Millersburg Ohio Homes for Sale

Lake Buckhorn Homes for Sale - Millersburg, Ohio

$429,500
4 Beds 2 Baths 5229752 MLS
Just 10 Years Old, and when you walk through it, you will think it is newer. This SCHLABACH-BUILT 3 BEDROOM, 2 BATH FULL RANCH Home offers ONE FLOOR LIVING with its Convenient 1st FLOOR LAUNDRY off the Hall by the bedrooms. The home is Meticulously Cared for by the Loving Owners who built it. Every inch of the Beautiful Landscape & Fine Interior show the Meticulous Care that this home has received since the day it was built. You'll love the pretty curb appeal of the home w the appealing aesthetics of the Large 2-CAR SIDE LOAD Garage as well as the convenience of the size of the garage. As you walk up the front walk you will be greeted by lovely landscaping and an INVITING COVERED FRONT SITTING PORCH. Upon entering the Front Door you will be Welcomed by the OPEN FLOOR PLAN, the focal point of which is the Lovely Kitchen with the GRANITE ISLAND BREAKFAST BAR, STAINLESS STEEL APPLIANCES, Large Pantry and wonderful views of the Large Rear STAMPED CONCRETE PATIO and Large Rear Yard [1.1ACRE]w Tall Emerald Green Arborvitae as well as Green Giant Pyramidal Arborvitae for Spectacular Privacy. The Living Room, Dining Room and OPEN KITCHEN flow wonderfully together for family and entertaining. The MASTER SUITE with PRIVATE EN-SUITE Bath with shower, 2 additional bedrooms, nice FULL Bath, CONVENIENT 1ST FLOOR LAUNDRY with Laundry Sink and additional storage and open staircase to the partially finished WALK-OUT Basement complete the 1st floor. Most of the Living Areas feature Long Lasting, Easy Care LUXURY VINYL FLOORING that flows beautifully throughout the home. This home is just short distance from the Convenient Time-Saving MEMBER ONLY North Gate. Highly desired Area 8 Rec Area is the closest Rec Area for access to the Lake. The LAKE BUCKHORN COMMUNITY features 1,120 ACRES w the Lake being 220 of those Acres. The are 2 Beaches, a Social Hall, 5 Pavillons, 2 PlayGrounds, PickleBall & Tennis Courts, Softball Field, Boat Launches & Multiple REC AREAS throughout the Community.

7595 Arbon Drive, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

$350,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 5229754 MLS
SPACIOUS 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath (plumbed for 3rd Bath), Vinyl Sided split level home with METAL ROOF sits on a VERY PRIVATE SETTING in THE WONDERFUL LAKE BUCKHORN COMMUNITY. VERY PRIVATE LOCATION...No other homes are visible behind (Pond/Rec Area that is Heavily Treed) this home, to the sides or even across the street when the leaves are on the TALL, MATURE TREES Surrounding this 2.07 ACRE SETTING with a WOODED RAVINE on the most southerly lot for continued Privacy. This home also OVERLOOKS the Private NorthWest Fishing Pond. Views of the Pond through the filtering of the Tall, Mature Woods to the rear of this home. In addition to this Lovely Home with an ATTACHED 2-CAR SIDE LOAD Garage, there is a 2-STORY OUTBUILDING 28x24 w dedicated 200 AMP electric service (200volt outlet is in). Upper levels is drywalled and has nice laminate flooring. Lower level is 90% finished w plywood walls. HEATED & AIR CONDITIONED. Upper level is well suited for your hobbies or a studio. Lower for Carpentry, tinkering w autos etc. The SERENELY Located rear deck off the dining room overlooks the mature trees on 3 sides and the stocked north west pond down below. The DECK is built with Nearly MAINTENANCE-FREE COMPOSITE DECKING, VINYL POSTS & RAILS & Metal ballisters. ThIS OPEN FLOOR PLAN home features 3 Bedrooms, 2 Baths, Very Nice CUSTOM AMISH-Built CHERRY Finish CABINETRY by MULLET CABINETS, MASTER SUITE w PRIVATE EN-SUITE Bath has shower over the tub, Large FAMILY ROOM, a nice Living Room & Dining Room. Most of the Living Areas feature Long Lasting, Easy Care LUXURY VINYL FLOORING. Full CEMENT Driveway and Private Rear Deck. This is just a short distance from the desirable NORTH BEACH at the Rec Area 7. The LAKE BUCKHORN COMMUNITY features 1,120 ACRES with the Lake composing 220 of those Acre. The are 2 Beaches, a Social Hall, 5 Pavillons, 2 PlayGrounds, PickleBall Courts, Tennis Courts, Softball Field, Boat Launches, Multiple REC AREAS throughout the Community. VERY ATTRACTIVE FEES !!!

