Refine Search
Sort by
$462,950
4 Beds 3 Baths 225012446 MLS
This charming home has 4 bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms and a den, complemented by a cozy family room that provides picturesque views of the serene goldfish pond—a peaceful retreat right in your backyard! Nestled in the sought-after Colonial Hills subdivision within the Worthington School District, this home is conveniently located near 3 parks, a variety of restaurants and shops, the Worthington Farmers Market, and easy access to the interstate. The community has a tennis court and basketball courts. Recent updates include a metal roof (2016), a new deck (2022), HVAC system (2018), and a tankless water heater (2024), along with newer windows and leaf guard gutters. Additional highlights feature a generator, a greenhouse, and a tranquil goldfish pond complete with a fountain and a fenced yard.

559 Colonial Avenue, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Ann Logan ---- RE/MAX Affiliates, Inc.

Selling Office: Best Homes Real Estate Ltd..

$349,900
3 Beds 1 Baths 225010586 MLS
Charming Cape Cod in highly sought-after Colonial Hills neighborhood of Worthington! This 3BR home is ready for immediate move-in. The house offers a clean, bright kitchen with updated appliances (huge refrigerator), and spacious finished basement areas, including an extra room w/ closet - ideal for a guest suite or office. The upstairs features oversized dormers that create a bright, open feel and add valuable headroom. Kick back in the large three-season room or entertain on the spacious brick patio in the backyard. Additional features include a two-car garage, updated bath, and new flooring throughout the home. No carpet except low-pile Berber in finished basement areas. Short walk to Colonial Hills Elementary and close to shops, dining, and parks. A true gem in a thriving area.

5645 Indianola Avenue, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Paul Graves ---- Red 1 Realty

Selling Office: RE/MAX Consultant Group.

$400,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 225010157 MLS
Amazing Worthington Cape Cod with a brand-new roof & thoughtful updates throughout! This charming property boasts an oversized garage and a prime location near Indianola Park. Step inside this freshly painted gem, featuring replacement windows and stunning hardwood floors that enhance its immaculate appeal. A beautifully updated kitchen showcases new quartz countertops, tile backsplash, & built-in banquette—perfect for cozy dining. Updated LG Gas range & appliances remain for added convenience. The flexible finished lower level offers incredible additional living space, while the deluxe paver patio inside the fenced yard sets the stage for backyard BBQs and outdoor entertaining. Ideally situated near coveted schools, parks, and local amenities. New HWT & excellent move-in ready condition.

5735 Indianola Avenue, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Erin Ogden Oxender ---- Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs

Selling Office: Saxton Real Estate.

$370,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 225007880 MLS
A rare opportunity in Worthington's Colonial Hills. This updated home blends classic charm with modern features. The kitchen showcases quartz countertops, tiled backsplash, and stainless appliances. Upstairs offers three bedrooms, with the owner's suite featuring a custom built-in wood closet. The full bathroom boasts a large bay window, spacious shower/tub, and vessel sink. The lower level includes a carpeted recreation room with industrial metal accents. Unique 'pass-through' one-car garage connects to the backyard, where an additional 2.5-car standalone garage with new electrical serves as a workspace. Fenced yard and walking distance to Selby and Indianola Metro Parks. The home is in need of cosmetic updates & is priced accordingly.

554 Loveman Avenue, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : David J Weissman ---- Keller Williams Greater Cols

Selling Office: Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs.

$405,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 225002500 MLS
Beautifully updated and maintained 3BR ranch in popular Colonial Hills! Light & bright Living room with HW floors and gas log fireplace with gorgeous mantel ('15). Updated kitchen ('14) offers lots of cabinet and counter space. Custom blinds, bedroom ceiling fan, and can lights add the finishing touches to this charming home. Spacious primary suite with dedicated full bath! Hall full bath refreshed in '20. The many exterior updates include: fresh paint, new roof, gutter guards, white fence w/gates, and replaced asphalt driveway ('18-'19)! Fantastic neighborhood community with planned events throughout the year. Prime location near the shops and restaurants of downtown Old Worthington. Addl highlights include the AC ('16), water heater ('22), and furnace ('24)!

464 Kenbrook Drive, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Cynthia C MacKenzie ---- CYMACK Real Estate

Selling Office: CRT, Realtors.

