44231 Ohio Commercial Properties for Sale

44231 Ohio Commercial Properties for Sale

$620,000
5242141 MLS
What if you could own one of the coolest pieces of Garrettsville history? Originally built in 1804 as a water powered flour mill, Garrett’s Mill is an approx. 9,170 SF historic property offering an operating restaurant, bar, ice cream shop and 3.5 barrel craft brewery as a complete package. Renovated in 2019 as part of its Restaurant: Impossible transformation, the property retains incredible historic character, original beams and mill features. The restaurant features a front bar area, commercial kitchen with full fire suppression system and a rear dining room overlooking Eagle Creek and the falls. Two outdoor dining areas create completely different experiences: a rear deck overlooking the waterfall and a front patio overlooking downtown Garrettsville, Main Street and the new Buckeye Block amphitheater. Waterfall out back. Downtown out front. The walkout lower level has a private entrance, direct access to the waterfall deck, original mill artifacts and a unique viewing area into the historic mill workings. With some elbow grease and the right vision, imagine a hidden speakeasy, live music, beer tastings, private events or catering that could bring guests in earlier and keep them longer. Future public use subject to applicable improvements and approvals. An additional approx. 1,420 SF attic offers even more opportunity. Offered at $620,000, just $67.61/SF, including the real estate, operating restaurant and brewery, commercial restaurant and brewery equipment, furnishings and applicable non leased equipment, plus three Ohio liquor licenses identified by seller as A1A, A1C and D6, subject to verification and transfer approval.

8148 Main Street, Garrettsville

Listing Courtesy of: Lauren Patrick, lpsoldit@gmail.com With Vincent Patrick Realty
$400,000
5204296 MLS
What an amazing opportunity. This free standing office building features a kitchenette, bathroom, 5 office spaces and so much more. In addition to the office building the property has a well maintained home that is currently being used as a rental property. The house has 3 bedrooms, kitchen, dining, living room, 1 full bath, 1/2 bath, first floor laundry hookup, and a bonus room. The building and house sit on just under 2 acres just outside of the village of Garrettsville. Plenty of parking at the office building and even more in the fenced area. Do not walk the property without an agent. 24 hour notice required. Room dimensions (House) Kitchen 11X11, Dining 10X14, Living 12X14, 1/2 Bath 6X5, Full bath 12X7, Bedroom (1st floor) 11X9, Bedroom 10X15, Bedroom 10X15, bonus/office space 9X12. Do not walk the property without your agent. 24 hour notice required. Listing agent will be present for all showings.

8454 Windham Street, Garrettsville

Listing Courtesy of: Lisa Irwin, LisaIrwinHomes@gmail.com With HomeSmart Real Estate Momentum LLC
$380,000
5194272 MLS
Turnkey Auto/Shop + Investment Property. A Ready to Run Business For the first time in 36 years, this well-established commercial property is hitting the market. Set on 3.71 acres in Garrettsville, 10320 Brosius Rd offers the kind of setup that's hard to find, two solid buildings, a proven location, and room to grow. Both buildings consist of over 4,200 sq ft. The front building (48x32 pole building with block construction) features three bay doors- one 12' and two 10' plus a loft for additional storage. Inside you'll find an air-conditioned front office addition and an additional office off the garage. Includes Two Twin Post Challenger Lifts at 12,000 lb capacity each & an Ingersoll air compressor. The back building (40x60) adds a 10' garage door and plenty of open space for equipment, storage, or additional work bays. The back building is already wired with phone and electric for additional offices. Both buildings are well-maintained & ready to go. The property runs on 200-amp service. Updated vinyl siding (2023), vinyl windows, fiberglass entry doors, & a roof with no known issues round out the exterior. Additional systems include a Gemini alarm system, Panasonic phone system capable of 10 lines, & an intercom/PA system. Cell tower located on the east portion of the property. No lease and no royalties associated with the tower. There is an easement over the southern parcel that provides additional driveway access and turnaround space for the parcel being offered for sale.The southern 1.54-acre parcel is not currently included in this sale. It is presently used by Village Motors Towing for storage & operations & may be offered separately in the future as an investment opportunity. Whether you're an auto mechanic, machine shop operator, car dealer, or investor looking for a versatile commercial property with built-in infrastructure, this one checks the boxes. Includes both buildings & all major equipment. See you tube for video.

10320 Brosius Road, Garrettsville

Listing Courtesy of: Lauren Patrick, lpsoldit@gmail.com With Vincent Patrick Realty

Selling Office: Vincent Patrick Realty.

$299,900
226003776 MLS
Unusual church property that also has a 1900 SF house on this 2.2 acre lot. Church was just recently closed. Fully functional featuring just over 4,000 SF. A perfect location for a church or other event center (pending any zoning changes that may be required). House dwelling is 4 bdrms, 2 baths in very good condition and has plenty of space.

12888 State Route 88, Garrettsville

Listing Courtesy of : Ross V DiGiorgio ---- The Westwood Real Estate Co.
$145,000
5123870 MLS
Prime location in the heart of Garrettsville you will find this gorgeous building waiting for whatever is coming up next! Private parking and entrance, Ample parking for employees and visitors, Spacious and versatile floor plan. This building is zoned mixed use. It was a hair salon but has many possibilities for a variety of uses such as dentist office, attorney office, insurance, retail, investment…the list is endless! This building features gorgeous hardwood floors, large open layout with a large half bathroom, small break room or kitchenette area, entry room and Full Walk-out basement with plenty of storage room! The 2 workstations and 2 shampoo stations that are there currently can stay if the buyer would like them, if not, the seller will remove them prior to closing.

7997 State Street, Garrettsville

Listing Courtesy of: Bambi L Brown, bambibrown17@gmail.com With Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realty

Selling Office: Century 21 Homestar.

$230,000
4493960 MLS
Great location for your new business! Situated on an acre of land with easy access, plenty of room outside for parking and storage. Roof replaced on back side of building in 2023. Inside areas will hold 8-10 vehicles. Main building has plenty of storage in its over 4000 sq ft , with office and a private bathroom. Paint booth has been upgraded with gas heating and LED lighting just recently. Shed on side does not transfer. There are security cameras, and so many extras...too many to list! Come and take a look. set up your own personal viewing. We ask that weekday showings are after 4 pm, as business is still fully operational. All equipment is negotiable, currently an auto body/paint shop, but seller is willing to remove any equipment not needed or wanted. Additional photos are available upon request. Thanks !

10305 Liberty Street, Garrettsville

Listing Courtesy of: Sandra J Brown, lighthousecardcompany@gmail.com With MB Realty Group

Selling Office: MB Realty Group.

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

44231 Ohio Commercial Properties

Search all Commercial Properties in 44231 Ohio. These 44231 Commercial Properties property details include large photos, local school info, tours, maps, street view and more in 44231 OH.

Call or Text (614) 683-5116 to schedule a showing on any 44231 Ohio Commercial Properties Today!