2699 Ruswil Drive, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

$545,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 5218821 MLS
This home won the Award for the BEST NEW HOME in the County the year it was built. The Innovative Foresight in this floor plan is Astonishing! Perfectly set up for MULTI-GENERATIONAL LIVING or Family & Friends visiting you at your LAKEHOUSE RETREAT. This is a wonderful 4 Bedrm, 4 FULL BATH, 1 Half Bath 2,468 sqft CUSTOM-DESIGNED, RANCH STYLE LOG HOME on OVER AN ACRE in Our Beautiful Lake Buckhorn Community. "Come join Our LAKE BUCKHORN FAMILY." Your Log Home features a 74-Foot COVERED WRAP-AROUND DECK [inviting you to RELAX and feel all STRESS GO AWAY.], (2) 15x12 SCREENED PORCHES, a 20x14 ENTERTAINMENT PATIO, Fenced area for pets, 36 x 24 3-CAR GARAGE, Majestic Vaulted Wood-Beamed Ceilings in the open GREAT ROOM area, 2 Private Suites, & a massive FULL BASEMENT if you want even more room. 30x30 GREAT ROOM AREA w River Rock WOODBURNING Fireplace; Huge Beamed, Soaring, WOOD Ceilings Accented by 4 SKYLights; Open DINING AREA featuring an Inviting BAY WINDOW; and Large OPEN KITCHEN w ISLAND BREAKFAST BAR. Newer HIGH-END APPLIANCES. The home is set up w TWO near identical SUITES, one on each side of the Home creating the Much Desired “Split Bedroom Floor Plan”. Each suite has a Nice-Sized Sitting/TV Area and 2 Separate Bdrms each w a Private FULL BATH & 15X12 SCREENED PORCH. Enjoy the COMFORT & BENEFITS of the Very Economical GEOTHERMAL heating & cooling system. Brand NEW FURNACE & CENTRAL AIR being installed early July ($24,000). THIS IS A TRULY SPECIAL HOME! Lake Buckhorn is a private, gated lake community of 1,120 Acres including a pristine 220 Acre lake that is perfect for skiing, tubing, relaxing … and great fishing. The community has multiple pavilions, 2 beaches, boat docks, ponds and a wonderful Community SOCIAL HALL lodge. All the street are private. The entire community is a densely wooded retreat of rolling beauty. Join Our BUCKHORN FAMILY…YOU WILL LOVE IT!

2653 Constance Drive, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

$375,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 5214613 MLS
Being Sold TURNKEY! When you walk through the front door your eyes will immediately be drawn to the Soaring WALL OF WINDOWS in the Great Room and the natural views. The open floor plan greets you with the open living area encompassing the Great Room, Kitchen and Spacious Eating Area all under a soaring Vaulted Ceiling with a Large Beam that puts an exclamation mark the room and a smile on your face when you return home. This feels like HOME, not just a house. The kitchen is a SCHROCK Kitchen with an Attractive ISLAND with Raised Panel Side Cabinets. The Great Room features a corner gas fireplace; to be converted to gas from propane. This is a Very Nice Home that feels much newer than its 26 year age. It is a Wonderful location quietly tucked away in an area of nice homes of this Lake Buckhorn Community. No other homes are visible to the rear of the house. The only view you have from your low maintenance composite & vinyl deck will be trees & treetops from this low maintenance vinyl-sided home. There are 2 Bedrooms and a Full Bath to the rear of the home. Topping off the 1st floor is peaceful composite & vinyl rear deck for coffee, meals, refreshment and relaxation. Upstairs is a Very Large Loft Bedroom with Wonderful Views through the Soaring Wall of Windows at the end of the Great Room. The Loft is adorned with the same Beam that extends through the ceiling of the Living Area below. The WALKOUT Basement has another FULL BATH & a room that obviously was thought of as future expansion for a bedroom when the home was built. The main open area that you step into when you come down the stairs would be a lovely Family Room w large DayLight windows & French Doors to the area under the deck above. This home has been a Wonderful Get-A-Way for the present owners to enjoy. It seem perfect for a get-a-way home. Finishing the basement and it certainly could be a fulltime home. This is an opportunity to join Lake Buckhorn & enjoy all this spectacular community offers.

7917 Flawil Drive, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

$825,000
3 Beds 4 Baths 5202577 MLS
Terrific REMODELED LAKEFRONT with 288 FEET OF LAKE FRONTAGE (rather than customary 120 feet) being sold TURNKEY including the John Deere Gator [Pontoon Boat is excluded, but is negotiable]. Another plus for this home is that the Area Down by the LAKE IS PRETTY MUCH FLAT as compared to MOST LAKE BUCKHORN LAKEFRONT HOMES. LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION! This home is MUCH Larger than it looks from the street. SPECTACULAR ADDITION … TOTAL REMODEL gave this home that all important “LAKEHOUSE FEEL”. When you’re at the lake, you want to be RELAXED WITH THE LAKE BEING YOUR FAVORITE PLACE! Call today! This LAKEFRONT home in the wonderful 1,120 Acre LAKE BUCKHORN Community with a pristine lake nearly 2 miles long offers 3 Bedrooms, 4 FULL Baths 2 KITCHENS (Beautiful Main Kitchen on the 1st Floor + kitchen in the WALK OUT BEAUTIFULLY FINISHED LOWER LEVEL), a HEAVENLY SCREENED PORCH overlooking the lake and woods, 2 Fireplaces (1 Woodburner + 1 gas) a WONDERFUL WALKOUT Lower Level with another FAMILY ROOM, 2nd Large MASTER SUITE with sliders OVERLOOKING THE LAKE and WALKS OUT TO THE PATIO. Wonderful CHEF’s KITCHEN with ISLAND, Large Eating area, Wall oven w/ warming drawer. It is GORGEOUS! The 1st Floor MASTER SUITE includes a Jacuzzi tub, Separate Shower, Dual Sinks and a Skylight. Relaxing Outdoor living off both levels with an EXPANSIVE easy Care Composite Deck with VINYL RAILINGS and patios extending the length of the home on the Lakeside and the best part … an INVITING SCREENED PORCH. Lighted cement drive to the composite DOCK with BOAT LIFT. There also is a Yard Shed. You will be impressed by the quality in this home and the near perfection the owners have shown in its maintenance. It is located between Rec Area 6 & Rec Area 7 [the quiet North Beach area] in a relaxing No Wake Zone. Don’t wait make this home your Lifelong Dreamed About Piece of Heaven for you family and friends. Memories are made at Lake Buckhorn .. and made even more special on the LAKEFRONT.

