Refine Search
Sort by
$309,900
4 Beds 3 Baths 5219835 MLS
Custom-built, move-in ready lake access ranch home in a gated community in West Salem, Ohio, offering wooded views and resort-style amenities. This well-maintained home features an open-concept layout with vaulted ceilings, recessed lighting, and seamless flow between the living, dining, and kitchen areas. The kitchen includes Corian countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a walk-in pantry, and opens to a dining area and spacious deck with a SunSetter retractable awning, ideal for outdoor living and entertaining. Main level living includes a primary suite with private en-suite bath, plus two additional bedrooms and a full bath. Convenient first-floor laundry adds everyday functionality. The finished walkout lower level provides additional living space with a fourth bedroom and full bath, offering flexible use as a guest suite or in-law suite. The lower level also includes storage space, and direct patio access overlooking wooded green space with lake views. Direct lake access via greenbelt. Additional features include a two-car attached garage, poured concrete basement, wireless security system, and internet access. Natural gas is available at the street offering conversion potential. All appliances convey with the home. Community amenities include lake access with boating and fishing, swimming, heated pool, tennis and basketball courts, nature trails, and a community lodge, offering a full resort-style lifestyle for full-time residence or second home use.

5117 Sangria Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Tiffany Wynne, homes@tiffanywynne.com With Real of Ohio

$479,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 5213369 MLS
Stunning property with large stone patio that sits on one of the largest lots in Cinnamon Lake with beautiful views of the lake. Stone walkways, plant retaining wall and rear lake facing retaining wall were new as of 2025. New outdoor landscaping with architectural lighting lights the house in the front and back by the lake. A screen porch and open deck were rebuilt in 2026. Kitchen with granite counter tops, glass tile backsplash and vinyl flooring. Downstairs bath has vinyl flooring, new shower with glass doors and skirted toilet. Bath up has vanity with stone top, skirted toilet, all newer lights with new shower and new soaking tub. Flooring in upstairs bath, living room and hallway have new luxury vinyl. Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42. Home warranty will also be included.

4145 Cedar Lane, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: Keller Williams Living.

$310,500
2 Beds 2 Baths 5217003 MLS
Welcome to this one-of-a-kind custom log home, built on-site from timber sourced from Upper Michigan and nestled on a double lot in the private Cinnamon Lake community. Offering 2 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and a detached 2-car garage, this beautifully maintained home combines rustic charm with numerous modern updates. An additional improved, buildable lot is included, featuring a culvert and gravel driveway already in place—perfect for added privacy, future construction, or potential resale. Inside, you'll find exceptional craftsmanship throughout, including custom doors, stunning cherry wood carvings, red oak floors on main level and Amish-built custom kitchen cabinetry. The spacious primary suite features a jetted tub and large walk-in closet, while new carpet upstairs adds comfort and style. All appliances convey with the home, making it truly move-in ready. Major improvements completed within the last five years include a new furnace and central air unit, new roofs on both the home and garage, a new hot water tank, new tilt-in windows throughout, a Generac generator, and a chimney that was raised six feet and professionally refaced. The full basement offers additional possibilities with a third full bathroom already partially framed and ready for completion. Step outside to enjoy the brand-new 2026 deck overlooking private woods, creating the perfect setting for relaxing or entertaining. The front yard looks like a picture out of a magazine with its beautiful landscaping, raised garden beds, and oversized cement driveway. This rare property offers the warmth and character of a true log home, modern conveniences, extra land, and all the amenities of Cinnamon Lake living. Whether you're thinking of year round living or just a vacation home, this home is truly something special

5082 Burgundy Court, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Jennifer Carlson, jennifercarlson@tprsold.com With Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Stouffer Realty

Selling Office: Russell Real Estate Services.

