Sumterville Florida Homes for Sale

Sumterville Florida Homes for Sale

$689,000
3 Beds 2 Baths G5116100 MLS
Step back in time to a piece of Old Florida paradise without sacrificing modern comfort. Built in 1875 and set on 4.8 picturesque acres, this one-of-a-kind historic farmhouse has been extensively and immaculately renovated while thoughtfully preserving the character, warmth and craftsmanship that make a home of this era so special. The three-bedroom, two-bath residence is filled with distinctive details you simply won't find in a new home. Warm wood floors, cypress beams and shelving, abundant natural light and carefully selected finishes complement the home's historic architecture. At the heart of the home is a truly unique farmhouse kitchen featuring custom cabinetry, soapstone countertops, an apron-front sink, new appliances and stove hood, and an extraordinary 1800s kitchen island originally from an old store in Patterson, North Carolina. Throughout the home, old and new have been blended with remarkable attention to detail, creating spaces that feel authentic, comfortable and completely at home in their surroundings. While the historic charm remains, extensive improvements have brought the property into the modern era. Updates include new electrical, new HVAC, new roof, Hardie Board siding, new wood flooring and subfloors, resurfaced ceilings, updated drain field, new appliances and numerous additional improvements. Outside, the transformation continues with a new asphalt driveway, new landscaping and patios, a rebuilt front porch and a solar-powered entrance gate. The 4.8-acre property is designed for those ready to enjoy the country lifestyle from day one. Two fenced and cross-fenced pastures, along with a separate dry lot, provide flexibility for horses and other livestock. The impressive 30' x 38' center-aisle barn features three stalls and has electrical service, while a separate 15' x 40' workshop with dedicated lawn-equipment room, an 11' x 14' garden shed and covered parking provide exceptional space for equipment, projects and storage. Mature, centuries-old live oaks create the unmistakable atmosphere of Old Florida, while established landscaping, patios and fruit trees—including mulberry, plum, peach, guava and apple—add to the property's charm and self-sufficient appeal. Whether your dream is horses, a hobby farm, homesteading or simply having room to breathe, this is a rare opportunity to own a turn-key historic Florida homestead where much of the hard work has already been done. From the beautifully renovated 1875 farmhouse to the barn, pastures, workshop and gardens, every part of the property contributes to a lifestyle that would be difficult to recreate today. Historic character. Modern comfort. Nearly five acres of Old Florida. This is not simply a home—it's a property with a story and a lifestyle all its own.

2242 Cr 543, Sumterville

$260,000
3 Beds 2 Baths G5116297 MLS
Welcome home to this like-new concrete block and stucco residence, offering 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a 2-car garage in a quiet, welcoming neighborhood designed for comfortable living at any stage of life. Step inside to an inviting open-concept floor plan featuring high ceilings, abundant natural light, and a versatile combination of ceramic tile and carpet flooring. The spacious great room creates an ideal setting for everyday living and entertaining. The well-appointed kitchen offers plenty of cabinetry for storage, granite countertops, a convenient breakfast bar/island, and a stainless-steel appliance package. The adjacent dining area features glass sliding doors leading to the covered rear patio, creating an effortless connection between indoor and outdoor living. The spacious primary suite provides a relaxing private retreat, complete with a walk-in closet and an ensuite bathroom featuring a quartz-topped vanity, additional cabinetry, and a walk-in shower. Two generously sized guest bedrooms provide plenty of room for family, guests, a home office, or hobbies. The front bedroom features double-door entry, adding flexibility and style. The guest bathroom is thoughtfully appointed with a quartz-topped vanity, additional cabinetry, and a convenient tub/shower combination. An indoor laundry room is conveniently located within the home, while the spacious two-car garage offers an automatic door opener and plenty of room for vehicles and storage. Outside, the open backyard provides a wonderful blank canvas for entertaining, gardening, outdoor activities, or creating your own private retreat. With its newer construction, desirable open floor plan, quality finishes, and peaceful neighborhood setting, this move-in-ready home is ready for its next owner. Schedule your private preview today and discover everything this beautiful home has to offer! This newer scenic Sumter County community boasts a tranquil location, with quick access to I-75 and U.S. 301, outdoor recreation, and exciting local activities such as the Teaching Zoo, Dade Battlefield State Park, Cypress House Ranch, and Lake Townsend Regional Park.