2594 W Buckhorn Drive, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

$365,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 5208700 MLS
Uniquely, quiet location at wonderful Lake Buckhorn which features a near 2 mile long lake for skiing, fishing, swimming, etc. This home sits on a very FLAT LOT which is something that is quite unusual in the Lake Buckhorn community. The peacefulness and serenity of this home, especially the rear yard…it’s simply wonderful. With bushes across the back, untouched wooded lot to the north of the house, (part of the property) and a 71 acre farm to the rear, it is heavenly. This home is located on a street that is a loop street which has ONLY 5 Homes and a serene ravine to the south of the loop. If you yearn for quiet solitude, combined w the comforting security of having neighbors nearby but not too close, this is a home that you should look at before it’s gone. It lives larger than looks. The home features a 1st floor master suite w en suite bath & walk-in closet. There is a 2nd FULL Bath & a den/bedroom on the 1st floor along w the large Eat-In Kitchen w ISLAND & nice sized living rm. The windows of nearly all of rooms feature views of nature not neighboring homes. Upstairs, there are 2 bedrooms, 1 large & 1 extremely large featuring two wide closets and a FULL Bath + large area that could be a computer/study room between the 2 bedrooms. It’s a 4 BEDROOM, 3 FULL Bath home though the one bedroom (w ADJACENT FULL BATH) on the 1st floor may be used as a den. The kitchen is spacious & extremely nice w the popular WHITE Cabinets, ISLAND, large dining room-sized Eating area w sliders out to the deck and terrific views from the window over the kitchen sink and the sliding doors in Eating area. I’m sure the new owners will spend a great deal of time on the 20 x 10 deck in the rear of the house off of the Eating area. It is a very serene, peaceful & beautiful spot to spend your time w your morning coffee or relaxing in the evenings. There is a very spacious 24x24 garage off the laundry room & FULL unfinished basement waiting for your plans to fit you best. Call today

7938 Interlaken Drive, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC..

$555,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 5204413 MLS
This LAKEFRONT home on TWO LOTS being sold Turkey AT UNDER $600,000 is quite an opportunity for an astute buyer. This rustic home with the metal roof new in the fall of 2025features two bedrooms and two baths on the main floor, possibly a very large sleeping loft above that our looks the great room and kitchen. Master bedroom has a private bath. The kitchen has a breakfast bar plus a kitchen table area. There’s lots and lots of WINDOWS AND SLIDERS on the EAST-FACING LAKESIDE OF THE HOME. This home is being sold, turn key, including everything even the John Deere gator and the pontoon boat. There are steps to from the house to the lake as well as a cement drive down to the lake for easy and comfort access to the lakefront where you’ll find a full dock with a boathouse. This home is located such that the boathouse is in an awake area. . This home is located such that the boathouse is in a No Wake area so swimming and fishing is certainly more comfortable and safer. There is a 8 x 33’ deck off of the great room. Add the cement patio down below on the basement level. There also is a quiet inviting 19x 9 screened porch on the side of the home set among tall trees, and pine trees with beautiful views of the lake and this wonderful natural setting. The kitchen, great room and loft have very tall vaulted ceilings that are adorned with beautiful rustic wood planks. N

2636 W Buckhorn Drive, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: The Right Choice- Kirch Realty.

$89,500
5201972 MLS
Wonderful building site of 4 lots very near popular Recreational Area #8. It is a very short walk to Recreational Area #8 and there is an off-lake rec area that abuts the rear of this building site. This building site is TWICE the size of normal Lake Buckhorn sites. It is 1.41 ACRES. The frontage is 310 feet. The sides are 200 feet & 198 feet with a rear width of 310 feet. Additionally, there is a 4.37 Acre Rec Area to the rear of this building site. This area where no other home will be built another attractive feature of this site. It is a well treed site which gradually slopes up toward the rear of the lot easily allowing for a walkout basement which creates wonderful living area at a lower cost. Lake Buckhorn is a Private Gated Recreational Community in the heart of Amish country located 1-1/2 hours from either Cleveland, Columbus or Akron. The 1,120 Acre community is Truly GORGEOUS with its rolling terrain, dense woods, abundant nature and very clean lake. When you drive through the gates your stress levels immediately lessen. Our Lake is very clean and Beautiful offering plenty of recreational opportunities with the near 2 mile long lake, multiple rec areas, 2 beaches, 2 playgrounds, clubhouse, tennis & pickleball courts. If " when I'm at the Lake, I want to FEEL like I have left the stress of the day-to-day world behind and I am relaxed and comfortable" describes what you are looking for, call today and come visit Lake Buckhorn tomorrow. [only 1 house allowed per deed restrictions]

1524-1527 E Buckhorn Drive, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

$187,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 5168026 MLS
Discover this rare opportunity to own one of only four homes on a private street in the highly sought-after Lake Buckhorn gated community. Set on three large, level lots, this property offers space, privacy, and direct access to an abundance of community amenities—including the pickleball, basketball, tennis courts, ball field, main lodge, and the lake’s primary swimming beach with umbrella shade structures and a playground. Thoughtfully updated, this home features a metal roof and foundation upgrades (2016) and numerous 2024 upgrades, including new windows, drywalled ceilings, fixtures, fans, with additional insulation, luxury vinyl plank flooring, and fresh interior paint. Step outside to enjoy a stunning 10x44 covered raised back porch with soffit ceiling, new gutters and downspouts, and freshly stained decks (2025). The property also includes new raised garden beds for those who love outdoor living and gardening. The interior welcomes you with an open-concept living space filled with natural light, ideal for entertaining or relaxing. The spacious primary bedroom comfortably fits a king-size bed and offers flexibility for additional furnishings. A separate storage building with electric, lighting, and RV hookup provides extra functionality, while a covered patio area doubles as a grilling space or convenient parking for a UTV. This agent-owned property, located just minutes from Millersburg and the heart of Amish Country, blends modern comfort with the peaceful lifestyle of a lake community. Perfect as a full-time residence or a weekend retreat—a true gem in Lake Buckhorn!