$199,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 5215981 MLS
Nestled on 2 wooded lots, in a quiet lake community. This charming brick home offers a secluded space from neighbors. Facing the sunset. Updated butcher block countertops, new sink and commercial pre rinse faucet. stainless appliances, and new laminate flooring. Amish built soft close drawers w copper hardware. Recently installed sliding barn doors reveal a laundry / pantry area just off kitchen. New lighting fixtures and fan. Beautiful brick herringbone fireplace facade, and matching entry pony wall. An inviting 3 seasons room and attached porch facing the rear creek and woods is a great place for deer, bird, and squirrel watching. Bidet in main bathroom 2 car garage with brand new opener, and nice lighting schematic. Also a shed Furnace and a/c is 7 years old, water heater 4 years old . Metal roof is 9 years old, three seasons roof has brand new commercial grade trp roof. Also lake, boat access, pickle ball and tennis courts, beach areas , pool access, and large playground also both bathrooms have extra heaters.

1373 Saffron Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

$480,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 5210939 MLS
Welcome to 6520 Ruff Rd, where peaceful country living meets space, character, and comfort. Situated on 3.154 acres and surrounded by open fields, this 2,600 square foot ranch offers the lifestyle so many are searching for. From the moment you arrive, you will appreciate everything this property has to offer outside, including a 20x24 barn with loft, a large fenced-in garden area to keep the deer away, and wide-open views that create a true sense of privacy and serenity. The screened-in front porch provides the perfect space to enjoy your morning coffee, unwind after a long day, or take in the quiet of the countryside. Inside and you are welcomed by warm hardwood floors, a spacious living room, and a kitchen designed for gathering. Featuring a wood-burning stove and a one-of-a-kind handcrafted center island, this space blends function and charm effortlessly. Just beyond, the great room showcases stunning cathedral pine ceilings along with a second wood-burning stove, creating a cozy yet impressive space for entertaining or relaxing. The main level offers two generously sized bedrooms along with a primary suite featuring an ensuite bath and dual closets. The lower level is partially finished and includes a dedicated workshop area, perfect for hobbies, storage, or additional living space. This home has been thoughtfully updated over the years, including a new roof in 2018, furnace and A/C in 2022, air ducts cleaned in 2022, hot water tank in 2026, Culligan water treatment system with reverse osmosis installed in 2021, new windows throughout in 2015, and a septic system replaced in 2009. The main living room addition was completed in 2018, adding even more space to enjoy. If you have been searching for space, updates, acreage, and the peace of country living, this property delivers.

6520 Ruff Road, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: D. Michael Bomboris, mike@bomboristeam.com With RE/MAX Showcase

Selling Office: Keller Williams Legacy Group Realty.

$132,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 5207557 MLS
AUCTION DATE: Thursday, May 28th 6:00 PM OPEN HOUSE: Tuesday, May 19th 4:00 - 6:00 PM Here’s an opportunity to purchase an affordable home in Wayne County, offering 3 bedrooms and 1.5 bathrooms in a convenient location in West Salem in the Northwestern School District. This property features a newer roof, first floor laundry, a garage with additional storage, a large front porch, and a nice-sized backyard. While some portions of the home have been updated over the years, there is still opportunity for the next owner to make improvements and add value. Whether you’re just getting started, looking to downsize, or searching for an investment property, this one checks a lot of boxes. With limited affordable housing available in the area, this is an opportunity you won’t want to miss. Preview the property at the open house, then make plans to join us on auction day! TERMS: This property sells with a minimum bid of $40,000 to satisfy existing liens. A Buyer’s Premium will be added to the high bid to determine the final contract sale price (contact listing agent for specific details) plus non-refundable downpayment due the day of the auction and balance due in 45 days (contact listing agent for specific details). Arrange your financing and come bid your judgment. Announcements on sale day take precedence over all previous advertising. AUCTION DATE: Thursday, May 28th 6:00 PM OPEN HOUSE: Tuesday, May 19th 4:00 - 6:00 PM

59 W Buckeye Street, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Jed Acker, jed.acker@gmail.com With Donald K. Gant Realty

Selling Office: Donald K. Gant Realty.

