Refine Search
Sort by
$4,000
5047506 MLS
Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

1281 Tupelo Lane, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

$13,900
5046508 MLS
Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

5049-5050 Sangria Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

$160,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 5045328 MLS
A staycation year round with this wonderful home located at Cinnamon Lake in Ashland County. Community perks include lake privileges, pool and community center. Swim, kayak boat or fish until your heart's content! Double lot that offers red and green pear trees, a grape vine and a cherry tree that are all delicious seller said. Single car garage was converted to a large primary bedroom for a total of three bedrooms. Updates include flooring, paint and light fixtures most recently as well as new roof shingles and front porch in 2021, vinyl siding in 2020 and replacement windows in 2018. Cinnamon Lake offers a private gated community with shopping and private storage units adjacent to the community. Home sits on a crawl space so everything is on one level for convenient living. Outdoor living space includes a cozy deck with patio space as well as a sitting area in the back yard. Conveniently located...only 20 minutes to Ashland, 30 minutes to Wooster and 40 minutes to Mansfield you have ample options for nearby shopping, restaurants and employment opportunities!

1515 Cinnamon Drive S, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Kim Merckle, kim@thesupreme.team With Cutler Real Estate

Selling Office: RE/MAX Crossroads Properties.

$2,900
5036414 MLS
Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

1012 Laurel Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

$225,000
2 Beds 1 Baths 5036006 MLS
If you are looking for a home in park like setting, look no further. This updated move in ready home sets on a quiet culdesac, with open space yet surrounded by the views and sounds of nature. Now as you walk in you feel the WOW effect of the the inviting open floor plan with warm colors that will give you that "I'm home" feeling. This home boasts of lots of natural light, from the skylights in the kitchen/living room, big windows in the laundry room to the bonus/Four seasons room that has a front and back entrance with French doors. If storage is a concern, check out the clean full unfinished basement. Truly a must see home. For you garage loving people, how does a 2 car 23' x 26'10 sound? Let's TOP this dream home off with a metal roof. With all this excitement, before you leave, take a seat on the beautiful handcrafted swing and imagine yourself just enjoying the peace and quiet away from all the hussle and bussle of the world. If siting on the porch isn't your thing, try fishing, paddle boating, swimming, or invite some family and friends for fellowship in the lodge, or just take a walk on the quiet park like streets. A home away from home. At Cinnamon Lake you can't help but feel like your on vacation. Stop by soon!

2269 Pinella Court, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Kristine M Barski, kbarski@remax.net With RE/MAX Crossroads Properties

Selling Office: Keller Williams Elevate.

$6,000
5033635 MLS
Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

3264 Arrick Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

$6,000
5032037 MLS
Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

5119 Sangria Road, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

$2,000
5032087 MLS
Welcome to Cinnamon Lake - Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Developed in the mid 1970's, over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake. Amenities include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge, a beach & swimming pool, basketball court, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked w/bass, walleye, saugeye, crappie, & bluegill to name a few! The development is served by 17 miles of all weather roads. Currently we have over 500 homes constructed. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

2025 Coriander Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ivan G Santacruz, ivansantacruz@remax.net With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: Non-Member.

$309,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 5026687 MLS
Very private w/beautiful trees, house sits far back from the road. Beautiful views of the lake from most windows. Enjoy looking at the lake while at the kitchen sink. Kitchen was remodeled w/new counters with oak trim, new appliances, new cooktop, oven, & refrigerator. Next to the kitchen is the dining area w/sliders to upper deck which gives a beautiful view of lake while dining. Master bath totally gutted, everything new w/beadboard walls, granite countertop & new fixtures. Lower level family room has a nice fireplace and sliding doors lead to a lower deck. There is a new metal roof and sump pump (2021) and several new windows (2015). There are steps down to the water and a boat dock. Amenities of a community pool, clubhouse, tennis courts and sand volleyball and of course the lake make this a great family neighborhood. Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake. Amenities include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge, a beach & swimming pool, basketball court, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked w/bass, walleye, saugeye, crappie, & bluegill to name a few!

5107 Sangria Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: Century 21 Carolyn Riley RL. Est. Srvcs, Inc..

$10,000
5024582 MLS
Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

6056-6057 Live Oak Court, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

$13,900
5023318 MLS
Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

1135-1136 Cinnamon Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

$380,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 4494932 MLS
Experience Lakefront Bliss! This 3 Bed, 2 Bath Ranch Home on Cinnamon Lake is a Must-See. Immaculate & Move-In Ready! Step inside to discover a neutral color palette that soothes the senses. The heart of the home, the living room, connects seamlessly to a 4-season room, offering breathtaking lake views. The kitchen, complete with stainless steel appliances, adjoins a spacious dining area, making mealtime a joy. The laundry room is conveniently located on the main level. The master bedroom features an ensuite bathroom, ensuring your comfort. Two additional bedrooms are thoughtfully placed nearby, keeping everyone close. Winter evenings are a delight in your private hot tub. Outside, a multi-level composite deck provides low-maintenance relaxation, and the days of staining a deck are over! Embrace summertime fun by fishing off your own dock on hot summer days. If lake life is your dream, don't wait! Schedule your private tour today. Your waterfront oasis awaits!