7771 Buckhorn Cove, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Mary Mason, agentsrealty1@gmail.com With Agents Realty & Auction Service

Selling Office: Howard Hanna Real Estate Services.

$400,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 5156203 MLS
ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE VIEWS of the Lake and the COUNTRY SIDE from this home which sits up high enough for panoramic views not only of this gorgeous Lake, but also of the abounding nature of the Holmes County countryside!!!!! There are only a very few homes in the Lake Buckhorn Community with any lake views unless they are right lakefront and in a much higher price range.. This home has great views of the Lake, Astounding Countryside Views & $150,000+ REMODELING & IMPROVEMENTS by Croft Construction in 2018!!! Since 2019 the present owner has added a Large CEMENT DRIVEWAY including 2 ADJACENT PARKING SPOTS, NEW METAL ROOF ON THE HOUSE AND THE ATTACHED 2-1/2 CAR GARAGE, A NEW ROOF ON THE DETACHED 32x24 OUTBUILDING out behind the house where the present owner crafted A SUPER, SUPER NICE “MAN CAVE” ABOVE on THE SECOND FLOOR OF THE OUTBUILDING (REAR GARAGE). There is new easy care flooring throughout most of the house. This is truly an incredible opportunity to really enjoy not only Lake Buckhorn, but the beauty of the entire gorgeous, rolling Holmes County Countryside. Opportunities like this are Few & Far Between. Be the first to view this home!! The improvement completed in 2018 by the prior owner were completed for the owner's own enjoyment and t high quality levels and then circumstances happened that required a sale. It likely will be many years before an opportunity like this will comes about again at Lake Buckhorn. The updates to this home seem endless. Extensive WRAP AROUND Maintenance-free TREX Decking & Railing system with impressive views of Lake Buckhorn & the rolling Holmes County countryside. Whole house backup generator. Entire exterior of the home has been renovated with cultures stone, vinyl siding & NEW WINDOWS & NEW DOORS. There are Remodeled Baths, New Lower-Level Walk-Out Family Room (includes kitchenette) w Wood-Plank Look ceramic tile that is incredibly popular. The remodeling has been done w high quality choices for all of the improvements.

1743 W Buckhorn Drive, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: The Right Choice- Kirch Realty.

$360,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 5146019 MLS
This lovely RANCH HOME featuring an Open Floorplan w/ 3 BEDROOMS & 2 FULL BATHS on the main floor plus a LARGE RECREATION ROOM w WOODBURNING STOVE, BEDROOM & FULL BATH on the DAYLIGHT Lower level is located just a 1/2 MILE from the MAIN BOAT LAUNCH & 3/4 MILE from the MAIN BEACH. This one owner home has been Lovingly Updated and Cared For. RECENT UPDATES include a BRAND NEW ROOF AUGUST 1, 2025, Basement Bedroom Carpeted in July 2025, Nice Vinyl Flooring through Most Of The House and Basement Rec Room SPRING of 2025. NEW KITCHEN COUNTERTOPS were put in AUGUST 2025 and the ENTIRE INTERIOR WAS FRESHLY PAINTED IN 2025. As you walk through the front door, you are Embraced by High Ceilings, Natural Light, & an Open Floor Plan where you immediately are greeted by the living room, dining room and kitchen. Living room features tall vaulted ceilings, a beautiful Propane Fireplace with a large television mounted to the wall above it, new stylish ceiling fan, and Large BREATHTAKING FRONT WINDOW ... Round Top Palladium Style. The dining room which is open to the living room and the kitchen has a large sliding glass door opening out onto the private deck and also has wonderful views of the very private backyard where adorable dear families visit nearly daily. The well appointed kitchen which overlook the living room & dining room features Quality, STAINLESS STEEL APPLIANCES and BRAND NEW COUNTERTOPS & GARBAGE DISPOSAL. There’s a Large PANTRY step away from the kitchen. There is a 1ST FLOOR MASTER SUITE w EN SUITE BATH & Large WALK-IN CLOSET. There are 2 more bedrooms and a full bath along with a nice laundry room. that complete the first floor. The garage is a 2-1/2 car garage extra deep it’s 560 ft.². The very nicely finished lower level features a 26x16 rec room with a wood-burning fireplace, 10 x 12 office/bedroom with adjacent full bath. There also is a very spacious storage area in the basement. The lot is a very private 8/10ths of an acre. This home is Move-In ready.

1910 Susten Drive, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: Olde Town Realty.

$300,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 5132118 MLS
Spacious home with an extensive wraparound deck & very nice location w distant views & privacy in the rear of the lot. It has both a 2-car ((back of home)& a 1-car garage(front of home). This home has lots to offer and still additional potential. This low maintenance BRICK RANCH sits on just under an acre and has 1,638 sqft finished on the main level, approximately 660 sqft finished in the Walk-Out basement and an great 744 sqft elevated deck with spectacular views. There’s also a 12x10 shed. Master suite was added in 2018 to the rear of the house w great master bath, including a large 6x4 tile shower w multiple heads. There also is a 10x10 walk-in closet with a window viewing the lovely backyard. The master suite includes a door which can walk out to that large wraparound deck 9when it’s extended0. The present owner changed the heat over to Natural Gas (40 budget) and expanded the kitchen and put in new high-quality cabinets and granite countertops. The Owner also added the beamed covered porch to the front of the house. An ew Metal Roof was put on in 2018. New soffits, gutter updates & ScreensThe Kitchen is open to the large living room featuring a large bow window with window seat that brings the outdoors inside. At the end of the living room is a Anderson French Door that provides a spectacular view of the horizon. View the pictures and you will imagine enjoying the beautiful sunsets. The finished basement features an efficient woodburning stove, double-hung window, open staircase from the main floor liv rm, an oversized 8-foot sliding door to the back yard and an exterior spiral staircase up to the deck for convenient entertaining. There also is a stairs from the 1-car garage to the basement for convenience if you have hobbies or want to bring wood to the woodburner. The main bathroom has been remodeled with a large vanity with dual sinks, a tall linen cabinet, and a low maintenance tub/shower surround. The bedrooms feature oak hardwood floors.