$380,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 224042493 MLS
NEW PRICE-Come see this pristine, adorable Cape Cod in Colonial Hills in the Worthington School District. This home has been well cared for & maintained-New Roof in 23, New Furnace in 20, New AC in 21, New Hot Water Tank in 21. All appliances are newer. Sump pump with battery backup in 22. Radon mitigation in place. Additionally, it still has all of the charm of a vintage 1942 family home. with the original hardwood floors throughout, Lower level has 2 finished rooms for extended family entertaining or office space. This home is ready for you to move in & enjoy the inviting, friendly community of Colonial Hills. Very walkable to 3 parks & Colonial Hills Elementary School, Old Worthington shops & the renowned Worthington Farmers Market. Come Home to Worthington today!

475 Park Boulevard, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Donn W Rosselet ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs

Selling Office: Berkshire Hathaway HS Calhoon.

$340,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224037399 MLS
Welcome to Old Worthington, Colonial Hills community. This original 1942 family-owned & beautifully updated ranch home is MOVE-IN READY! Neutral palette, hardwood floors, fresh paint throughout, ceiling fans, recessed lighting, new window coverings, solid surface kitchen countertops w/custom 3-bowl sink & SS appliances. Two hall bedrooms, full bath w/solid surface walk-in shower, 3rd BONUS bedroom (or multipurpose space) w/LVT flooring, full bath w/shower, and laundry closet. New vinyl siding w/freshly painted trim, detached 2-car tandem garage w/storage space. Fenced backyard w/cleared space to enjoy with all who visit. Prime location gives quick access to Worthington Farmer's Market, Old Worthington shops/dining, Indianola Park, Selby Park, schools, main & major thoroughfares!

387 Kenbrook Drive, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Janet A Rung ---- Coldwell Banker Realty

Selling Office: Reafco.

$399,999
3 Beds 3 Baths 224035708 MLS
Charming 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath Colonial Hills home on a cul-de-sac! Featuring hardwood floors throughout, the bright living room flows into a dining area and refreshed kitchen. The entry-level bedroom and full bath add convenience, with two spacious bedrooms and an updated half bath upstairs. The finished lower level offers a living room, and another room perfect for a home office, along with an additional full bath and plenty of storage. Step out to the 3-season room and enjoy the large, fenced backyard with a storage shed. Many recent updates to the home! Located near downtown Worthington, schools, and parks. Seller is a licensed agent in the State of Ohio.

178 Loveman Avenue, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Tayler Reid ---- Century 21 Excellence Realty

Selling Office: Key Realty.

$530,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 224029380 MLS
Beautifully updated 4 BR, 2 BA home w/ excellent curb appeal! Relax on the Idyllic covered front porch & enjoy the dreamy neighborhood offering mature trees, 2 parks, a creek, community center & sporting areas, minutes from Old Worthington. Upon entry charming LR greets you & opens up to 2 convenient entry level BR's & the gorgeous open concept kitchen featuring Amish custom soft close cabinetry & pull out spice rack, SS appliances & delightful breakfast bar! Light & bright Dining space opens to FR w/ cozy wood burning stove. Convenient entry level laundry room. Upstairs offers 2 spacious BR's & refreshed FB! Recently expanded back deck overlooks the spacious backyard w/ potting shed (w/ electric) & gazebo! Adtl highlights: Solar panels, fresh paint, new storm door & light fixtures

304 E Selby Boulevard, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Cynthia C MacKenzie ---- CYMACK Real Estate

Selling Office: Roby Realty.

$370,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 224021941 MLS
Charming 3BR Cape Cod with rare 2 car detached garage located in popular Colonial Hills! Inviting covered side porch & fresh exterior paint ('23)! Lovely living room with beautiful HW floors! Updated kitchen features granite & butcher block counters, tile backsplash, and ceramic floors! Two roomy bedrooms & refreshed full bath on the entry level. Upstairs you will find the large primary bedroom with sitting area and half bath. Fantastic finished lower level with updated flooring ('22) and 2nd full bath! Enjoy spending time outdoors in the deep yard with privacy fence ('22). Addl updates include: Windows '24, Furnace/AC '23, Gutters w guard '22, Roof '22. Wonderful community with mature trees, 2 parks, a creek, clubhouse & sporting areas. Close to schools and downtown Old Worthington!

5690 Indianola Avenue, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Cynthia C MacKenzie ---- CYMACK Real Estate

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Realty.

$460,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 224020753 MLS
Beautiful 4 BR, 3 BA home in popular Colonial Hills! Dreamy neighborhood with mature trees, 2 parks, a creek, community center & sporting areas. Gleaming hardwood floors & fresh paint ('24) flow throughout. Updated kitchen features granite counters & SS appliances. Welcoming Family Room with high ceilings highlight the brick fireplace. Updated BA on entry level offers granite counter, tile shower surround, new shower door & fixtures ('24). Refinished HW floors flow throughout upper level. 3 spacious bedrooms with ample closet space & full BA with beautiful tile surround. Versatile LL Rec Room offers full bath & utility space. Enjoy the spacious backyard featuring a composite deck, basketball court & 2 storage sheds! Updates incl: Interior Paint '24, Water Heater '23, Radon Mitigation '22

467 Park Boulevard, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Cynthia C MacKenzie ---- CYMACK Real Estate

Selling Office: The Columbus Agents.

