Palmyra Homes for Sale - Diamond, Ohio

Remodeled Ranch with tons of charm. Spacious kitchen with some newer cabinets. First floor laundry room. Three bedrooms, full basement. Three parcels included totaling 1.77 acres. Detached garage approximately 27 x 29. Minutes away from Interstate 76, Lake Milton State Park, West Branch State Park and Berlin Lake.

9470 Tallmadge Road, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Cindy Le-Mon, cllcsells@gmail.com With RE/MAX Crossroads Properties

$42,500

5205532 MLS

This 3.17-acre parcel in Diamond, OH sits 10 minutes from Lake Milton State Park with road frontage on the paved McClintocksburg Rd. Utilities are available at the road, and soil testing has already been completed on two separate sites. If you've been looking for a flat, open lot in this area that's ready to go, this is it. Lake Milton is what brings people to this part of Portage County. Boating, fishing, a state park beach, disc golf, wineries, and trails, all a short drive away. West Branch State Park and Berlin Lake are close by as well. When you're not on the water, I-76 keeps Ravenna, Kent, and Akron all within comfortable commuting distance. The land is cleared and more open than most lots you'll find in this area. At 3.17 acres you have plenty of room for a home, garage, and yard without feeling cramped. Two separate passed soil sites give you more flexibility when it comes time to design your septic system and place your home, something most lots simply don't offer. McClintocksburg Rd is a mix of established homes ranging from modest to over half a million dollars. It’s the kind of place where people have put down real roots. Both perc sites are approved for up to a 4-bedroom home with a mound or spray irrigation system. Electric and natural gas are available at the road. Like most parcels in this part of the county, a well and septic will be needed. Zoned agricultural and residential. The adjacent 3.18-acre parcel is also available and listed separately. Call the listing agent, Dave, to schedule a time to walk the property.

Mcclintocksburg Road Unit B, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Dave Angus, dave.angus@oh-realestate.com With Carol Goff & Associates

Selling Office: Carol Goff & Associates.

$42,500

5205520 MLS

This 3.18-acre parcel in Diamond, OH sits 10 minutes from Lake Milton State Park with road frontage on the paved McClintocksburg Rd. Utilities are available at the road, and soil testing has already been completed. If you've been looking for a lot in this area, you know how hard it is to find one that doesn't come with a long list of things to figure out first. This one doesn't. Lake Milton is what brings people to this part of Portage County. Boating, fishing, a state park beach, disc golf, wineries, and trails, all a short drive away. West Branch State Park and Berlin Lake are close by as well. When you're not on the water, I-76 keeps Ravenna, Kent, and Akron all within comfortable commuting distance. The land is cleared and ready for a site plan. At 3.18 acres, you have plenty of room for a home, garage, and yard without feeling cramped. The property's gentle slope would be ideal for a walkout basement home. McClintocksburg Rd is a mix of established homes, ranging from modest to over half a million dollars. It’s the kind of place where people have put down real roots. The perc is already done and approved for up to a 4-bedroom home with a mound or spray irrigation system. Electric and natural gas are available at the road. Like most parcels in this part of the county, a well and septic will be needed. Zoned agricultural and residential. The adjacent 3.17-acre parcel is also available and listed separately. Call the listing agent, Dave, to schedule a time to walk the property.

Mcclintocksburg Road Unit A, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Dave Angus, dave.angus@oh-realestate.com With Carol Goff & Associates

Selling Office: Carol Goff & Associates.

