

"NEW PRICE"- ATTENTION LANDLORDS & INVESTORS: QUAD-PLEX APARTMENT BUILDING FOR SALE IN EUSTIS, FL 32726. Located in the historic district of Eustis and just (3) Blocks from downtown. Currently delivering a 7.03% CAP Rate with Additional Revenue Potential. $47,220.00 Gross Revenue. $33,049.00 Net Operating Income. This "TURNKEY" investment opportunity is 100% Occupied and All Tenants are on Annual Leases. No "HOA". City of Eustis water & sewer. Unit Profile: Living/Dining Rooms, Full Kitchen, Full Bathroom, Primary Bedroom, Bonus/Bedroom#2, Rear Porch. (2) Dedicated Parking Spaces per unit. All units are in good operating condition! The property is located within close proximity & walking distance to Downtown Eustis & Bay Street, Lake Eustis lakefront, lots of restaurants, shops, city parks & just 5-minutes to the Lake County Mall, Target, Walmart, etc. and a variety of other conveniences for the tenants and their guests. PLEASE DO NOT ENGAGE OR DISTURB TENANTS. NO SIGN at the property and all inquiries are to be directed to the Listing Agent only. FULL FINANCIALS, PROPERTY PROFILE, RENT ROLLS, EXPENSES, FLOOR PLAN, SURVEY, ETC., ARE AVAILABLE TO QUALIFIED BUYERS.

422 E Citrus Avenue, Eustis

Listing courtesy of ROCK SPRINGS REALTY, LLC. 877-333-2811

$469,900

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ G5107267 MLS

"NEW PRICE"- ATTENTION LANDLORDS & INVESTORS: QUAD-PLEX APARTMENT BUILDING, PLUS (4) STORAGE RENTAL UNITS FOR SALE IN EUSTIS, FL 32726. Located in the historic district of Eustis and just (3) Blocks from downtown. Currently delivering a 6.82% CAP Rate with Additional Revenue Potential. This "TURNKEY" investment opportunity is 100% Occupied and All Tenants are on Annual Leases. No "HOA". City of Eustis water & sewer. Unit Profile: Living/Dining Rooms, Full Kitchen, Full Bathroom, Primary Bedroom, Bonus/Bedroom#2, Rear Porch. (2) Dedicated Parking Spaces. All units were fully remodeled and updated in 2019. The property also includes a detached (4-unit) rental storage building with roll-up doors that generates $500.00 in monthly income. The property is located within close proximity & walking distance to Downtown Eustis & Bay Street, Lake Eustis lakefront, lots of restaurants, shops, city parks & just 5-minutes to the Lake County Mall, Target, Walmart, etc. and a variety of other conveniences for the tenants and their guests. PLEASE DO NOT ENGAGE OR DISTURB TENANTS. NO SIGN at the property and all inquiries are to be directed to the Listing Agent. ALSO, the Quad-Plex next door is also listed for sale (422 E. Citrus Ave.), see MLS#G5108332.

426 E Citrus Avenue, Eustis

Listing courtesy of ROCK SPRINGS REALTY, LLC. 877-333-2811

$299,900

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ O6376518 MLS

Income-Producing Duplex in Eustis! Excellent investment opportunity with strong cash flow history. This well-located duplex at 206 Osceola Ave can generate approximately $3,000 in gross monthly rental income. The property offers two units with a total of 5 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, providing stable rental demand and efficient management under one roof. Conveniently located near downtown Eustis, shopping, schools, and local amenities. Ideal for investors seeking immediate income in a growing Lake County market.

206 Osceola Avenue, Eustis

Listing courtesy of RLW REALTY. 352-771-2560

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

Eustis Florida Multi-Family

Search all Multi-Family in Eustis Florida. These Eustis Multi-Family property details include large photos, local school info, tours, maps, street view and more in Eustis FL.

Call or Text (239) 880-8873 to schedule a showing on any Eustis Florida Multi-Family Today!