Refine Search
Sort by
$505,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 5024338 MLS
WOW! Don't miss your opportunity for a unique setting with wooded privacy and serene lake living at its best. Immaculate low-maintenance home is ready for you to begin enjoying all of Lake Buckhorn’s charms. Geared for fun with family and friends, this 2BR + built-in loft beds, 2 ½ bath natural gas home is so inviting and special, you will love living here. Plenty of space to spread out and entertain overnight guests. A total rebuild in 2009, this home is in pristine condition and has been lovingly cared for. Beautiful custom hickory kitchen cabinetry, extra deep cabinets with granite counters and black splash, stainless steel appliances, generous storage. On chilly days turn down the thermostat and enjoy the attractive Jotul wood stove with gorgeous stone hearth in the two-story great room. Heat pump provides A/C. Dining area overlooks the stunning back yard and lake. The 3-season screen room is a perfect place to relax, listen to the birds, share a meal, take a nap, or sleep the night. Fully finished, carpeted lower level is perfect for watching TV, entertaining, with room to lounge, game, or sleep. Beautiful built-in hickory cabinetry and bookshelves. It has a large full bathroom, plus utility/laundry/mud room with washer/dryer and extra fridge. Walk out to your spacious patio overlooking the back yard, lake, and custom-built fire pit. The patio level offers separate access to a large storage room. Both the house and 3-car heated garage/shop are fully Generac protected. This 1.7 acre property boasts a truly unique location, abutting the North Beach Recreation area where you can swim, play, or dock your boat for the day. Simply walk down through your back yard and you're there!

2637 Buckhorn Cove, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: Donald K. Gant Realty.

$375,000
1 Beds 2 Baths 5021346 MLS
Move right into this cozy lakefront A-frame cottage nestled in a quiet cove! Escape to this private lake oasis that features approximately 2600 sq ft of living space on three floors. The bedroom on the upper level offers plenty of sleeping room. Property can sleep 10+ with lower level being fully finished. Living space, including kitchen, eating area, great room, and a full bath on the main level. The main level also features a wood burning heat stove. Even more living space can be enjoyed in the fully finished lower level with a full bath! This property comes fully furnished with a pull out queen sleeper couches on main and lower level. Upper and lower decks offer lovely, tranquil view of the lake below. Boathouse with a boat lift and dock for fun in the sun! Don't miss this opportunity to own your piece of paradise. Contact us today to schedule a tour and make this lake cottage your dream retreat!

3160 E Buckhorn, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Tremper Coblentz, tremper.coblentz@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

Selling Office: Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC..

$310,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 5017949 MLS
This is a great opportunity to have a home at Lake Buckhorn that really has the warm, cozy lakehouse feel that most Buckhorn buyers are looking for at the Lake. This is an Estate and is sold “AS-IS”. The limited items remaining in the house are included and will transfer to the buyers on title transfer. This home is across the street from the lake and near the very popular Area 8 Rec Area. This cedar-sided home with log beam interior has no drywall. It is a warm, cozy feel buyer that loves the wood look. Nice kitchen with hickory cabinets w pull-out shelves, stainless steel appliances, soaring beamed ceiling, wood floors and entirely open to the Great Room with its wood burning stove. There are 2 bedrooms and a nice full bath on the main floor. Upstairs is a Large Open Loft with log beams that overlooks the Great Room and a 10x4 exterior balcony. There is a 30x8 elevated deck on the front of the house toward the lake. There is a 24x12 deck on the back of the house with a 10x4 balcony above. There also is a 42x6 wrap-around deck. The basement is full with laundry & workshop area. It has a walk-out, but doesn’t really seem as if it would be a good finished area. The huge garage & yard are highlights of property. The 3 car garage w barn-siding walls and a 2nd story with a pulldown staircase. Not pulldown steps; actual stairs. The is a half bath and a motorized pulley system to the 2nd floor. There is a heater. The garage was set up as a great workshop with vacuum system. Will be a Fabulous man cave. The home is on 3 lots totaling 1.19 Acres. The property is really nice w wall accent walls. Lake Buckhorn is a 1,120 Acre gated community in the heart of Amish country. The lake is about 2 miles long w Rec Areas along the lake as well as throughout the community off lake. Whether you enjoy fishing (well stocked ), skiing, wakeboarding, tubing, swimming, wake surfing, picnicking, kayaking, paddle boarding … there is something for everyone. PICKLEBALL & TENNIS

