Refine Search
Sort by
$195,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 5026370 MLS
Welcome to a picturesque Victorian treasure in the peaceful village of Newcomerstown, where history and charm blend seamlessly with modern living. This 1920 brick masterpiece, with its 2,185 sq. ft. of refined space, is a true embodiment of classic elegance and warmth. Step onto the inviting covered porch and through the solid wood door into a world where the past is beautifully preserved. Inside, you're greeted by an elegant entryway with gleaming hardwood floors and exquisite woodwork that sets the tone for the entire home. The living room, accessible through solid wood French doors, offers a cozy fireplace as its centerpiece, while another set of French doors opens to the dining room, complete with a large window and bench seating with hidden storage. The spacious kitchen is a chef's delight, featuring a wall of cabinets, a double stainless steel sink, and a charming built-in wood hutch, ensuring all your storage needs are met. A conveniently located half bath adds to the main floor's functionality. Ascend the wooden staircase to the second floor, where an open hallway connects four bedrooms and a full bath, complete with a tub/shower unit and a handy laundry chute. The home also features a mudroom/coat room at a side entry, leading to a partially finished basement that offers versatile space for a home office, playroom, or game room, alongside two storage rooms and a laundry area with a shower and commode. Outside, a detached two-car garage, matching the home's brick façade, sits at the rear of the property, providing ample parking and storage space. Experience the blend of historic charm and convenient living in this tranquil setting, making this home a rare find and a timeless retreat.

314 W Main Street, Newcomerstown

Listing Courtesy of: Seth Kienzle, seth@homesearchohio.com With Real Integrity

Selling Office: Howard Hanna.

$170,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 5026089 MLS
This beautiful restored 3/2 home with 2 living rooms, formal dining, eat-in kitchen, 2 multipurpose rooms, and 4 car garage is a must-see! This home boasts original hardwood floors, renovated bathrooms and kitchen. Vintage baths were removed during reno and then placed back in bathrooms. Almost every light has been hand-picked to match the era of the home. All wood trim throughout the home is original with the exception of the kitchen. The window sills are deep! Some windows have been restored. On the second floor, you will find updated outlets, the master bedroom closet expanded, updated plumbing, new light fixtures, and all rooms were redone in the last year. You will also find a walk-up attic access in one of the bedrooms. This attic has been partially renovated, and insulated, and a very unique and beautiful space. With a little work, this room could be used as living space. The landing is big enough for plants or a bookshelf. The first floor is absolutely a treasure! There are 2 sets of pocket doors, built-ins, and original wide hardwood trim! There are original and large doors, as well as the original and gorgeous trim on the stairs. You will find tall ceilings with brand-new lighting in every room. There are 3 bay windows in the home! The first floor features 2 living rooms, a formal dining, eat-in kitchen with a wood burner and laundry closet, and a large entryway. The home also has 2 bonus rooms that can be used as bedrooms or offices or whatever you choose. This home has a beautiful front porch large enough for a swing and chairs! There is an enclosed back porch and an attached garage that currently has a drum booth built in. If you need storage, along with the attic, there is a storage attic above the attached garage, and a large dry basement! There is also an additional 3 car garage for all your vehicles. Newly installed hot tub (negotiable), lots of perennial flower beds and herbs, and a newly installed privacy fence as of 2023. Seller is a Realtor.

369 E Canal Street, Newcomerstown

Listing Courtesy of: Steven C Dailey, stevedaileyrealtor@gmail.com With Leonard and Newland Real Estate Services

Selling Office: Leonard and Newland Real Estate Services.