$320,000
3 Beds 4 Baths 5206583 MLS
LIVE LAKE LIFE! Welcome home to this beautifully updated 3 bedroom residence nestled the private gated community of Cinnamon Lake, set in the heart of Ohio’s Amish countryside. Offering the perfect balance of peace and convenience. This property is centrally located between Ashland, Wooster and Medina, and just 45 min south of Cleveland in Cinnamon lake the hidden gem of North Central Ohio! Situated on a serene, wooded one acre lot, with close proximity to the Lake. This home provides both privacy and space to enjoy the outdoors. A standout feature is the impressive 24x32 outbuilding, perfect for storing collectibles, recreational equipment, or creating your dream workshop. Inside, you’ll find a move-in ready home with 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and 2 half bathrooms, thoughtfully updated by the current owner. Recent improvements include stylish kitchen and bathroom makeovers, new flooring, fresh paint, and numerous additional upgrades that enhance both comfort and appeal. Whether you’re looking for a full-time residence or a peaceful retreat, this property offers the best of both worlds, modern updates in a tranquil, community focused setting. Don’t miss your opportunity to own a slice of quiet country living with all the conveniences just a short drive away!

5073 Burgundy Court, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Cindy A McCory, cmccory@remax.net With RE/MAX Showcase

Selling Office: Northern Ohio Realty.

$469,900
4 Beds 3 Baths 5205882 MLS
Move in ready! Pre-listing inspection completed. Beautiful view. Spacious open floor plan. Living room with fireplace and surround sound. Big kitchen with lots of cabinets, breakfast bar and movable island. Large dining space. Ceiling fans in all rooms. Luxury master bathroom. 1st floor laundry. Deck with awning and a brick fire-pit on patio. Large dock of composite decking, with electricity. Basement rec room includes raised-seating theater room. High-efficiency gas furnace and on-demand gas hot water heater provide low utility bills. Plenty of storage space and a large work area. Very low HOA fees. Cinnamon Lake, is a quiet, all-electric motor, 135 acre stocked lake with a pool, beach, lodge, tennis/pickle-ball and basketball courts, volleyball, boat docks, fishing pier, playground, and pavilions. This is luxury lake living at its best!

4209 Majorna Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

$419,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 5205910 MLS
Tucked on a quiet cul-de-sac in Cinnamon Lake, this log-sided lakefront home blends comfort and style with year-round appeal. The main level offers 1,584 sq ft plus a partially finished walk-out basement with a large rec room. Featuring 3 bedrooms and 3 updated baths, including a primary suite with a recirculating tub and walk-in closets, the home is filled with natural light from cathedral ceilings, 3 skylights, and lake views from every room. Highlights include bamboo floors, quartz counters, remodeled kitchen, gas fireplace, and modern systems like a heat pump & natural gas furnace, Generac generator, humidifier, and EV charger. Enjoy Trex decking, hot tub, patio, and a private floating dock. Move-in ready with key updates and all appliances included. New roof in 2022 with leaf guard. Schedule your showing today before this fantastic property is gone!

1264 Tupelo Lane, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Tyler Jarvis, tylerjarviscbw@gmail.com With Coldwell Banker Ward RE

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Ward RE.

$313,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 5205531 MLS
Step into this beautifully maintained one-owner 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch offering comfortable one-floor living in the desirable gated lakeside community of Cinnamon Lake. The bright, cheerful kitchen features a center island and opens seamlessly to the dining and living areas, creating an inviting space filled with natural light—perfect for everyday living and entertaining. Just off the kitchen, enjoy a relaxing patio with attached pergola overlooking the backyard. This home also offers a dedicated laundry room and a convenient mudroom off the attached 2-car garage. The impressive detached garage includes a mini split, LED lighting, and 10-ft side walls—ideal for hobbies, storage, or a workshop. Additional features include a 10x16 shed, concrete pad with RV/boat hookup, hot tub, walk-in shower, neutral décor, and two lots totaling over half an acre.

3283 Acuminata Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Stacey Olive, homes@soldwithstacey.net With Key Realty

Selling Office: RE/MAX Showcase.

$272,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 5199330 MLS
Within 5 mins. walking distance to marina, loge & beach. Move-in condition. Garbage disposal 3 months old, furnace approx 4 yrs old (including new duct work), air conditioner is approx 4 yrs old, deck restabilized and ramp built approx 4 yrs ago, siding 4 yrs old. Carpet & laminate flooring is 5 yrs old (except for office), new windows done 4 yrs ago, lights are new 4 yrs ago. Washer & dryer approx 4 yrs, refrigerator is approx 4 yrs, stove 4 yrs ago, dishwasher 4 yrs, sump pump is 5 yrs. Master bath standing shower 5 yrs ago done by Thiel bath/kitchen in Ashland. All lights were put in approx 4 yrs ago. Gravel driveway enlarged 4 yrs ago & new gravel was dropped last year. Front door & storm door new 3-4 yrs ago.