2179 Rhone Drive, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: Agents Realty & Auction Service.

$925,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 5141033 MLS
FULLY FURNISHED, BOAT INCLUDED! There is still time to enjoy the private community of Lake Buckhorn this summer. This newer construction, fully furnished, including boat & dock is thoughtfully equipped with stylish furniture, linens, kitchenware, and décor—move in and start enjoying lake life immediately. This immaculate home offers 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths, and attached garage. Ideal layout for families, guests, or groups complete with quality finishes and thoughtful design throughout. Through the accordion door outdoor living is elevated with spacious deck that embraces sunshine at sunrise and tranquil sunsets over the water. Well-crafted concrete steps descend gracefully toward the water’s edge and lead directly to your private dock, which is equipped with power boat lift for the 2020 Angler Quest (115 mercury, 4 stroke pontoon) and deck area for entertaining. These particular lots offer perfect view of main lake area but are inside the low wake zone allowing for a peaceful environment that supports recreational activities like fishing and simply relaxing by the water. This gated community is centered around a 220 acre lake surrounded by wooded hillsides. Amenities include: picnic areas & playgrounds, beaches, fishing ponds, event hall, and basketball, tennis, pickleball, softball areas.

3190 E Buckhorn Dr, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Crystal Horn, crystal.horn@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

Selling Office: Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC..

$570,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 5132113 MLS
LAKEFRONT living at LAKE BUCKHORN at an AFFORDABLE Price Truly is attainable. And this home is conveniently being sold TURNKEY. BUY TODAY and start enjoying the incredible LAKE HOME Lifestyle starting tomorrow...NOW! A lifestyle few are so blessed to experience. Come see this Beautifully updated 3 bedroom, 2 full bath LAKEFRONT HOME with a Stunning 2-STORY GREAT ROOM with soaring wood plank ceilings, wood-burning stove and hardwood flooring. The welcoming wood flooring also extends into the Large Casual Eating Area and Breakfast Bar with room for 4 bar stools. DECKS OFF ALL 3 LEVELS Adorned by the Beauty of Mother Nature. Off the top level deck is a FIREPIT for sharing memories with family and friends! A nice size kitchen with Breakfast bar for 4 is well equipped for entertaining family and friends. The kitchen opens to the Great Room perfect for socializing with two sets of large sliding doors out to the Spacious Wonderful 38X11 deck built with very Low Maintenance COMPOSITE DECKING and RAILS. The finished lower level walkout features a wood-burning fireplace, billiard room, large wet bar and an additional full bath. It also has sliders walking out to the lower deck with steps to the upper deck creating additional entertaining space. The upper level of this home features spacious loft with three beds and a walkout door to the 16x16 upper deck with adjacent Firepit sitting area.The large loft overlooks the great room with Grand Views toward the lake out the WALL OF WINDOWS of the lakeside Great Room. At the lakefront you will have your own piece of heaven on you dock/deck sitting on the water in a quiet No Wake area with a private boathouse and a boatlift to keep your boat ready for on-the-water fun. During the winter season you will appreciate the wood-burning stove insert in the fireplace of the great room which will create a warm and cozy, peaceful setting as you watch the snowflakes float down through the wall windows in the great room.

2650 W Buckhorn Drive Unit 823, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: The Right Choice- Kirch Realty.

$250,000
2 Beds 1 Baths 5132112 MLS
This is an excellent opportunity to live in Lake Buckhorn at very near the low end of the price range of our breathtaking Lake. Very Nice 2 Bedroom Ranch Home w/ a Large Attached Garage, Outbuilding, a Finished Walk-Out Lower Level with a rear garage door on just under a near flat Acre. With such an already large garage, the original garage on the lower level could be finished into a wonderful family Room with sliding Door out to the backyard. This would be an ideal opportunity to add more finished living area. Open kitchen/living room floor plan …CALL TODAY. The home also has a recently added 26x26 Garage, Partial Cement Driveway, and 19x10 Elevated Deck. The lot is 105Front x 235S x 239Back x 243S. It is just about 9/10 of a Acre. The location is very nice with no homes behind it and conveniently located a short distance from the main entrance of the Lake, but almost no traffic passes the house at this tranquil location. The softball field is in the distance along with the pickleball courts, tennis courts and basketball hoops. The Home has central air, has been converted to Natural Gas and has a newer furnace in late 2019. There also is an additional shower in the lower level. In the summer you will love the Central Air Conditioning. Lake Buckhorn is a truly Awesome & BEAUTIFUL Gated Community featuring a pristine 225-Acre Lake, Gorgeous Rolling Terrain. It is a Densely Wooded Private Community w/ a Social Hall. If you come visit us, don't be surprised if you fall in love ... with Lake Buckhorn. Whether you want to Swim, Ski, Tube, Wakeboard, or just Cruise on your Pontoon, Lake Buckhorn makes all of these activity even more enjoyable just by how Gorgeous it is. The $1,085/year cost is such an incredible opportunity to enjoy so much for so little ! These fees include a gated security system, trash, social hall, pavillons, beaches, boating, community and street maintenance, gorgeous views, ponds and picnic areas! Call for a Private Tour of this secluded Paradise.