$28,500
5022583 MLS
A rare find. The perfect lot for your new home. Spring is here. Bring our plans and set the stakes for your new home. Plenty of room on this 90'x117' (double lot-one parcel) city lot to build an easy living ranch or a 2 story home for a growing household. Your new address could be on Oxford Ave or Beech St. Lot allows for a front load or side load attached garage. Low traffic area on a back street close to the the Tuscarawas River. City water, sewer, gas and electric available at the street. Lot restrictions include: no commercial, no single wide mobile homes, garage on the property must have a residence. (no free standing garages permitted for storage or commercial use. Please refer to the Village of Newcomerstown zoning manual should you have additional questions. Don't miss this nice opportunity to purchase a lot within the village. So few left.

Oxford Avenue, Newcomerstown

Listing Courtesy of: Cheryl K Hogue, cherylhoguerealtor@gmail.com With RE/MAX Crossroads Properties

Selling Office: Golden Realty Realty.

$190,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 5021049 MLS
Welcome home to this stunning gem....you won't see a home like this very often! Embrace the beauty of high ceilings and lovingly maintained original wood throughout the home while appreciating modern conveniences like a first floor bedroom and washer/dryer hookups! Love to cook? The updated kitchen includes plenty of custom cabinetry that was built with love and offers pull out shelves for ease and full access, doors with glass inserts, and more! You will also find plenty of storage in both bathrooms, bedrooms, and even a unique closet in the front family room! It certainly is not hard to imagine lazy morning coffee or a quiet relaxing evening while you sit on your enclosed front porch after dinner. Love being outside? Take a stroll to check out the rather spacious yard that surrounds this home as well as the easy access from the side alley. Be sure to call and set up your private showing soon as this beauty won't be available for very long!

60951 County Road 9, Newcomerstown

Listing Courtesy of: Catherine L Marlatt, CatherineLMarlatt@gmail.com With Olinger & Company Realty, LLC.

Selling Office: RE/MAX Crossroads Properties.

$233,500
4 Beds 3 Baths 5020041 MLS
Seller is Motivated and open to all offers. Seller is offering $3,000 towards the buyer’s closing cost’s. Spacious Cape Cod home located on .48 acres in Newcomerstown. Beautiful decorative pavers around the front of the house completing the driveway and sidewalks. This house features 4 bedrooms and 2.5 baths with a heated 2 car garage. With over 2300 sq ft you're sure to have plenty of room for the whole family. Main level has 2 living rooms along with a dining room, kitchen, and a half bath. All kitchen appliances were new 2 years ago, are staying with the house and are still under warranty. First floor has had many updates including new floating flooring, all new LED light fixtures, updated tamper resistant outlets , and new switches throughout. The dining room had shiplap wall added along with fresh paint throughout the whole house. The main level half bath was recently redone with a new vanity, flooring connected to the kitchen, and a new toilet. The house comes with two new nest thermostats and a ring doorbell. In the basement you will find a family room perfect for any get together. There is a dry bar, canning room, extra shower, and the laundry room. Upstairs on the 2nd level you will find the 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a whole house vent system. The master bath has a jetted tub, 2 sink vanity, and a stand alone shower. The other bathroom upstairs has been newly updated as well with a new vanity and toilet. Back downstairs through the breezeway is the Connected Garage. This 2 car garage has its very own HVAC and AC systems for summer and winter months. The garage has plenty of room to park your cars and room for all your future projects. Above the garage is a spacious unfinished area. There is an additional 3 parcels which equal 2 acres separately located behind the house that are also available for purchase This area has so much potential to become anything you want. Call today to schedule a showing and see this place for yourself.

260 N College Street, Newcomerstown

Listing Courtesy of: Halie Schwab, halies502@gmail.com With Olinger & Company Realty, LLC.

Selling Office: RE/MAX Crossroads Properties.

