Refine Search
Sort by
$499,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 225044089 MLS
This stunning 2022 Craftsman ranch first-tier property delivers the effortless lifestyle. Set on a rare .62-acre double lot, the property offers exceptional outdoor space for entertaining, recreation, gatherings, and evenings by the fire pit. Designed for easy, single-story living, the home features an open and spacious floor plan with 9-foot ceilings, abundant natural light, and a seamless flow between living, dining, and kitchen spaces. The electric fireplace adds warmth and character to the great room. The large primary bedroom is privately positioned on its own side of the floor plan and includes a generous walk-in closet and ensuite bath--creating a peaceful retreat separate from the home's additional bedrooms. Built for comfort and efficiency, the property offers natural gas for the furnace and stove/oven (with built-in air fryer), plus the added peace of mind of a whole-house generator. A full basement with an egress window and a completed bathroom provides tremendous potential for future living space or storage. A dedicated laundry and mudroom adds convenience to daily life, and all appliances--including the washer and dryer--are included, ensuring an easy transition for the next owner. Located inside one of Ohio's most desirable gated communities, residents enjoy 24-hour security and an unmatched outdoor lifestyle. Candlewood Lake offers two pools, tennis, pickleball, lakeside lodge, playgrounds, nature trails, a marina, and a year-round calendar of community events. Whether you prefer an active lifestyle or peaceful retreat, this community offers both. With an incredible location, Craftsman architecture, a large single-floor footprint, and extra land for privacy and outdoor living, this home represents the perfect blend of comfort, space, recreation, and serenity. Whether full-time or part-time, it delivers the heart-of-the-lake lifestyle so many dream of--yet rarely find this close to the water. (At least 2 photos have been digitally enhanced.)

7326 State Route 19 Unit 9, Lots 220 & 221 Unit Unit 9, Lots 220 & 221, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Anthony Glen Reed ---- LakefrontLivingRealty-LakeTeam

$107,000
4 Beds 1 Baths 225043870 MLS
Overflowing with character and early-century craftsmanship, this spacious 2-story home is the perfect opportunity for buyers seeking charm, space, and incredible potential. An inviting covered front porch welcomes you inside to generous living areas highlighted by original woodwork, timeless trim, built-ins, and a striking stone fireplace. The formal dining room offers warm natural light, while the functional kitchen layout is ready for your vision. With 4 bedrooms—two on the main level and two upstairs—plus 1,924 sq ft of living space, this home provides flexibility for a variety of lifestyles. A full basement and detached garage add valuable storage and utility, and the property's classic architecture makes it an ideal candidate for a flip or a rewarding renovation. Don't miss your chance to bring this beautiful home back to life—schedule your showing today!

125 E Marion Street, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Stacey J Wampler ---- Sluss Realty Company

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Realty.

$679,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 225043227 MLS
Amazing Lake Front View of beautiful Candlewood Lake from this log home that has a gradual sloping back yard to a recently built boat dock with lift. This Lake Front home rests directly across the lake from beautiful Harmon Lodge and the pool, tennis courts, and basketball courts. This 4 bedroom home has beautiful hardwood floors on the main living area and 3 skylights to allow the sun to shine in. Newer metal roof and newer shed along with a large wrap around deck that overlooks the lake. Large stone front fireplace in main living area. Seller has added additional new cabinets and the kitchen island will remain along with the quality cook stove and all kitchen appliances. Lower level has a walkout basement family room to a large concrete patio. Exterior of home was recently stained in September of this year. Enjoy sitting in your main living area with large cathedral ceilings and skylights while watching a fire in your large stone fireplace, and watching a football game on the TV, while looking out the all glass front of your living room overlooking the lake.

7326 State Route 19 Unit 9 Lot 281 Unit Unit 9 Lot 281, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Rick Roe ---- Real Estate Showcase, RES

Selling Office: Century 21 Excellence Realty.

$209,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 225042423 MLS
Welcome home to this charming and well-maintained 3-bedroom, 2-full-bath two-story home in the heart of Mt. Gilead. This move-in-ready property features new flooring, fresh interior paint, and a beautifully remodeled upstairs full bath. Enjoy the bonus of a bright and inviting 3-season room—ideal for morning coffee or relaxing evenings—and a fully fenced backyard that provides privacy and space for pets, play, or entertaining. All appliances stay including a brand new washer & dryer and hot water heater. This home also has a concrete driveway and beautiful stamped walkway. Located in town, you'll love being just moments away from local shops, restaurants, and the many beloved events and festivals that make Mt. Gilead such a vibrant community. This is a wonderful opportunity to own a delightful home with modern updates in an ideal location. Seller is offering a home warranty as well. Schedule your showing and come see for yourself!

209 W Marion Street, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Erin C Kelty ---- e-Merge Real Estate Champions

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Realty.