7757 Buckhorn Cove Unit 1665-1666, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC..

$850,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 5107863 MLS
Custom builder, Walnut Valley Log Homes, took one of its most desirable floorplans that they build and improved it. View some of the pictures below of the completed home which this home was modeled after. This floorplan has been very well received. Crafting this home, the builder made it larger, and fine tuned it idyllically for this wonderful 1.3 Acre Wooded lot full of Mature Trees that perfectly frames the home. You will appreciate the lovely Lakehouse Style and Low Maintenance of the Cultured Stone, Vinyl-Sided Exterior and Metal Roof. When you are at the lake you want to enjoy the activities, solitude, and relaxation of your home; not be a slave to the maintenance. As you arrive you are welcomed by a 36-foot covered porch which beckons you to sit and take in the solace of the treed side yard; even on a rainy day. As you enter the home you are greeted by the Soaring 2-Story Great Room with its featured Prow Wall w Soaring Cultured Stone Gas Fireplace, flanked by 2 PELLA Sliding Doors w Transom Windows to invite you out to the large Trex Deck. The Great Room adjoins the Open Kitchen with a Breakfast Bar Island, Hickory Cabinets & Granite Countertops. There is a Private 1st Floor Master Suite w the privacy of ensuite bath & convenient washer & dryer hookup. The upper level boasts a Loft overlooking the Great Room & Fireplace and with Views of Nature through the Dual 2nd Story PELLA Trapazoid Windows. This spot can be your reading area, computer nook, etc. There also are 2 more bedrooms and a full bath on the upper level. The full Basement encompassing 1,200sqft is pre-plumbed for another full bath for future expansion to the new owners desires. There are Sliding Doors in the basement which lead to a 360sqft concrete patio perfect to walk out to a relaxing area for a future firepit. Intuitive pre-planning, the builder put an egress window w stepped window well for a future additional bedroom if the new owner desires. YOU WILL LOVE EVERYTHING ABOUT LAKE BUCKHORN !!!

7636 ARBON Drive Unit 1222, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: Howard Hanna Real Estate Services.

$74,000
5078525 MLS
So many Lake Buckhorn buyers are looking for lakefront, but at times the price of a lakefront home or lot is out of reach. Inevitably their next question is, "what about a home with a lake view?" At Lake Buckhorn, we literally only have about a dozen Lakeview properties, none of which are for sale now or expected to be for sale in the near future. This Lot is an opportunity to have a Lakeview property and DESIGN THE HOME TO BE EXACTLY AS YOU WANT IT. This 104Front x 258Side x 129Rear x 217Side Lot has a gradual slope that is perfect for a FINISHED WALKOUT BASEMENT toward the Lake. A finished Walkout Basement is a very cost-effective way to design your home for yourself and your guests. This 6/10 acre lot offers spectacular views of the lake and is a very short walk away from the main beach with a pavilion and playground and just a bit further is the boat launch area. The soil report for septic approval have been done for septic design, permit, so then you are ready to build Your LAKEVIEW DREAM HOME. Water, electricity, natural gas are the front of the lot. Lake Buckhorn is a gorgeous community sitting among the rolling terrain of Holmes County and amidst Amish Country. LAKE BUCKHORN is a heavily treed, rural area ... there is nothing suburbanite about Lake Buckhorn. It is located just 10 minutes south of the Millersburg Square. This is a fantastic opportunity to purchase a lot at Lake Buckhorn with access to our 220 acre pristine lake. The wonderful amenities at Lake Buckhorn include a social hall accommodating up to 200 guests with an expansive deck overlooking the lake, multiple recreation areas, [both lakefront and off the lake], 2 beaches, 2 children’s playgrounds, 5 pavilions, multiple places to launch your boats, Pickleball, tennis and basketball courts and a softball field. Our LAKE is great for fishing, skiing, all boating activities. This lot is conveniently located on the east side of the lake only about a 1/4 mile from the gate … sunsets ? YES !

3877 E Buckhorn Drive Unit 257+, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: The Right Choice- Kirch Realty.

$225,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 5075636 MLS
LAKE BUCKHORN 1.4 Acres Lot ! Great location with Wooded Views to the front of the house and sides and literally 100s of acres of farmland to the rear of the this home. The side lots also have a treed perimeter. When you have a lakehouse at Lake Buckhorn you don't want to be doing a lot of maintenance. This low maintenance home (Trex Decking w maintenance-free railing system & Metal Roof) is in lovely shape and is a great opportunity for a super Get-Away Home or Weekender or for smaller full-time home. Though it is not a huge home, for the previous 2 owners this has been their full-time home. The huge 24x19 Great Room is terrific with a true rustic feel with barn-siding on the walls and ceiling and with beams, skylights, Barn Door Interior Shutters on the windows and a wood-burning stove. Wood burners, in addition to being very economical, they provide a warm, cozy, peaceful ambience. This very inviting & room warm room is a wonderful focal point of this wonderful rustic home. This home is located on FOUR private lots, each is 75x203.5. The lot size of 300 x 203 is 1.4 ACRES at the extremely quiet end of Stammheim Drive. THE VIEWS IN EVERY DIRECTION FROM THIS HOME ARE TRULY AWESOME. Especially from the elevated side TREX DECK with maintenance-free railing system. Enjoy Gorgeous Views from this deck as you relax with your morning coffee or your drink of choice. The French Doors from the Great Room leads to the rear [also Trex] Deck. The metal roof will also give you long-term peace of mind. This is a Tremendous Dream Get-A-Way Home Whether you will use it as a Weekender or Full-Time Home it will provide you with a lovely retreat from the stresses of everyday life. Lake Buckhorn, it’s a private gated community in Holmes County near the largest Amish community. The 225 acre lake is approximately 2 miles long. The pristine Lake Buckhorn community sets on the lovely rolling terrain of Holmes County totaling 1120 acres w lots of trees & beautiful views. You deserve it!