$149,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 5015789 MLS
MOVE IN CONDITION! This renovated three bd, 1.5 bath home offers a fresh look in a great location. The interior features a spacious eat in kitchen with abundant new counter space, sink and plumbing, white cabinets, laminate flooring. There is a living and dining room with unique archways. Foyer entrance has coat closet, laminate flooring, open staircase and a storage bench. The lg first floor bathroom has been totally renovated with new vanity, toilet, tub and nice linen closet. The upstairs has a new 1/2 bath, 3 lg bedroom with storage. All the flooring and carpet and brand new. The home has been freshly painted inside and out. A new roof, gutters, downspouts, central air (most ductwork has been replaced), GFCI protection where needed, light fixtures. Front porch trek deck and railing. 200-amp service. Updated replacement windows, High efficiency furnace 11 yrs. approx., new screens in windows, Nice older basement with laundry hookup that could be finished. The alley bound lot allows for easy access to a 24 x 28 building that could serve as a workshop, storage, modified to accommodate a vehicle, small business, or a place to gather with family and friends. The building has a 100-amp service (only one electric to the property), concrete floor, loft, lg. wood beams. The roof has sheeting and tar paper under the shingles. The seller is unsure if there is a water line to the building. There are drains. Nice property and location. Compare.

450 Barnett Avenue, Newcomerstown

Listing Courtesy of: Cheryl K Hogue, cherylhoguerealtor@gmail.com With RE/MAX Crossroads Properties

Selling Office: RE/MAX Crossroads Properties.

$192,500
3 Beds 1 Baths 5016518 MLS
Welcome to this charming two-story colonial home sitting on .73 acres with a huge back yard that leads straight to the river with easy access. Think of all the FUN you could have kayaking, tubing, canoeing, fishing, and picnics or just sit and let the river mesmerize you. Now on the inside, you will feel the warmth and character of this home as soon as you walk through the front door. The first thing that you will notice is the gorgeous staircase. The living room with its hardwood floors and a propane fireplace, soak up the sun in the spacious sunroom, the dining room with hardwood floors and a window seat. Upstairs you will find the 3 bedrooms and the bath. Full, clean unfinished basement with potential. There is a fireplace and half bath in the basement that has never been used by current owner. Updates: New roof and windows in 2016. Newly painted kitchen cabinets with hardware - stained and sealed original hardwood floors - new pex piping for the washer and the bathroom - freshly painted sunroom and bathroom.

725 E State Street, Newcomerstown

Listing Courtesy of: Candy Hostetter, candyhostetter@howardhanna.com With Howard Hanna Real Estate Services

Selling Office: RE/MAX Edge Realty.

$149,900
2 Beds 1 Baths 5015324 MLS
This home has been completely renovated with high-quality materials and modern design. You will love the spacious and bright open concept living area featuring new vinyl LVT flooring. The kitchen is a chef’s dream, with new cabinets, countertops, backsplash, and appliances. The bathroom is equally impressive with the vanity having dual sinks. Although the home is a 2 bedroom you have the possibility to add a 3rd in the full-size basement. The home also boasts newer drywall, roof, windows, and fresh paint throughout. This home is conveniently located close to schools. Don’t miss this opportunity to own this beautiful and move-in ready home! The Listing agent is the brother of the owner.

560 Heller, Newcomerstown

Listing Courtesy of: Ron A Hickman, ronhickmansells@gmail.com With Olde Town Realty

Selling Office: NextHome New Horizons Equity Realty.

$195,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 5014152 MLS
Back on the Market! Escape to the serene beauty of this charming bi-level house nestled on over 1.49 acres of beautiful landscape. Situated on a hillside, this hidden gem offers a tranquil retreat while still being conveniently located near modern amenities. As you drive up, you'll be greeted by a 1-car garage, providing ample space for your vehicle and storage needs. Step inside and discover the potential to make this house your own. While the house could benefit from some updates, it presents an incredible opportunity to create your dream home. With a finished basement, this house offers additional living space, perfect for a cozy family room. The 2,600 sq. ft. of living space provides room for everyone to spread out and enjoy their own private sanctuary. The house boasts 3 bedrooms and 2 1/2 bathrooms, ensuring there's plenty of room for you and your loved ones to comfortably settle in. Public water and sewer connections make maintenance a breeze, while the new metal roof provides peace of mind for years to come. Across the road, you'll find a spacious 2-car garage, perfect for storing your vehicles, tools, or even creating your own workshop. Adjacent to the garage is a shed, providing even more storage space for all your outdoor essentials. Built in 1964, this house carries a rich history and offers a chance to create lasting memories. Embrace the potential to turn this house into a home that reflects your unique style and taste. Schedule a viewing today and start envisioning the endless possibilities that await you in this scenic, bi-level house on 2+ acres.