$420,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 225041288 MLS
Own a piece of serene countryside with this 3 bed, 2 bath ranch home, 30x40 horse barn, fenced-in pasture w/ pond access, all on 6.9 acres! Newer roof and siding ensure peace of mind for years to come. Too many updates to include! Some of the recent highlights: new carpet, kitchen counters/backsplash and a new hot water tank installed all within the last year. The attached garage was tastefully converted to extra living space, making the interior a total of 1,920 SF. Has potential to be made into a mother in law suite or rental space. Pole barn has a couple horse stalls and is equipped with electric/water. Conveniently located in Northmor school district, close to town amenities, minutes from Mount Gilead and Lexington. Don't miss out on this rare find for hobby farmers, equestrians, or anyone seeking elbow room, schedule your private tour today!

6351 US Highway 42, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Jeff Stuttler ---- e-Merge Real Estate Champions

Selling Office: NON MEMBER OFFICE.

$19,000
225040998 MLS Candlewood Lake BLDG.
Discover the perfect place to build your getaway or forever home inside the sought-after Candlewood Lake gated community. This spacious 0.46-acre property (two side-by-side 0.23-acre lots) sits near the end of a quiet cul-de-sac, offering privacy, wooded charm, and close proximity to the water. Candlewood Lake is known for its peaceful atmosphere--never overcrowded--while still offering fantastic amenities for year-round enjoyment. Residents enjoy a private lake, community pool, beach areas, clubhouse, tennis and pickleball, playgrounds, and plenty of space to slow down and reconnect with nature. Golf carts are welcome, making it easy to cruise to the water or spend the day on the lake. With available utilities and a low-maintenance lifestyle, this is the ideal spot to build your dream lake home, vacation retreat, or investment property. All of this is offered with a $161/month HOA that maintains the security, roads, and amenities that make Candlewood Lake so special. Enjoy lake living, small-community charm, and the quiet you've been looking for -- all just a short drive from Columbus.

210 Candlewood 210, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Kate E Shulaw ---- Keller Williams Greater Cols

$1,450,000
225040906 MLS
FANTASTIC OPPORTUNITY for anyone wanting Hobby Farm or POTENTIAL for HOME DEVELOPER! Very Nice Well Built 1 1/2 Story Home W/ 1st Floor Master Suite W/ Double Closets, Full Bath and Laundry Utility. Lots of Beautiful Natural Wood Doors, Trim and Flooring Throughout. Open Kitchen W/ Conventional Electric Oven-Range + Functional Wood Fired Cooking Range like Amish might use! Spacious 2nd Floor W/ 2 additional Bedrooms and 2nd Full Bath. Also, Lots of extra Floored Attic Storage. Ground Level Walk-out has additional Possibilities W/ some Partially Finished Rooms and Oversized 1 Car Garage. Several Outbuilding including 30 x 100, a 50 x 36 Pole Barn, a 30 x 30 Shop (old Grain Storage) and a 27 x 25 Garage ( Attached to Barn) W/ 8000 # rated Car Lift Rack. (Sq. Ft. per Auditor Information, to be verified by purchaser) S/A Taxes include 3 Parcels 3 separate Parcels Totaling 76.39 Acres (+ or -) and Approximately 1820 Feet Road Frontage. Availability of Water & Sewer Must Be Verified by purchasers doing own due diligence) The population growth rate for Morrow County falls into the upper third of all Ohio counties. For a primarily rural county, this rate of expansion is well above average and driven by the area's proximity to Columbus, one of the fastest-growing metro regions in the Midwest. Just 40 miles north of Columbus, Mount Gilead is strategically positioned between the Columbus and Mansfield markets. The area offers convenient access to I-71, providing a direct connection to Columbus, Cleveland, and Cincinnati markets while maintaining a quiet rural character.

4926 US Highway 42, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Jeffrey E Horne ---- Coldwell Banker Heritage

$240,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 225040430 MLS
Beautifully Restored Victorian Home in the Heart of Mount Gilead! Less than 35 minutes from Polaris! Step into timeless elegance with this beautifully restored Victorian home. Offering 1962 sq. ft. of living space, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath residence has undergone an extensive transformation in recent years-preserving its original character while incorporating quality updates throughout. You'll fall in love with the stunning original woodwork, trim, & doors, complimented by modern touches like sliding barn doors and fresh paint throughout. A spacious kitchen features Amish custom cabinetry, SS Whirlpool appliances, and vintage porcelain tile that enhances its historic charm. The original dual butler's pantry offers both functionality & style, perfect for entertaining or extra storage. The entry/foyer has new windows, and is a showstopper entrance from the covered front porch with original stone pillars. Large living room area, formal dining room, and 1st floor bedroom, laundry, and full bath. Upstairs, the oversized bedrooms and open loft area provide plenty of room to relax. Mechanical updates bring peace of mind--new HVAC, furnace, central air & ductwork (2020), full electrical upgrade with new panel (2020), and new concrete front and rear sidewalks and steps (2024). Additional improvements include a new roof on the back porch & flat roof (2023), new glass block windows in basement, and new front foyer windows (2022). Enjoy the outdoors from the expansive covered back porch, that leads into the mud room or bonus space. Situated in the Village of Mt Gilead, you'll appreciate the easy access to city amenities while enjoying the character & warmth of a historic home. A true move-in ready gem--full of charm, space, and thoughtful updates!