2833 Stammheim Drive Unit 893, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: The Right Choice- Kirch Realty.

$410,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 5069524 MLS
RARE LAKE OPPORTUNITY! Fabulous, Well-Maintained LAKE BUCKHORN LOG HOME situated on 5 wooded lots totaling 2.36 ACRES in the Private Gated Community of LAKE BUCKHORN. The wooded setting brings peace and tranquility and is delightful in all seasons and is refreshingly cool even in the heat of the summer. Nestled in the trees this Log Home features of spacious two-story great room with fireplace and beveled glass windows. The spacious Eat-In Kitchen is graced with Custom Mullet Cabinetry, Granite Countertops, Stainless Steel Appliances, a Farmhouse Sink and plenty of cabinetry/pantry space and counters space for preparing comforting meals while enjoying the panoramic wooded view of Your Retreat! The wraparound porch is the perfect place to spend the morning enjoying breakfast & coffee or unwinding in the evening. RECENT ENHANCEMENTS: NEW ROOF on home, Outbuilding & Gazebo (June 2024); Home & Garage Re-Stained(2022); New Furnace & Whole-house Backup Generator whole house(2016); 50 Gallon Rapid Recovery Hot Water Heater(2022); GE Profile Refrigerator & Microwave(2023); Washer & Dryer(2020); Walk-In Jacuzzi Tub(2022, $11,000); Basement Storm Door(2022); Interior Door in Kitchen(2022). The floorplan is perfect for the entertaining most of us do at Lake Buckhorn with periodic overnight guest and family with Bedrooms and Full Baths on all 3 levels, including the Private Walk-Out Lower Level. This home will give you and your family and friends endless opportunities to create Lifelong Memories. Outside there is a (28x32, 896sqft) 4 car Heated Garage w plenty of overhead storage, (31x15) Barn/Workshop Outbuilding w Upper Floor & an Incredible Screened Gazebo w electricity for fan. This overlooks a Waterfall in the Ravine. Lake Buckhorn amenities include 1,120 Acre; a 225 Acre Well Stocked Lake; multiple Rec Areas Pavilions, Beach Access, Playgrounds; 2 additional Stocked Fishing Ponds; Dock & boating Launch Areas and Lakeview Hall complete with full kitchen & Reception Area.

8125 Geneva Circle, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

$711,000
3 Beds 4 Baths 5065001 MLS
LAKE BUCKHORN LAKEFRONT on 3 Lots with 375 feet of Lake Frontage totaling 1.46 ACRE. This Brick Ranch features 2,285sqft of living area on the main floor, huge Finished Rec Room in the Walk-Out Lower Level, an INDOOR BASKETBALL COURT [AWESOME], an Attached 3-CAR GARAGE + a DETACHED 32x 28 Garage for all your "Lake Toys" and also TWO Boat Lifts with Docks. The home needs updating and maintenance, but this location, this view, is a lakefront opportunity that rarely comes available. Seller wants it Sold! This home sits at a terrific location in a no wake zone but with BIG MAIN LAKE VIEWS ... The Best of Both Worlds. The Large Great Room features a Wood Burning Stone Fireplace, Two 6-foot tall windows and TWO sets of French Doors Overlooking the Lake and walks out to the deck for Spectacular Views. The Kitchen is open to the Great Room and overlooks the Great Room with Nice Views out to the Lake. The living room and dining room are to the front of the home with large windows. The home is built on the middle of three lots with the two side lots being mostly dense trees, providing a PRIVATE OASIS on the back deck and patio overlooking the lake. The Master Suite with dual Walk-In Closets, his & hers and French Doors leading to the Large Deck has a private master bath. The bath has Dual Sinks in the vanity, Separate Shower and Relaxing Jetted Tub. There are 2 additional bedrooms on the main floor. The home has 3 full baths (2 on Main floor+1 on the lower level) plus a 1/2 bath on the main floor. The landscaping is well-designed and simply needs some maintenance It’s truly beautifully landscaped. There is a very large laundry room with lots of built-in cabinets, counterspace, and a built-in ironing board. Think about it, 2,285 square-foot brick Ranch with a large finish basement and indoor basketball court and attach three car oversize garage and a detached 32 x 28 garage +2 boat docs all on 375 feet of lakefront.

1510 W Buckhorn Drive, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: The Right Choice- Kirch Realty.

$915,000
5 Beds 3 Baths 5034155 MLS
This is Truly an EXCEPTIONAL LAKEFRONT Home that was built in 2011, but was lightly used and feels much newer. SELLING TURNKEY. Floorplan and design are TRULY perfect for a lakefront home. Wonderful Open Living Areas on all floors with 5 Bedrooms & 3 Full Baths. This home Comfortably sleeps 13 in beds; not sleeper sofas. Great for entertaining family and friends for good times at OUR LAKEHOUSE. Large, Wonderfully Equipped (Stainless Steel Appliances including a Double Oven), Open, 2-Story, Kitchen with a table for 8, with a leaf to expand to 10 people. The Kitchen is fully open to the Great Room, to the 20 x 14 Composite Deck, to the Loft above and only a few steps from the welcoming 14x14 Screened Porch. The Warm, Inviting 2-Story Great Room is adorned with reclaimed wood floors (as is the entire main floor) and a Stone Woodburning Fireplace (w/ convenient gas starter) and Built-In Bookcases. You will spend a great deal of time in the screened porch as if perched in the trees like a tree house overlooking the lake. This porch also has a stone gas fireplace. The private master suite w dual sinks, full tile shower & large closet; 2nd bedroom with full bath, walk-in pantry finish the main floor. The open staircase from the great room soars to the charming loft and 22-ft bunk room. The Walk-Out lower level features a 2nd great room which is 16x19 with built-in bar and tranquil views of the lake. The 2 additional bedrooms and a full bath finish off the lower level. Just outside the great room is a 34x14 covered stamped concrete patio with stone stairs that lead down to the private composite dock with covered boathouse and a firepit for relaxing evenings. This lake paradise sits next to a huge densely treed rec area that creates privacy..."living in the trees". Enjoy swimming in the no wake cove & watching the annual July 4th fireworks right from your dock. Come join our Buckhorn Family ! "If you are lucky enough to have a home at Lake Buckhorn...You are Lucky Enough! "