400 Park Hill Drive, Newcomerstown

Listing Courtesy of: Jamie H Miller, jamie.miller@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

Selling Office: DeHOFF REALTORS.

$85,000
5008743 MLS
First time offered! Nice commercial property suitable for various businesses. High traffic area. Sale includes 1,629 square foot building. There is a partial basement with concrete floor, storage rooms, 2 restrooms, 2 bays, reception area, gas heat. In addition there is a 1,064 sq. ft., 3 bay garage with 1-10' door plus 2-9' doors, and gas furnace. Electric allows for air compressor operation. Ample parking in and around the station and 3 bay garage. There is also a home on the property with a long term tenant. All of the buildings have newer metal roofs, well maintained and ready for a new owner. This property has many possibilities for a new owner. It could be converted to serve many businesses. The income from the rental home is a bonus. A great place to locate with a great deal of drive by exposure. Home rents for $600/month with a long term tenant. 24 hour notice to show due to pets needing to be removed. Seller open to compressor, tire machine, and tire balancer. 24 hours notice required.

300 & 310 E Canal Street, Newcomerstown

Listing Courtesy of: Cheryl K Hogue, cherylhoguerealtor@gmail.com With RE/MAX Crossroads Properties

Selling Office: RE/MAX Crossroads Properties.

$129,400
3 Beds 1 Baths 5007691 MLS
Move in condition. Clean & well maintained home. This home has so much to offer given the large first floor plan. The spacious liv & family room in front of the home has room for everyone. Formal din room has beautiful open staircase. A bright, cheery kitchen comes with appliances and has a walk in pantry. The windows surround a corner sunroom. It was a seller favorite. A must see totally, professionally renovated first floor bath with step in shower, glass doors, high profile toilet, storage and updated flooring. The bedrooms are spacious with ample storage. This home features updated electric, furnace & central, updated roof, vinyl siding, and leaf guard. There is a nice older basement with an inside & outside entrance and half bath. A convenient enclosed porch off the kitchen makes a great place for shoes/coats. BONUS--This home is located near Newcomerstown High School, Middle School & West Elementary. Also within walking distance to downtown area, football stadium and local hot spots. Alley bound on side and back. Same owner for 60+ years. A good solid home that has been loved. You must see soon!

471 S River Street, Newcomerstown

Listing Courtesy of: Cheryl K Hogue, cherylhoguerealtor@gmail.com With RE/MAX Crossroads Properties

Selling Office: Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC..

$222,376
4448717 MLS
Auction 4/29- Attention outdoor enthusiasts and nature lovers! Prepare yourself for an unforgettable auction experience! 619 acres of premier hunting and recreational land in Coshocton & Guernsey Counties. The property is situated in a prime hunting area and is home to an abundance of wildlife, including deer, turkey, and small game. Whether you're a seasoned hunter or just looking for a peaceful escape, this property has something for everyone. This beautiful all-wooded property has potential building sites, making it a great investment opportunity for those looking for a retreat homestead or cabin site. The land also boasts mature timber, offering additional potential for investment. There are numerous trails throughout and the land has frontage on multiple roads. The parcels range in size from 36 to 92 acres and offer the possibility for land groupings for those looking for large contiguous land tracts. Don't miss out on this rare opportunity to own a piece of excellent hunting and

Coshocton Road, Newcomerstown

Listing Courtesy of: Curtis L Yoder, curt@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC

Selling Office: Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.