1565 Texas Avenue, Sumterville

$895,000
3 Beds 2 Baths OM729236 MLS
Experience the perfect blend of modern farmhouse living and country charm on this beautiful 11-acre property, ideally located just minutes from The Villages and The Villages Charter School. Built in 2019, this custom 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers quality finishes, an open-concept design, and endless possibilities for horse enthusiasts or anyone seeking room to roam. Inside, you’ll find vaulted ceilings, luxury vinyl plank flooring, and a desirable split-bedroom floor plan. The spacious kitchen is the heart of the home, featuring granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, abundant cabinetry, and a large island overlooking the living and dining areas simply perfect for entertaining or everyday living. The generous primary suite serves as a private retreat with a spacious en-suite bath and two oversized walk-in closets. French doors lead to the covered back patio, where you’ll enjoy peaceful views of open pasture and majestic oak trees that create the perfect backdrop for Florida country living. The home is also pre-wired for a generator hookup for added peace of mind. Designed with both beauty and function in mind, the property is fully fenced and cross-fenced with quality no-climb wire and top-board fencing. The open acreage provides an ideal location for your dream barn, riding arena, additional paddocks, or workshop, allowing you to create the equestrian property you’ve always envisioned. Tucked away on a quiet, paved dead-end road, this private retreat offers the serenity of country living while remaining only 10 minutes from the shopping, dining, healthcare, and everyday conveniences of The Villages. Whether you’re bringing horses, starting a hobby farm, or simply looking for wide-open spaces to call home, this exceptional property is ready to make your vision a reality.

1539 Se 34th Way, Sumterville

$975,000
3 Beds 3 Baths TB8513033 MLS
Welcome to Magnolia Manor! This 10 acre ranch has it all. Almost 3,000 square feet of living space in the main house, over 1,000 square feet of living space in the mother-in-law suite, Pool, HUGE metal building with concrete floor, center aisle horse barn AND separate stables. Main house offers 3 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms with vaulted ceilings. The split bedroom plan offers more than convenience. Master bedroom has tray ceiling and French doors leading to the pool enclosure. The en suite has dual walk-in closets, plus a linen closet, dual vanities, soaker tub, water closet and walk in shower. Second bathroom connects the pool and 2nd bedroom. 3rd bedroom has its own en suite. Living room includes beautiful gas fireplace and overlooks the pool and your new ranch. Den/Office offers great built-in desk and cabinetry. Formal dining room and breakfast nook surround the showstopper kitchen. This is a space you’ll love to be in. Breakfast bar, pantry with pull out drawers, lots of cabinets, island and super cool range hood. Oversized garage has a spiral staircase that leads to another room…could be storage, game room or just a little hideaway spot. Pool area is large enough for lots of friends and family to enjoy with a separate concrete slab to the side. The heated spa overflows into the massive pool. Mother-in-law suite has its own 1 car garage, laundry hook up and screened in front porch. Kitchen is generous in size, has room for large table, and has one of the coolest pantry doors you’ll ever see. Back to the farm…HUGE metal building has 2 lean to storage areas that run the length of the building. Little red horse barn has 4 stalls and 10 ft overhang, there are 5 grazing pastures, and all have water. The center aisle horse barn has 5 stalls, feed/tack room, and separate washing station. More valuable features include whole house Generac generator, roof replaced in 2019, a/c replaced in 2020, water heater 2019, irrigation system, and more that you just have to see!