$400,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5199400 MLS

Experience elevated country living on FIVE serene acres, where this beautifully transformed residence effortlessly blends timeless style, everyday functionality, and convenience with the most peaceful surroundings to create an exceptional lifestyle. From the moment you enter, you are welcomed by a warm and inviting living room anchored by the wood-burning fireplace, stone surround and raised hearth, effortlessly flowing into the fully remodeled kitchen. Thoughtfully curated with new cabinetry, quartz counters, and premium appliances (2025), the kitchen is complimented by eat-in dining area and shoe room nook with elegant archways, sconces and spacious built-in shelving. A first-floor laundry room with adjacent half-bath adds everyday convenience, while a nearly 500sqft addition (2024) elevates the home's living space--flooded with natural light and seamlessly connecting to the patio, back yard, and pool deck, creating an ideal space for relaxation, play space for the kids, or hosting large family gatherings. Outdoors, the expansive back yard boasts a 30 foot above ground pool (2018) with deck (2023), patio, fire pit, shed (2025) and is backed by mature woods, perfect for enjoying morning coffee, pool parties, and bonfires with family and friends. Upstairs, two guest rooms share a full bathroom, while the primary is a true retreat, featuring walk-in closet, soaking tub, and views overlooking the front half of the property. The lower level presents a partially finished recreation space with LVP flooring, bar, and pool table, along with storage/utility area. Mechanical updates provide confidence and peace of mind including new heat pump, furnace, hot water heater (2024), sump pump and water softener system (2025). Extensively updated and thoughtfully designed, this turn-key home is ready to give you the space, tranquility, comfort, and peace of mind to savor the lifestyle you truly deserve to live--THIS is where your next chapter begins!

8742 Henderson Road, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Cody Mazanek, codymazanek@mosholder.com With Mosholder Realty Inc.

Selling Office: RE/MAX Infinity.

$277,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5182618 MLS

Beautiful 3-bedroom ranch situated on just over 3 acres. Features an attached 2-car garage plus an additional 3-car garage with 220 electric, wood burner, and electric service—perfect for hobbies or extra storage. Enjoy granite countertops, a finished basement with wood-burning fireplace, and a screened-in back porch overlooking the peaceful property. Two sump pumps provide added peace of mind. A great blend of space, comfort, and functionality!

3875 Mcclintocksburg Road, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Kelly L Warren, kelly@kellysoldit.com With Kelly Warren and Associates RE Solutions

Selling Office: Kelly Warren and Associates RE Solutions.

$420,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5143673 MLS

Nestled on 2 beautifully maintained acres in Southeast Schools, this updated 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath, built by Dutch Heritage Homes offers space, comfort, and an inviting lifestyle just minutes from Lake Milton and Berlin Lake. Spend your summers lounging by the gorgeous in-ground, heated pool, hosting unforgettable backyard gatherings in the fenced yard, or simply enjoying peaceful evenings under the stars. Inside, the updated kitchen is ready for everything from slow Sunday mornings to full-on holiday feasts, while the light-filled, spacious living areas offer room to relax and recharge. Upstairs, you'll find 4 generous bedrooms with 2 full baths and brand-new carpet throughout. The partially finished basement offers an additional 1300 sq ft of space to spread out or for storage. Recent updates including a new roof in 2024, new water heater in 2025, Luxury vinyl throughout the 1st floor in 2024, new carpet throughout the 2nd floor in 2025, inground heated pool in 2022, and an upgraded water system with chlorinated water and reverse osmosis installed in 2023 that makes city water pale in comparison. Whether you're looking for more room to grow, a place to unwind, an easy commute, or easy access to Lake Milton's boating, fishing, and dining, this property has it all. Close to the schools, and easy access to I-76. Schedule your showing today!

10575 Tallmadge Road, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Andrew P Guanciale, andrew.guanciale@cbrealty.com With Coldwell Banker Realty

Selling Office: Howard Hanna.

$399,500

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5136328 MLS

Updated Farmhouse with 15.41 acres! Updates include new roof, newer windows, new water well, water softener, pressure tank and UV light system. First floor owner's bedroom and a full bath on the first floor. Two additional bedrooms on the second floor. The property was once a tree farm and there are several trees still left on the back of the property. Detached garage plus a nice size barn with tons of storage space. Small pond for watering livestock. A lot on the property was soil tested and approved by the township if the new buyer wants to build a new home or split the property. Don't miss this rare opportunity!

3609 State Route 225, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Cindy Le-Mon, cllcsells@gmail.com With RE/MAX Crossroads Properties

Selling Office: Keller Williams Chervenic Realty.

$295,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5126107 MLS

3 Bed 2.5 Bath Conventional/Cape Cod style home on 5.92 acres in Diamond, OH within Southeast Local School District with FREE GAS! On the main level you will find a first-floor laundry room, half bath, kitchen, large living room with wood burning fireplace, formal dining room with bay window, and first floor master bedroom with ensuite full bath. Upstairs holds two additional bedrooms and a second full bath. There is an attached 2 car garage with electric, covered back porch and a 20x28 barn with dirt floor and lean to storage area. The house receives free gas from the well that is on the property. This fixer upper offers tons of potential for the right buyer!