251 Lincoln Avenue, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Cheyenne A Peck ---- Howard Hanna - Main Office

Selling Office: Red 1 Realty.

$270,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 225040238 MLS
Welcome home to the country! This beautiful brick ranch is move in ready! Sitting on 2.21 acres with mature trees and a spacious detached garage that could be used as a hobby shop or office. Inside you will find 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and a lovely layout that combines space, comfort and convenience. The family room is highlighted with a fireplace and lots of natural light. The metal roof is only 5 years old adding peace of mind for years to come. Located within the well-regarded Northmor Local School District, the home offers a great setting for both students and adults seeking a quieter lifestyle while still being part of a strong community. Schedule your showing today.

6713 US Highway 42, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Erin C Kelty ---- e-Merge Real Estate Champions

Selling Office: Key Realty.

$15,000
225040133 MLS
Lake life doesn't have to be out of reach! This double lot in Candlewood's Unit 5 gives you the chance to enjoy private lake access, community amenities, and a more relaxed pace - at a much more approachable entry point. With room for a manufactured home, a large shed that remains with the property, and green space behind, it's a setup that offers both value and privacy. ~ Private access to the 250 acre lake ~ Boating, swimming, fishing, tubing & more ~ Private Beach and Pool ~ Playgrounds ~ Fitness Center ~ Sport Courts ~ Bike and Golf Cart friendly community ~ Year round community events! 'Enjoy life living in a vacation-like atmosphere year round!' A true hidden gem in Central Ohio, you have to come see it for yourself!

7326 State Route 19 Unit 5 - Lots 25 & 26 Unit Unit 5 - Lots 25 & 26, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Chelsea Visconti ---- The Holden Agency

Selling Office: NON MEMBER OFFICE.

$310,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 225038926 MLS
CHARMING MOVE-IN READY RANCH ON 5+ ACRES IN MOUNT GILEAD! Welcome home to this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch perfectly situated on over 5 scenic acres, partially wooded for added privacy and natural beauty. Enjoy peaceful country living while relaxing on the inviting front porch with your favorite glass of lemonade. Step inside to find brand-new carpeting, freshly painted walls, and new luxury vinyl plank flooring in the kitchen and baths. The open-concept kitchen and dining area make entertaining a breeze, and the spacious family room is filled with natural light. The owner's suite features its own private full bath, and the convenient first-floor laundry (washer and dryer remain!) adds extra ease to daily living. The basement offers endless potential for additional living space or storage. An oversized 2-car garage provides plenty of room for vehicles, tools, and hobbies. Recent updates include a newer furnace '23. Nestled on a quiet road with serene views, this home offers the perfect blend of comfort, privacy, and charm—just minutes from town. Move right in and start enjoying the peaceful country life you've been dreaming of!

4565 Township Road 59, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Craig Buehler ---- Coldwell Banker Realty

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Realty.

$210,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 225038780 MLS
Welcome to this charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath home with 1,206 sq ft of well-designed living space in Mt Gilead. The home features a spacious eat-in kitchen with ample counter space, generous cabinetry, and included appliances, perfect for daily living and entertaining. Two bedrooms are located on the main floor, with a large third bedroom on the upper level. Enjoy the versatility of the enclosed 20'11' x 8'1' breezeway connecting the house to the garage. Durable LVP flooring adds modern appeal throughout the main level. The full basement offers potential for additional living or storage space. Located near Mount Gilead High School and set on a generous lot.

669 Baker Street, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : MARILYN K. MILEY ---- CRAIG A MILEY REALTY & AUCTION

Selling Office: Real of Ohio .

$71,000
2 Beds 1 Baths 225038192 MLS
Investor opportunity in Mount Gilead! This 2-bedroom, 1-bath home with 986 sq. ft. is located in a quiet neighborhood on the outskirts of town and is ready for your finishing touches. Many major updates are already complete, including a brand-new well, new septic tank, new roof, and a new mini split unit. Home has recently had new insulation added, plumbing updated, and two new windows, giving you a strong head start. The interior is down to drywall and subflooring, offering a blank canvas to design as you wish. Additional work will be needed to complete the home, but the foundation is set for your vision. This property is being sold as-is and is best suited for investors looking for a fix-and-flip or long-term rental project. Due to its current unfinished condition, this will need to be a cash purchase or rehab loan. Don't miss this chance to invest in a property where the most expensive systems are already taken care of! Bring your vision and make it shine!