1550 W Buckhorn Drive, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: The Right Choice- Kirch Realty.

$505,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 5024338 MLS
WOW! Don't miss your opportunity for a unique setting with wooded privacy and serene lake living at its best. Immaculate low-maintenance home is ready for you to begin enjoying all of Lake Buckhorn’s charms. Geared for fun with family and friends, this 2BR + built-in loft beds, 2 ½ bath natural gas home is so inviting and special, you will love living here. Plenty of space to spread out and entertain overnight guests. A total rebuild in 2009, this home is in pristine condition and has been lovingly cared for. Beautiful custom hickory kitchen cabinetry, extra deep cabinets with granite counters and black splash, stainless steel appliances, generous storage. On chilly days turn down the thermostat and enjoy the attractive Jotul wood stove with gorgeous stone hearth in the two-story great room. Heat pump provides A/C. Dining area overlooks the stunning back yard and lake. The 3-season screen room is a perfect place to relax, listen to the birds, share a meal, take a nap, or sleep the night. Fully finished, carpeted lower level is perfect for watching TV, entertaining, with room to lounge, game, or sleep. Beautiful built-in hickory cabinetry and bookshelves. It has a large full bathroom, plus utility/laundry/mud room with washer/dryer and extra fridge. Walk out to your spacious patio overlooking the back yard, lake, and custom-built fire pit. The patio level offers separate access to a large storage room. Both the house and 3-car heated garage/shop are fully Generac protected. This 1.7 acre property boasts a truly unique location, abutting the North Beach Recreation area where you can swim, play, or dock your boat for the day. Simply walk down through your back yard and you're there!

2637 Buckhorn Cove, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: Donald K. Gant Realty.

$310,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 5017949 MLS
This is a great opportunity to have a home at Lake Buckhorn that really has the warm, cozy lakehouse feel that most Buckhorn buyers are looking for at the Lake. This is an Estate and is sold “AS-IS”. The limited items remaining in the house are included and will transfer to the buyers on title transfer. This home is across the street from the lake and near the very popular Area 8 Rec Area. This cedar-sided home with log beam interior has no drywall. It is a warm, cozy feel buyer that loves the wood look. Nice kitchen with hickory cabinets w pull-out shelves, stainless steel appliances, soaring beamed ceiling, wood floors and entirely open to the Great Room with its wood burning stove. There are 2 bedrooms and a nice full bath on the main floor. Upstairs is a Large Open Loft with log beams that overlooks the Great Room and a 10x4 exterior balcony. There is a 30x8 elevated deck on the front of the house toward the lake. There is a 24x12 deck on the back of the house with a 10x4 balcony above. There also is a 42x6 wrap-around deck. The basement is full with laundry & workshop area. It has a walk-out, but doesn’t really seem as if it would be a good finished area. The huge garage & yard are highlights of property. The 3 car garage w barn-siding walls and a 2nd story with a pulldown staircase. Not pulldown steps; actual stairs. The is a half bath and a motorized pulley system to the 2nd floor. There is a heater. The garage was set up as a great workshop with vacuum system. Will be a Fabulous man cave. The home is on 3 lots totaling 1.19 Acres. The property is really nice w wall accent walls. Lake Buckhorn is a 1,120 Acre gated community in the heart of Amish country. The lake is about 2 miles long w Rec Areas along the lake as well as throughout the community off lake. Whether you enjoy fishing (well stocked ), skiing, wakeboarding, tubing, swimming, wake surfing, picnicking, kayaking, paddle boarding … there is something for everyone. PICKLEBALL & TENNIS

2350 Bern Drive Unit 61,75&76, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: The Right Choice- Kirch Realty.

$200,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 4497408 MLS
This home provides what we crave ... stress-free days that most people look for at the Lake where we say ... "we are at the Lake" and when we are at the Lake, we want to feel like WE ARE AT THE LAKE ... OUR RETREAT" Rare opportunity to find a home in the Lake Buckhorn community at this entry-point pricing. Metal Roof Gutters & Downspouts in 2017This home sits on a very quiet 1.4 Acre site at the very northwest portion of incredible Lake Buckhorn !!! Four private lots at the end of Stammheim each 75x203.58. You don’t see ANY Neighboring homes. This is an extremely quiet portion of the Lake Buckhorn community where rarely a car passes … sweet opportunity for a serene get-a-way. Great location with a wooded views to the front and sides as well as 200-acre farm to the rear that also has a treed perimeter. What a great opportunity for a super Get-A-Way home or Weekender ... though the home is a full time home for the present owner. Also has a large shed. The very inviting and warm spacious Great Room is TERRIFIC with "barn-siding" on the walls and ceiling. The Great Room is always the focal point of a home .. where you spend most of your time. The Great Room with beamed ceiling, 2 skylights, and a warm & cozy woodburning stove also is adorned with custom Barn Door shutters on front and rear windows. The Open Kitchen overlooks the great room and also the backyard and the vast adjacent farm. The lower level provides space for a 2nd bedrm or large bunk room w private half bath.

2833 Stammheim Drive Unit 893, Millersburg

Listing Courtesy of: Thomas F Kirchendorfer, TomKirch4Sold@aol.com With The Right Choice- Kirch Realty

Selling Office: Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC..

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

Lake Buckhorn Homes for Sale - Millersburg, Ohio

Call or Text (614) 683-5116 to schedule a showing on any Lake Buckhorn Millersburg, OH home for sale or to sell your Lake Buckhorn Millersburg Ohio home!