9439 Williams Road, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Roxanne R Simon, rsimon@jkohlre.com With Jack Kohl Realty

Selling Office: Keller Williams Chervenic Rlty.

$129,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5100239 MLS

Welcome to 10375 Williams Road. This sweet 3 bedroom ranch sits nicely on 1.28 acres, perfect for animals of your choice. The home was modified with pets in mind! Bi-level, fenced in porch with beautiful wisteria leads to an ideal garden space for chickens, ducks, or a furry friend of your choice! Come on inside to experience a beautiful kitchen with Kraftmaid cabinetry, ceramic tile flooring, 1st floor laundry and a brick mantle fireplace among many other wonderful benefits. A little TLC and this house can be transformed into your home sweet home in no time! Call co-lister today and be blessed!

10375 Williams Road, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Kelly L Warren, kelly@kellysoldit.com With Kelly Warren and Associates RE Solutions

Selling Office: Howard Hanna.

$225,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5095890 MLS

Welcome to this 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom ranch nestled on 2 acres in the picturesque Palmyra Township. This freshly painted and newly carpeted home is one of many updates done to the home, including: flooring, drywall, plumbing, electrical, interior doors, garage door, insulation and more! The walkout basement adds functionality and flexibility to the living space. The finished basement area encompasses a laundry room, a cozy family room, a bedroom, and a bonus room with access to the 2-car attached garage and mudroom. With its tranquil location and versatile living spaces, this home presents the perfect opportunity to create your own haven.

4947 Wayland Road, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Amanda Hall, amanda.hall@CBSchmidtOhio.com With Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realty

Selling Office: RE/MAX Edge Realty.

$165,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5089297 MLS

Two unit duplex rents month to month @$750 a side. Each side has 2 BR 1 BA, half basement. Garage is detached 26 x 24 (approx.). Sits on 2.12 acre lot.

9987-9989 Scotts Corner Road, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Cindy Le-Mon, cllcsells@gmail.com With RE/MAX Crossroads Properties

Selling Office: RE/MAX Crossroads Properties.

$235,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5059908 MLS

Check out this rare find in Diamond, Ohio! You'll love this 3-bedroom home situated on a gorgeous lot. Enjoy the fishing and boating at Lake Milton State Park and Recreation Area about one mile east of this property. The home is a sturdy brick build with a spacious back deck overlooking the fenced in backyard and newer back patio area! With main level laundry and master bedroom, this home is perfect for buyers of all ages. Spacious bedrooms and closets as well as an open kitchen, and gas fireplace in the main living area are a few more features to note. New roof 2023, electric 2021, windows 2018, landscaping/patio 2022, and new owners 2024!

10307 Tallmadge Road, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Jacob Ketler, jketler@cutlerhomes.com With Cutler Real Estate

Selling Office: RE/MAX Trends Realty.

$549,700

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 5056573 MLS

Welcome to 9715 Williams Rd.! This home boasts so much potential for either the Equine, or car buff enthusiast, homesteader, naturalist, country lover, or wide-open space seeker. Situated on just over 7 acres, this 3 BR, 2 Full, 2 Half BA, 2 story colonial gem offers interior, natural, hand scraped hickory flooring throughout the first floor, generous sized rooms, tasteful decor, and obvious pride of ownership. As you walk through the home your eye will be drawn to the custom stone fireplace topped with a custom mantel, not to mention, the wood burner insert that can been used to heat the entire home. As you make your way from room to room, you'll appreciate the meticulous attention to detail each room offers. You'll finish your tour in the beautifully adorned family room located in the full basement with a custom entertainment area including a bar and beautiful custom stone wall. As you make your way to the exterior of the home and from the beautiful 'TREX deck with hot tub and paver patio, you will be captivated by the massive 5400 sq ft outbuilding offering so much versatility from 6 horse or miscellaneous livestock stalls, to a pig pen, to tack room, wash bay, machinery shed, 20x60 insulated/heated workshop or workout area, and multiple paddock and fenced areas. This addition provides for a multitude of uses. You choose it! This building is at your beck and call. Oh! I forgot to mention the following improvements/upgrades....Windows and roof 2019 and water treatment system 2021. This home is SHOW STOPPER and MOVE IN READY!