2350 Bern Drive Unit 61,75&76, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: The Right Choice- Kirch Realty.

$58,000
5016219 MLS
Very nice building site composed of 2 lots totaling 0.83 Acres near Area 4 (pavillon, rental docks, grill). 110feet front, 221feet right side, 246feet left side & 223feet in the rear. This site is across the street from Area 4 and there is an dditional nature rec area to the right of the building site which continues across the back of the site. Lake Buckhorn is a private, gated, 1,120 Acre community featuring a pristine lake, rolling terrain and heavily treed. It truly is breathtakingly beautiful. There are 2 beaches, multiple Rec Areas with pavillons & rental docks, incredible boating and fishing, social hall, tennis courts, pickleball courts, and a ball field. The 225 Acres Lake is nearly 2 miles long and beautiful.

591 & 592 W Buckhorn Drive Unit 591&592, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: The Right Choice- Kirch Realty.

$300,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 4480690 MLS
Are you looking for a beautiful property in West Holmes LSD in Lake Buckhorn Association? This is the property for you! With just shy of 2 acres of land this property offers you pristine living and ample indoor and outdoor space! With Buckhorn Lake being just seconds away, you will be able to sit back and relax year round. With 3 Bedrooms/ 2 Full Baths and a half bath, this property boasts ample space for a growing family. With many updates including New Natural Gas, New second Wood Burning Furnace, Newer Windows, New Garage Insulation, New Kitchen Cabinets, and SO much more, you will be able to move right in and add your own finishing touches. This property gives you the option to have Natural Gas Heat or Wood Burning Heat to heat the home which is perfect for various family needs. Did I mention that this home has ample entertaining space, storage space and outdoor space with an extra large 16' x 20' composite/wood deck along with a hot tub? For our car enthusiast, there is a detached garage with its own workshop area! This home has something for everyone. Schedule a showing today to see how you can make this one your own!

2086 Geneva Drive, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Amanda Mercier, amercier@amhghomes.com With EXP Realty, LLC.

Selling Office: EXP Realty, LLC..

$320,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 4480536 MLS
CEDAR Log Home on a lovely wooded setting in glorious Lake Buckhorn right on Buckhorn Drive. Terrific, desirable home that is neat as a pin. Great quiet retreat! This home sets on 3 wooded lots totaling 1.33 Acre which are extremely peaceful with lots of song birds and deer visiting on a daily basis. The floor plan features open living areas with open kitchen looking out into eating area as well as the large Great Room with a gas fireplace. There are triple french door from the Great Room as well as the eating area out onto the inviting elevated 28 x 10 deck overlooking the wooded lot. The Great Room/Kitchen/Dining Area has a vaulted ceiling with knotty "barn siding" on the ceiling creating a warmth and charm that envelopes and embraces not just you, but also your heart. The pair of triple french doors (6 total panels) provide wonderful natural light and tranquil views. The woods behind as well as on the sides of this home provide just a nice serene setting. The furnace-5yrs old, Centr

2265 W Buckhorn Drive Unit 751, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: Woodlawn Real Estate LLC.

$200,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 4497408 MLS
This home provides what we crave ... stress-free days that most people look for at the Lake where we say ... "we are at the Lake" and when we are at the Lake, we want to feel like WE ARE AT THE LAKE ... OUR RETREAT" Rare opportunity to find a home in the Lake Buckhorn community at this entry-point pricing. Metal Roof Gutters & Downspouts in 2017This home sits on a very quiet 1.4 Acre site at the very northwest portion of incredible Lake Buckhorn !!! Four private lots at the end of Stammheim each 75x203.58. You don’t see ANY Neighboring homes. This is an extremely quiet portion of the Lake Buckhorn community where rarely a car passes … sweet opportunity for a serene get-a-way. Great location with a wooded views to the front and sides as well as 200-acre farm to the rear that also has a treed perimeter. What a great opportunity for a super Get-A-Way home or Weekender ... though the home is a full time home for the present owner. Also has a large shed. The very inviting and warm spacious Great Room is TERRIFIC with "barn-siding" on the walls and ceiling. The Great Room is always the focal point of a home .. where you spend most of your time. The Great Room with beamed ceiling, 2 skylights, and a warm & cozy woodburning stove also is adorned with custom Barn Door shutters on front and rear windows. The Open Kitchen overlooks the great room and also the backyard and the vast adjacent farm. The lower level provides space for a 2nd bedrm or large bunk room w private half bath.

2833 Stammheim Drive Unit 893, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC..

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.