6160 Congress Street, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Paige Bryant ---- Coldwell Banker Realty

Selling Office: The Holden Agency.

$256,275
3 Beds 1 Baths 225037442 MLS
Discover a beautiful 4.53-acre property in the desirable Highland School District. The land offers plenty of space to enjoy the outdoors, with room for gardening, recreation, or simply soaking in the peaceful country setting. The home itself is ready for your vision—solidly built with good bones and full of potential, it's the perfect opportunity to update and make it your own. Convenient freeway access, just 5 minutes to I71, makes commuting a breeze while still allowing you to enjoy the privacy of a spacious property. House has a roof that is only 3 years old. The well was new 5 years ago and the water softener is new. Come see this property and envision the possibilities!

4011 State Route 314, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Erin C Kelty ---- e-Merge Real Estate Champions

Selling Office: RE/MAX Genesis.

$353,100
3 Beds 2 Baths 225036903 MLS
Well maintained 3-bedroom 2 bath home on 2+Acres with Full Basement and 2 car attached garage! Updates Include: Flooring; Roof, gutters & downspouts, water heater, basement waterproofing system with warranty, sump pump 2025; water filtration system 2023; Updated kitchen sink & counter & backsplash 2022; fenced rear yard 2020; Windows 2019; Heating/Cooling Units 2019/2021; Siding & doors 2017; Large Open Living Areas. Stainless kitchen appliances. Owner suite with his & hers closets. Large 12x23 Shed and Chicken Coup. The seller is requesting property to be marketed for 7 days. Highest and best offers will be considered on Monday, October 6, 2025 at 2pm. Please leave offers open until the next business day.

5171 US Highway 42, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Patricia K Jackson ---- RE/MAX Genesis

Selling Office: EXP Realty, LLC.

$490,000
5 Beds 3 Baths 225036233 MLS
Beautiful 2 story home located on just under 2 acres and centrally located with quick access to I-71. You have to see this home to believe all that it has to offer with 5 BD, 2.5 BA, and 3600+ sqft. This home has a new addition with a spacious kitchen offering plenty of cabinets, a large grand island with storage plus a large walk-in pantry. The open floor plan joins the kitchen and dining area to the great room with an absolutely stunning floor to ceiling woodburning fireplace which is open to the loft/family room above. The main floor also offers 2 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, laundry/mud room and a living room. Upstairs you will find a large loft/family room, 3 large bedrooms and a beautiful full bath. The back yard offers privacy with wooded and field borders. 2 car garage with opener plus an additional 12x 24 storage shed. Delco water, natural gas heat, private septic. Come check out all this home has to offer.

4014 State Route 61, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Laura R Swihart ---- Sluss Realty Company

Selling Office: Red 1 Realty.

$170,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 225035887 MLS
Auction Oct. 11th @ 10 AM - Here is a one-owner three-bedroom, two bath brick ranch on 1.42 acres. The home has a newer metal roof and windows, hardwood floors, utility area with washer & dryer hookup, open kitchen and family room. In the full basement is a fuel oil furnace w/central air, electric water heater and sump pump w/battery back-up. All appliances are included with the home. The home is situated on 1.42 acres in the Northmor School District. Make your plans and bid your price on this property with great location and easy access to major highways and cities. TERMS: The property sells with Trustee's confirmation in AS-IS condition. A $10,00.00 non-refundable down payment is due auction day with balance due at closing by November 14, 2025. Any inspections desired by the buyer are prior to the auction at their expense. Open for inspection on Oct. 1st 5-6 pm & Oct. 5th 4-5 pm & 1 hour before the auction. See Agent 2 Agent remarks

7085 State Route 314, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Wesley L Wigton ---- Wigton Real Estate & Auction

Selling Office: Wigton Real Estate & Auction.

$17,500
225035703 MLS
Discover the perfect opportunity to build your dream retreat on two spacious lots located within the sought-after gated community of Candlewood Lake. This private setting not only offers peace and natural beauty but also gives you access to an incredible array of amenities. Enjoy boating, water skiing, and fishing on the sparkling lake, or spend your days relaxing at the lodge, swimming pool, or sandy beach area. Stay active with tennis and pickleball courts, hiking, and scenic nature trails, all just steps from your future home. Northmor Schools add to the appeal, making this an ideal spot for year-round living or a weekend getaway. With so much to offer, these lots provide the perfect blend of recreation, relaxation, and community.

7326 State Route 19 Unit 3 Lot 149-150 Unit Unit 3 Lot 149-150, Mount Gilead

Listing Courtesy of : Julie Schnuerer ---- Sluss Realty Company

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.