3333 Acuminata Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Tiffany Bracken, tbracken@dehoff.com With DeHOFF REALTORS

Selling Office: RE/MAX Infinity.

$8,000
4397578 MLS
Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Developed in the mid 1970's, over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake. Amenities include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge, a beach & swimming pool, basketball court, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked w/bass, walleye, saugeye, crappie, & bluegill to name a few! The development is served by 17 miles of all weather roads. Currently we have over 500 homes constructed. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

6056-6057 Live Oak Court 6057, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associate

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associate.

$316,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 4489051 MLS
Property is located on a 135 acre, private, well stocked Lake in Northern Ashland County. House has own private dock, open floor plan with a walk out partially finished basement with new luxury vinyl plank flooring. This 2088 sq ft plus 250 sq ft sunroom home was built in 1995. Enter right into a 2 story foyer with beautiful oak flooring. You will love the spacious kitchen with stunning oak cabinets, large island, granite countertops, large pantry with pull out shelves, new stainless steel appliances (frig, microwave, dishwasher). The 1st floor is warm & inviting with the oak flooring! This level of the home includes dining room, family room, living room, large master bedroom with walk in closet & full master bath, kitchen, laundry room & 1/2 bath. Beautiful sun room with plenty of windows off family room overlooking backyard & the lake. Upper floor has 2 spacious bedrooms with ceiling fans & a full bath. Basement is partially finished, ideal for entertaining, work out room or kids play area. Large storage room with built in shelves as well as heavy duty steel storage racking & an additional room with wood burning furnace. Home was converted to natural gas Sept 2016. Newly paved roads make Cinnamon Lake a very peaceful community featuring a pool, tennis & pickle-ball courts, basketball court & a playground. Lodge & pavilion rentals available. Pontoon boats, kayaking, paddle boards & sail boating all allowed on the lake! New roof installed August 2023.

1271 Tupelo Lane, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associate

Selling Office: Kelly Warren and Associates RE Solutions.

$350,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 4487556 MLS
Stunning property with large patio that sits on one of the largest lots in Cinnamon Lake with beautiful views of the lake. Kitchen with newer granite counter tops, glass tile backsplash and vinyl flooring. Fridge, stove, microwave, dishwasher and garbage disposal less than 4 yrs old. Downstairs bath has vinyl flooring, new vanity/sink/faucet, new lights and a new skirted toilet. Bath up has new vanity with stone top, new faucets and a new skirted toilet, all new lights. Most of the lighting in the house and outside has been replaced. Lennox furnace installed 5 years ago. Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

4145 Cedar Lane, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associate

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

$2,250
4481779 MLS
Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

1383 Saffron Drive, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc.

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associates, Inc..

$440,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 4484682 MLS
If you are looking for Peace and Tranquility, you don't want to miss this one! Built in 2019, this home has it all, from its spectacular lake front water view to its sensational kitchen. The love and care of this home is seen throughout every room. The kitchen includes beautifully hand crafted Amish Cabinets, a generous sized island, pot filler for convenience, granite countertops and all stainless steel appliances. The Master Bedroom has ample room with a master bath and an amazing view of the lake. Enjoy entertaining either on the over sized deck, gorgeous stamped patio or in the Walk Out Finished Basement. The basement has its own Kitchenette, Family Room, Full Bathroom, Bedroom and an extra room that could be an Office or Exercise Room, the possibilities are endless! There is a 10yr transferrable Structure/Foundation Warranty and 30yr Water Proofing Warranty (starting from 2019), Radon Mitigation System, Grinder Pump and the home has already been wired for a Generator. The only thing left to do is to schedule a showing!

4192 Cinnamon Drive N, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Shannon Manacapelli, smanacapelli@gmail.com With EXP Realty, LLC.

Selling Office: Non-Member.

$200,200
2 Beds 2 Baths 4472121 MLS
Beautiful log home completely updated on double lot with stream at back of property. All mechanical, electrical, insulation, roof, floors & interiors. Finished attic area for additional storage. 2 transparent roofed gazebos, large shed for outdoor equipment storage, extra wide single car garage for a shop area and a large carport attached. Brand new Mini Split for heating & cooling. Window air conditioner in garage. Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Developed in the mid 1970's, over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake. Amenities include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge, a beach & swimming pool, basketball court, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked w/bass, walleye, saugeye, crappie, & bluegill to na

4013 Larch Place, West Salem

Listing Courtesy of: Ron Sermak Sermak, sermak@aol.com With CENTURY 21 DePiero & Associate

Selling Office: RE/MAX Pathway.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.