2223 Cr 543, Sumterville

$280,000
3 Beds 2 Baths OM723884 MLS
PRIME LOCATION very close to The Villages Charter School. Enjoy all the perks of living just outside The Villages and Middleton, without the cost! Practically new and thoughtfully enhanced, this 2025-built home offers the rare advantage of new construction quality without the added expense, time, and effort of completing upgrades yourself. Located in the desirable Sumter Villas community, residents enjoy a low HOA, community pool, and sidewalks—all without the burden of a CDD, keeping monthly costs more affordable than other nearby neighborhoods. Built by Ryan Homes and no longer available new in this community, this Mahogany model is rated as "above average" quality in county record and sits on a larger homesite with a peaceful retention pond view and a uniquely private backyard—fully enclosed with a 6-ft vinyl fence and bordered by single-story homes with no rear neighbors. This home is in pristine condition with significant improvements—upgrades that new construction typically leaves to the buyer. Exterior improvements including the fence, a screened lanai with patio lighting, 'permanent' outdoor lighting, custom stepping stone walkway along driveway, manicured landscaping, and rain gutters. Inside, the home features a warm, neutral design with abundant natural light and a cohesive, upgraded finish throughout. Tile flooring spans the entire house, complemented by added recessed lighting in the main living space, upgraded fixtures, and fan kits in all major spaces. The kitchen showcases staggered cabinetry with custom hardware, granite countertops, and a clean, modern layout. Both bathrooms are elevated with quartz counters, square sinks, custom hardware, and a custom glass shower door in the primary suite. Additional enhancements include window treatments, an insulated garage door, and a finished garage with painted walls—details that further separate this home from standard builder-grade offerings. Ideally located just minutes from The Villages and Middleton, this home provides convenient proximity to top-rated charter schools, expanding employment opportunities, shopping, dining, and medical facilities. With continued growth in the surrounding area, this location offers both immediate lifestyle benefits and long-term appeal. Skip the build process and move right into a well built home where the upgrades are already complete and the value is clear.

2133 Tennessee Street, Sumterville

$255,000
3 Beds 2 Baths O6374739 MLS
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Investors wanted! Like-New Living, Smart Location, Big Lifestyle Appeal. Handing you an income producing property on a golden platter. Step into effortless Florida living in this like-new 3-bedroom, 2-bath home built in 2024, where modern style meets everyday comfort. With an open, airy floor plan, this home was made for entertaining—whether you’re hosting friends, family, or future tenants. The thoughtfully designed layout features a private primary suite with en-suite bath, while all bedrooms offer walk-in closets, giving everyone the space they crave. Ceiling fans add comfort and efficiency, and the whole-house water purification system brings peace of mind from day one. Outside, the newly added fence creates the perfect spot for pets, play, or relaxing evenings under the stars. Located in a quiet, up-and-coming community, you’ll enjoy a resort-style community pool and the excitement of watching the neighborhood grow—without the congestion of an established area. Best of all, you’re minutes from all the fun, dining, and entertainment of The Villages, close enough to enjoy it all, yet far enough away to truly unwind at home. With easy access throughout Central Florida, this home is a fantastic opportunity for first-time buyers, seasonal residents, or savvy investors looking for a low-maintenance, move-in-ready property in a high-demand area. New. Stylish. Smartly located. This is your chance to get in early and make it yours—schedule your showing today before this opportunity passes you by.

2059 Kentucky Road, Sumterville

$3,000,000
OM696078 MLS
Seize this rare opportunity to acquire a prime parcel of vacant commercial land, ideally located near the signalized intersection of, Hwy 301 and Hwy 470, just minutes from the newly expanding town of Middleton, Florida – a vibrant part of The Villages community. This strategically positioned 5.5 acres sits between I-75 and the Florida Turnpike, offering exceptional accessibility and visibility for businesses seeking a high-traffic location. With utilities to the site, this property is primed for immediate development with Heavy Commercial Land Use. The 20 acres abutting the property will be home to the new Sumter County Municipal complex and headquarters including the clerk of the court offices and new state of the art fire training center. Development is currently underway. Situated on Hwy 470, which is set for widening, it makes access and visibility even more desirable for this property. Located just 3 mile from Middleton, a community within The Villages, the largest and top selling residential communities in the country. Whether you're looking to parcel out for retail, commercial, or mixed-use development, the potential is limitless. Capitalize on the rapid growth of the surrounding area and establish your footprint in one of Florida's most sought-after communities. Don’t miss out on this once-in-a-lifetime chance to secure a prime commercial location with unparalleled exposure, right in the heart of a bustling, growing area. See adjoining property listed OM695931