5034 Maderia Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: Keller Williams Legacy Group Realty.

$156,500
2 Beds 1 Baths 5203818 MLS
Welcome to your private retreat in the sought-after Cinnamon Lake community—where comfort, charm, and lifestyle come together effortlessly. This beautifully updated, move-in ready 2-bedroom, 1-bath ranch offers the perfect blend of cozy living and modern touches. Step inside to find stunning LVP flooring flowing throughout the home, leading you into a light-filled living room anchored by a striking brick wood-burning fireplace, the perfect focal point for relaxing evenings. The eat-in kitchen is both stylish and functional, featuring newer appliances, butcher block countertops, and plenty of space to gather. Both bedrooms are generously sized, offering comfort and flexibility, while the updated bathroom showcases a sleek tile shower. Outside, your own wooded oasis awaits. Enjoy peaceful mornings or unwind under the stars around the fire pit, surrounded by nature and privacy. Life in Cinnamon Lake means more than just a home—it’s a lifestyle. Residents enjoy access to a 135-acre lake for fishing, swimming, and boating, along with a community lodge, beach, tennis courts, walking trails, and playground. Whether you’re searching for a year-round residence or the perfect summer escape, this enchanting home delivers the best of both worlds.

5090 Sangria Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Jill Renee Hill, jill@jillreneehill.com With HomeSmart Real Estate Momentum LLC

Selling Office: The Agency Cleveland Northcoast.

$257,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 5201234 MLS
Enjoy the space and possibilities of country living at 13550 Congress Road, West Salem! Situated on 7.25 acres, this 3-bedroom, 2- bath home offers 1,620 square feet of living space, a large office, and several major mechanical updates already in place, including newer AC, furnace, water system, and on-demand propane hot water. Outside is where this property truly stands out, featuring an impressive 30' x 72' detached outbuilding with 10-foot ceilings, including a 30' x 24' garage, 30' x 32' workshop, and 30' x 16' animal area. Solar panels installed in 2023 offer outstanding efficiency and have the potential to offset approximately 80?90% of the energy use for the house and barn combined. With room for hobbies, storage, animals, equipment, or projects, this property offers a unique blend of function, space, and opportunity in a peaceful rural setting.

13550 Congress Road, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Mathew Schaefer, mathewschaefer@howardhanna.com With Howard Hanna Real Estate Services

Selling Office: Keller Williams Elevate.

$215,900
2 Beds 2 Baths 5200586 MLS
Welcome to peaceful living in the desirable Cinnamon Lake Association! This charming brick ranch is perfectly situated on three spacious lots, offering privacy with no close neighbors and plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors. Start your mornings on the private back porch with beautiful sunrises, and unwind in the evenings on the front porch with stunning sunset views—both offering clear, open scenery. Inside, the home features 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, with a thoughtfully designed layout that is handicap accessible on the main floor, including wide doorways and durable wood floating flooring throughout. The home includes a 1-car attached garage and a full basement with a wood burner, providing great potential for additional finished living space. While cozy in size, this home is highly functional and ready to meet your needs. Living in Cinnamon Lake means enjoying a vibrant, amenity-rich community with year-round activities, a clubhouse, inground pool, and security. The expansive lake is perfect for fishing, swimming, and boating—making every summer feel like a getaway. If you’re looking for comfort, privacy, and an active community lifestyle, this property is a must-see!

1540 Cinnamon Drive S, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Jennifer Carlson, jennifercarlson@tprsold.com With Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Stouffer Realty

$188,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 5199809 MLS
Welcome to the charm of West Salem, a close-knit community known for its small-town feel and quiet, welcoming streets. This classic century home blends character with thoughtful updates. The main living area features a spacious kitchen that connects to the family room and dining room, creating a functional layout for everyday living. You will notice fresh paint in select areas, new dining room flooring, and updated bathroom fixtures that add a clean, refreshed touch. A first-floor bedroom offers flexibility, with two additional bedrooms upstairs. Outside, a covered patio overlooks the backyard, providing a comfortable space to relax. The full basement has been waterproofed and includes a sump pump, offering added peace of mind along with storage and a laundry area. A standout feature is the 5-car, 3-door garage, offering excellent space for a workshop, hobbyist, or car collector. Major updates include a newer furnace, A/C, hot water tank, a roof replaced in 2013 with 30-year shingles, and newer windows and doors. A solid home with character, in a community people truly enjoy being part of.