$600,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224017536 MLS
Idyllic 3BR Cape Cod with brick walk-way & slate roof nestled on a tree-lined lot in Colonial Hills! The upper & lower level porches are the envy of the neighborhood! The upper porch feels like a private sanctuary and the lower is perfect for outdoor entertaining! Light & bright interior with beautiful HW floors! Lovely living room w/ crown molding and fireplace. Two built-in cabinets in the dining room. Updated kitchen with tile backsplash, large island, SS appliances, and granite counters! Open & airy family room with high ceilings, fireplace, and deck access. Two spacious bedrooms and full bath on the entry level. Upstairs features a flex space, great for a home office or sitting room, and large primary bedroom with full bath! Prime location near parks, schools, and downtown Old WO!

71 E Southington Avenue, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Cynthia C MacKenzie ---- CYMACK Real Estate

Selling Office: Cutler Real Estate.

$510,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 224016466 MLS
Beautifully landscaped 4BR Cape Cod in popular Colonial Hills! Light & bright living room with built-ins, fireplace, and gorgeous HW floors! Updated kitchen features granite counters, SS appliances, timeless cabinets, and large window overlooking the serene backyard! Upstairs offers a large primary suite w/ sitting area, walk-in closet & dedicated full bath with double sink vanity! Fantastic LL offers brand new carpet, versatile gathering area with walk-out, bedroom, and full bath! Perfect for entertaining! Outdoor living at its best with this park-like backyard overlooking the wooded ravine! Enjoy the lovely surroundings from the multi-tiered deck & firepit area. Newer brick walk-way to steps leading down to the ravine. Great location near schools, parks, and Downtown Old Worthington!

306 Colonial Avenue, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Cynthia C MacKenzie ---- CYMACK Real Estate

Selling Office: The Columbus Agents.

$770,000
224013429 MLS
A GREAT OPPORTUNITY for a small business looking for a prime location with ample parking and easy access to public transportation. The three-story stone office building with over 7,300 square feet of space is located just south of downtown Worthington on High Street. This property includes 2 lots w/ plenty of parking, which is a valuable asset in this area. In addition to its convenient location, the building has a beautiful exterior appearance that is sure to make a great impression on customers and clients. With 3 stories of space, there is plenty of room for a variety of businesses, from small startups to established companies looking for more space. Overall, this property is an excellent opportunity for any small business looking to establish a presence in the Worthington.

5760 N High Street, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Joseph C Jackson ---- Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs

Selling Office: NON MEMBER OFFICE.

$415,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224013242 MLS
Don't miss this updated & move-in ready home in WORTHINGTON SCHOOLS! Prime location just 5 minutes from downtown Worthington & steps from Indianola Park, Selby Park & Colonial Hills Elementary School. 1st floor offers 2 separate living spaces, which could also be used for dining, office or playroom. Stunning kitchen w/ white shaker soft-close cabinetry, SS appliances & quartz counters opens to living room w/ vaulted ceilings & transom windows. Upstairs you'll find an en-suite master w/ walk-in closet, plus 2 additional bedrooms & bathroom. Gleaming hardwood flooring and neutral paint throughout. Large backyard w/ deck and fire pit is perfect for entertaining & is fully fenced for pets. All mechanicals & electric panel are newer. This home is sure to impress - Schedule your showing today!

590 N Selby Boulevard, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Emily Groza Yoko ---- KW Classic Properties Realty

Selling Office: KW Classic Properties Realty.

$454,500
4 Beds 2 Baths 224012386 MLS
Charming Colonial Hills two-story home boasting four bedrooms & two full bathrooms. Once inside your welcomed by the warmth of the hardwood floors, cozy fireplace & built-in bookcase. The classic kitchen has oak cabinets including some glass front cabinets adding to the character of the home. The cozy family room provides a great gathering space in addition to the living & dining rooms. There is a bedroom & full bath located on the 1st floor, with the additional 3 bedrooms & updated full bath upstairs. Outside the front porch welcomes you while the screened-in back porch provides a perfect spot for relaxation or entertaining. The lower level has a workshop area, laundry hook-ups and ample storage space. An ideal location with 3 nearby parks, plus schools, restaurants and shops!