TBD 470 Highway, Sumterville

$8,500,000
OM695931 MLS
Seize this rare opportunity to acquire a prime parcel of vacant commercial land, ideally located at a signalized hard corner on two major roads, Hwy 301 and Hwy 470, just minutes from the newly expanding town of Middleton, Florida – a vibrant part of The Villages community. This strategically positioned 13 acres sits between I-75 and the Florida Turnpike, offering exceptional accessibility and visibility for businesses seeking a high-traffic location. With utilities to the site, this property is primed for immediate development with Heavy Commercial Land Use. The 20 acres abutting the property will be home to the new Sumter County Municipal complex and headquarters including the clerk of the court offices and new state of the art fire training center. Development is currently underway. Situated on Hwy 301, which is set for realignment and widening from Hwy 470 to CR 525E (Industrial Park Drive), makes access and visibility even more desirable for this property. Located just 3 mile from Middleton, a community within The Villages, the largest and top selling residential communities in the country. Whether you're looking to parcel out for retail, commercial, or mixed-use development, the potential is limitless. Capitalize on the rapid growth of the surrounding area and establish your footprint in one of Florida's most sought-after communities. Don’t miss out on this once-in-a-lifetime chance to secure a prime commercial location with unparalleled exposure, right in the heart of a bustling, growing area. See adjoining property listed OM696078

178 N Us 301, Sumterville

$1,000,000
G5085701 MLS
One day you will say I wish I would have. The plans are set. The roads are laid out. The proverbial tea leaves have been read and all signs lead to future development and positioning. THIS SPOT will undoubtedly look very different one day. When?? That we don’t know but it will. We like to call this one a homestead with a vision…a vision of future development that is. The sunsets are pretty spectacular also. There is currently a 4 bedroom, 2 bathroom, block home with a lifetime metal roof that was built in 2017. Sitting comfortably at 1881 square feet this home can generate some rental income for you while you wait for development to come to your doorstep. Location matters. Future land use has been identified to CMPUD, however I think we can all agree this particular section of land might be a little more exciting than that. Inside The City of Bushnell’s joint planning agreement area and directly across the street from Wildwood city limits and land owned by The Villages, your guess is as good as ours but we have a pretty good hunch this terrain will look a little different. Future roads maps show Bexley Trail what appears to be directly across the street. Sitting on 10 acres. Approximately 465 feet of frontage on SR 471 and 935 feet deep. Live here, have a few cows and wait. Rent it out and wait. As they say….all good things come to those who wait. Buy and wait that is. Current fence lines are not all on the property lines as this is all a part of a larger family plot. Additional acreage avaible. Call today for details and prices.

3422 Sr 471, Sumterville

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

Sumterville Florida Homes for Sale

Are you looking to buy or sell a home in Sumterville Florida? Call or Text (239) 880-8850 to schedule a showing on any Sumterville, FL home for sale or to sell your Sumterville Florida home! As Realtors specializing in the Sumterville area, we can take care of all of your Sumterville FL real estate needs including buying pre-existing homes, new construction homes, condominiums, land, commercial and multi-family homes in Sumterville Florida. We can also help you find distressed properties in Sumterville including HUD Homes, Short Sales and REO Bank Foreclosures. If you need help financing a home in Sumterville, we have access to some of the best lenders that service the Sumterville Florida area, including lenders that offer credit repair to buy a home and work with home builders in and near the Sumterville area to help you build your home while building up your credit. If you are going to buy or sell a home in Sumterville Florida, then be sure to Call or Text (239) 880-8850 Today! We are a real estate team specializing in the Sumterville, FL area! Displayed are homes for sale in Sumterville, FL, a city located in Florida. These Sumterville Listings are updated every 15 minutes from the Sumterville MLS.