Fort Myers Beach Florida Homes for Sale

San Carlos On The Gulf - Fort Myers Beach Florida Homes for Sale

$699,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026010004 MLS
This is a must see! Completely remodeled inside and out! You’ve found the perfect location! Nestled on Fort Myers Beach, just over the bridge from Times Square, this beautifully updated, raised 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers the ideal blend of coastal charm and modern luxury. Walk or bike to the beach, waterfront restaurants, and all the island favorites. This meticulously maintained home has been modernized from top to bottom with no detail overlooked. The brand-new kitchen features white shaker cabinetry, stylish quartz countertops, a modern backsplash, and all-new appliances — perfect for entertaining or everyday living. Both bathrooms have been fully renovated with new tubs and showers, updated vanities, toilets, hardware, and contemporary lighting. Impact glass windows and sleek French doors not only provide peace of mind but also fill the home with natural light and refreshing coastal breezes. Did I mention new flooring throughout?! Step outside and enjoy the completely redone wraparound decks — ideal for morning coffee, evening gatherings, or simply soaking in beautiful bay views and unforgettable sunsets. The oversized yard offers plenty of room to relax, entertain, or create your own outdoor oasis. Best of all, there are no HOA fees or restrictions — just the freedom to enjoy island living to the fullest. Schedule your private showing today and start living the coastal lifestyle you’ve been dreaming of.

942 Prescott Street, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of John R. Wood Properties
$1,749,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2026009675 MLS
This stunning 3-story waterfront home at Fort Myers Beach, Florida, offers an exceptional blend of luxury and coastal living. Situated on San Carlos Island and overlooking Pelican Bay, it boasts deep water dockage for easy access to the Gulf of Mexico. The home features 4 spacious bedrooms and 4 well-appointed bathrooms (3 are en suite), providing plenty of room for family and guests. The chef's kitchen is a culinary dream, equipped with high-end appliances such as the JennAir double refrigerator and Wolf range and double wall ovens. Finished in custom cabinetry and granite counters, there’s ample counter space, perfect for preparing gourmet meals. The expansive Great Room offers a perfect place for entertaining, with a seamless transition to a screened Lanai that overlooks the pool deck, docks, and water. Enjoy the breathtaking views and gentle breezes in this peaceful outdoor space as you watch dolphin, manatees, and waterfowl playing right before your eyes. The third floor is dedicated to a private Primary Suite offering a luxurious retreat complete with its own balcony and a Study with panoramic views for relaxation or work. Step outside to a beautiful pool area, ideal for soaking up the sun or enjoying evening swims. The breezeway has been turned into additional outdoor living space, featuring a hot tub for relaxation and a dining table for alfresco meals. Also on the ground floor is an apartment with separate access and its own Living Room, Bedroom, and Bath – perfect for guests or extended family. A whole house generator and impact resistant doors provide peace of mind. The home is an easy bike ride or brisk walk to Fort Myers Beach, and a quick boat ride to a variety of waterfront restaurants. Located just north of the bridge for easier access to all of the other great attractions in the Fort Myers area. With its prime location, deep-water dockage, and luxurious design, this home is the epitome of Florida waterfront living.

921 Prescott Street, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Cypress Realty Inc.
$1,999,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2026008594 MLS
Coming 2026, White Sands and Sea Glass are elevated coastal residences in the prestigious San Carlos on the Gulf neighborhood of Fort Myers Beach, positioned among luxury homes and removed from the congestion of the main beach district. Featuring expansive open-concept living, oversized rooms, and refined coastal finishes, the elevated main level captures natural light and enhanced views. Built to current hurricane standards with elevator rough-in and optional pool, this is sophisticated island living offering comfort, privacy, and long-term coastal value, all within walking distance to beaches, marina’s, and waterfront dining. Pre-construction opportunity; pricing may evolve as construction progresses.