59 S Main Street, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ryan Shirley, ryan.shirley@kw.com With Keller Williams Living

Selling Office: EXP Realty, LLC.

$127,100
3 Beds 2 Baths 5200088 MLS
Come see this affordable country living dream! If you've been searching for a little acreage without breaking the bank, this property is a must-see! Inside, this home offers 3 beds, 1 and ½ bathrooms as well as an extra room that can be used for an office, library, or an additional living room space. In the front, there is a 30x10 enclosed area, perfect for storage, a mudroom, or flexible use. Outside, you'll find a spacious 24x24 garage for vehicles, tools, or hobbies. You will also find a chicken coop and a shipping container for additional storage. Key updates include, a new roof in 2021, hot water tank in 2025, and new fridge and stove in 2025. Make it your own! Come enjoy 2 acres in the countryside of Wayne County! The mobile home has not been converted and remains titled as personal property. Financing options may be limited, please find a lender who will lend on a title and land.

11308 Stratton Road, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Naomi Auerbach, naomicbward@gmail.com With Coldwell Banker Ward RE

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Ward RE.

$75,000
5200170 MLS
Historic commercial building located in the heart of downtown West Salem, originally constructed in 1900 and once home to a working blacksmith shop. This property offers a unique opportunity to own a piece of local heritage while bringing new life to a growing community. Situated in an area experiencing renewed energy and development, the building benefits from proximity to Dragway 42 and recent business growth, including a newly opened restaurant nearby. Downtown West Salem continues to attract interest as an up-and-coming destination with small-town charm and increasing visibility. Ideal for a variety of business uses, this space blends historic character with future potential. Become part of West Salem’s legacy and contribute to the continued revitalization of this vibrant community.

22 W Buckeye Street, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Maria K Slota, mariaslota@stoufferrealty.com With Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Stouffer Realty

$105,000
5199301 MLS
Not one… but TWO wooded lots in the gated community of Cinnamon Lake — offering a rare opportunity to secure extra space, added privacy, and endless potential. Whether you’re looking to build your dream home with room to spread out, create the ultimate weekend retreat, or invest in land within a sought-after lake community, this package delivers flexibility that’s hard to find. Enjoy lake access, mature trees, and the ability to design exactly what you want — all while being part of a vibrant community featuring a private stocked lake, beach, pool, clubhouse, restaurant, and recreational amenities. Opportunities to own multiple lots like this don’t come around often. Build bigger, think longer-term, or simply enjoy the added space — the choice is yours. Secure your place in Cinnamon Lake and start creating the lifestyle you’ve been thinking about. **Lot Lines in aerial photos are intended for general reference and are not precise boundaries.**

1290-1291 Laurel Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: D. Michael Bomboris, mike@bomboristeam.com With RE/MAX Showcase

Selling Office: RE/MAX Showcase.

$105,000
5199319 MLS
Tucked inside the gated community of Cinnamon Lake, this wooded lot offers the perfect opportunity to create your own private escape or future home. Surrounded by nature and just moments from the water, this property gives you the freedom to build at your own pace while enjoying everything this incredible community has to offer. Whether you’re dreaming of a weekend getaway or a full-time residence, this lot delivers the setting to bring your vision to life. Cinnamon Lake spans over 1,200 acres and features a stocked lake for fishing and boating, a sandy beach, swimming pool, clubhouse, restaurant, and year-round activities. With utilities available and a peaceful, wooded backdrop, this is more than just land — it’s your chance to invest in a lifestyle. If you’ve been waiting for the right place to build, unwind, and enjoy lake living… this is it. **Lot Lines in aerial photos are intended for general reference and are not precise boundaries.**

1292 Laurel Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: D. Michael Bomboris, mike@bomboristeam.com With RE/MAX Showcase

Selling Office: RE/MAX Showcase.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.