9715 Williams Road, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Valerie J Evans Coontz, valpal2u2@yahoo.com With Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Stouffer Realty

Selling Office: Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Professional Realty.

$390,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5055635 MLS

This property is more than just a home; it's a lifestyle. Whether you're looking for a peaceful retreat or a place to entertain, this colonial has it all. Nestled on a serene 5.03-acre lot, this captivating 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath colonial with a 2-car attached garage offers the perfect blend of classic elegance and modern amenities. From the moment you drive up the long winding driveway and past your very own private (stocked) pond, you will fall in love! The inviting front porch complete with a classic swing, is just the beginning of the outdoor charm this home offers. Welcoming foyer leads to a spacious living room with a woodburning FP (which has the option of being converted to propane if you wanted to), a formal dining room perfect for gatherings, and a cozy family room with large windows that provide stunning views of the pond. Your well-appointed kitchen boasts modern appliances, ample counter space, and beautiful cabinetry. The adjacent breakfast area has sliders that lead to your backyard oasis. Conveniently located off your kitchen you will also find your first-floor half bath and spacious laundry room. The second floor features your luxurious master bedroom with an en-suite bath and walk in closet as well as 3 additional bedrooms and an additional full bathroom. The full, partially finished basement includes a spacious recreation room and your fitness area. This versatile space adds significant living area, ample storage space and endless possibilities for family fun and entertainment. Step outside and relax on your large trex deck overlooking your refreshing 27 foot above ground pool with pool deck (which is heated) or gather around the firepit for the cozy evenings under the stars while watching the kids play on their very own playground area. This home has a warm and inviting atmosphere that’s perfect for creating lasting memories with family and friends.. Don't miss the opportunity to make this your forever home! A list of updates is provided in the home

3856 Jones Road, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Bambi L Brown, bambibrown17@gmail.com With Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realty

Selling Office: Brokers Realty Group.

$184,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5044525 MLS

Great opportunity! This home sits on 10 acres of 2 parcels. It is a mechanic's or car enthusiasts dream. It features a 4 car garage that also includes to office spaces. It has an additional 2 car detached garage with the 2 car attached garage on the home. The home has lots of room and a huge newer Central Air unit that was installed by the prior owner. There is so much that can be done to this home to make it your own. Come and see!

3902 Mcclintocksburg Road, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Shane Reid, shanereid97@gmail.com With Century 21 Homestar

Selling Office: Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Simon & Salhany Realty.

$370,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 4475490 MLS

Meticulously maintained Colonial Home with pride of ownership. Owner downsizing. Two car attached garage plus a super clean 40x32 pole building and additional garages that are 18x16 and 24x16, and a Gazebo, tons of storage. Home has a living room with pellet stove, huge sun room, eat-in kitchen plus formal dining room, 1/2 bath on the first floor, 2 updated baths on 2nd floor, owners suite with walk-in closet, 2nd floor laundry makes it super convenient. Minutes away from West Branch State Park and Interstate 76. Many updates including new roof on house "2019", new roof on large pole building "2020", new steel siding on large pole building "2021", small pole building new roof "2022", septic updated "2019", new hot water tank "2022", water softener "2022", pressure tank "2022", new furnace "2019",water well pump "2019", driveway black top in "2020" and sealed in "2022".

8314 Henderson Road, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Cindy Le-Mon, cllcsells@gmail.com With RE/MAX Crossroads Properties

Selling Office: Zidian Real Estate.

$195,000

7 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 4506003 MLS

This home has been completely updated inside and out. New kitchen, baths, drywall, roof, flooring, windows, garage, cement drive area, water system, furnace you name it-its updated. New roof, siding, windows, kitchen and baths, furnace, air, flooring, drywall etc. Must see!!

10264 Tallmadge Road, Diamond

Listing Courtesy of: Teresa M Crew, actionrealtyreo@outlook.com With Action Realty Co

Selling Office: EXP Realty, LLC..