371 Colonial Avenue, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Heather Byrne ---- KW Classic Properties Realty

Selling Office: CYMACK Real Estate.

$424,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224008287 MLS
Beautifully updated 1942 ranch in Worthington's popular Colonial Hills Neighborhood. Inviting floor plan featuring three bedrooms, two full baths, and versatile dual living areas. Ample kitchen with shaker cabinetry, stainless appliances, quartz, and neutral palette. Hardwood flooring, recessed lighting, and abundant natural light create a clean modern aesthetic. Primary with ensuite, convenient first-floor laundry and attached 1-car garage. Charming rear garden with covered porch, natural stone patio, mature trees, and professional landscaping. Prime location steps from the Worthington Farmer's Market, Old Worthington shops and dining, Selby Park, and Colonial Hills Elementary. OPEN HOUSE: Sunday, March 24th from 2-4PM, with offers due by 9PM on March 24th.

353 Kenbrook Drive, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Andrew P Malone ---- The Columbus Agents

Selling Office: ValEquity Real Estate.

$413,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224007604 MLS
Spacious 3BR, 2 Full Bath, 2 story home in popular Colonial Hills! Freshly updated interior, and gorgeous HW floors throughout! Lots of natural light in the living and dining rooms. Kitchen remodel in 2019 features newer appliances, tons of cabinet and new granite counter space! Beautiful entry level has a living room, bedroom, bathroom, kitchen and dining room! Two additional generous sized bedrooms and full bath (the was remodeled upstairs in 2017 with roman shower. Fantastic lower level rec room/flex room can be used as a gym/ extra living space. Walk out the back door onto a spacious patio, fenced yard for all of your outdoor living needs! Fun neighborhood activities planned yearlong! Prime location near schools, parks, and the amenities of downtown Old Worthington

198 Loveman Avenue, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Jonathan P Gilchrist ---- Rolls Realty

Selling Office: Baker Realty Group.

$400,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224004204 MLS
Gorgeous 3BR 2bath cape cod in desirable Colonial Hills. Prime location; large corner lot across from neighborhood park. So many updates inside and out. Hardwood floors throughout entire home. Granite counters, tile backsplash, white cabinets, and SS appliances in the updated kitchen. Laundry is conveniently located on main level. Owner's suite is located upstairs boasting a large updated bath and large walk-in closet. Huge concrete patio ('20) overlooking the deep private yard with new cedar fence ('20). Large extended driveway ('20) to 1 car attached garage. HVAC ('21) Fun neighborhood activities planned throughout the year! Prime location near schools, neighborhood parks and the shops and restaurants of downtown Old Worthington.

395 S Selby Boulevard, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Courtney J Mitchell ---- RE/MAX Premier Choice

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Realty.

$420,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 224001011 MLS
OPEN HOUSE- Saturday, 1/13, 2pm-4pm! Spacious 4BR, 2 story home in popular Colonial Hills! Fresh interior paint and gorgeous HW floors throughout! Lots of natural light in the living and dining rooms. Kitchen features SS appliances, tons of cabinet and counter space, and an organizational station! Large entry level primary bedroom with charming built-ins, double closet, and dedicated full bath! Three additional generous sized bedrooms and full bath upstairs. Fantastic lower level rec room with new LVP flooring and fresh paint. Screened porch, patio, fenced yard, firepit, and shed for all of your outdoor living needs! Fun neighborhood activities planned yearlong! Prime location near schools, parks, and the amenities of downtown Old Worthington.

471 Loveman Avenue, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Cynthia C MacKenzie ---- CYMACK Real Estate

Selling Office: Keller Williams Consultants.

$385,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 223029487 MLS
Charming 3 Bed/1.5 Bath move in ready bungalow in the heart of Worthington's Colonial Hills. Fresh paint, beautiful hardwood floors & newer windows provide plenty of natural light highlighting the spacious Living & Dining rooms. Sizeable bedrooms w/custom accent walls. Full bath w/gorgeous tile floors, new modern shiplap walls & lighting. Large Owners suite up w/half bath & office nook. Lower level offers a gorgeously renovated living area featuring built-in custom cabinetry, quartz counters, shiplap walls & new carpet. Fully fenced private rear yard offers shade, beautiful landscaping, refinished deck & firepit for entertaining. Radon System, 1 car attached garage and NEW furnace (Dec '22). Walk to Indianola & Selby Parks, downtown Worthington, restaurants & Farmers Market!

464 Colonial Avenue, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Courtney J Eaglin ---- RE/MAX Consultant Group

Selling Office: e-Merge Real Estate Unlimited.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.