961 San Carlos Court, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of HelloSold LLC
$749,000
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2026003445 MLS
Awesome income producing property on San Carlos Island with 4 total units in a WEEKLY RENTAL zone! The property consists of 2 efficiencies, a 2/1 bedroom apartment, plus an elevated 2 bedroom 1 bath unit with elevated deck space. Onsite coin laundry for tenant use. Huge workshop/storage shed on the back of the property with room for a pool. The best part about this location is you get the skip the traffic & the city taxes but still have the best of Fort Myers Beach at your fingertips! Multiple marinas, & restaurants are within walking distance including Doc Ford's, Dixie Fish & Bonita Bill's! The upstairs unit is 2 bedrooms with full kitchen & family room with nice open patio deck to enjoy the views & cool Florida breezes. Tremendous upside here as the area continues its renaissance! Now is the time to get in. Schedule your showing today! More photos coming soon

841/843 South Street, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of The Keyes Company
$3,399,000
226001800 MLS
Commanding an extraordinary half-acre of bayfront along the rising shores of San Carlos Island, this is the kind of opportunity that rarely surfaces—and never lasts. Encompassing an impressive 20,830 square feet with 100 feet of direct bay frontage and an exceptional depth of approximately 215 feet, this premier homesite delivers a level of scale, presence, and design freedom that is virtually unmatched across Southwest Florida. Positioned with coveted western exposure, the property is perfectly oriented to capture breathtaking sunset views over wide-open water, while a deep-water canal alongside provides quick, unobstructed access to the Gulf of Mexico—an ideal combination for both boating enthusiasts and those seeking a true waterfront lifestyle. A newer dock is already in place, thoughtfully designed to accommodate two boat lifts, allowing you to begin enjoying the water from day one while planning your custom coastal estate. The size and configuration of this parcel offer endless possibilities for expansive indoor-outdoor living, resort-style amenities, and a truly architectural statement home. San Carlos Island is quickly emerging as one of Southwest Florida’s most exciting luxury destinations, attracting discerning homeowners, investors, and top-tier builders. The location strikes a rare balance—just a short stroll to Fort Myers Beach’s iconic waterfront dining, and moments from the vibrant energy of Margaritaville Resort and the area’s world-renowned beaches—yet uniquely positioned to avoid the congestion typically associated with island living. With seamless access to Sanibel, Captiva, Bonita Springs, Naples, and RSW International Airport, convenience is unmatched. Whether you envision a private bayfront estate or a high-performing luxury rental—enhanced by the area’s no rental restrictions—this offering represents a compelling blend of lifestyle and investment potential. Half an acre of prime bayfront, deep-water Gulf access, sweeping sunset views, and exceptional proximity to Fort Myers Beach—948 San Carlos Boulevard is more than a homesite; it’s a rare canvas to create something truly remarkable.

948 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Premiere Plus Realty Company
$4,200,000
6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 2026002641 MLS
This is the Fort Myers Beach property that truly has it all—bayfront luxury with Gulf views, oversized grounds, income potential, and resort-style amenities. With 7 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, and an elevator, this exceptional estate is designed for both comfort and convenience, offered fully turnkey. The main residence rises three levels above a private apartment that opens directly to the heated pool and jacuzzi. Multiple balconies and screened decks capture long water views, while the top-level bedroom lookout provides a panoramic perspective of both Estero Bay and the Gulf of America. A wood-burning fireplace adds warmth and character to the spacious living areas. A separate guest house with its own garage sits at the front of the property and is currently leased to a long-term tenant, delivering a proven consistent annual rental income. The main home also offers excellent rental income, making this both a lifestyle retreat and a smart investment. Boaters will appreciate the private dock, complete with a captain’s walk and a 10,000 lb. boat lift—ideal for quick access to open water. The oversized lot enhances the estate feel, providing rare space and privacy on Fort Myers Beach. Perfectly located to avoid the heavy beach traffic yet just minutes from the shoreline, dining, and entertainment, this property offers the best of island living. With unmatched views, exceptional amenities, and turnkey convenience, this is one of the most remarkable opportunities on Fort Myers Beach.

950 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of iConnect RE
$2,380,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2026002629 MLS
Wake up to a million-dollar view without fighting island traffic. This gorgeous 5-bedroom, 3-bath home offers all the charm of Fort Myers Beach living — just across the bridge, where life feels easier, breezier, and perfectly relaxed. Boaters will love the private dock and covered lift (rebuilt in 2018 with electricity), ready for days spent exploring the Gulf. The in-ground pool overlooks wide open water with views that stretch all the way to the beach — it’s the kind of backdrop that makes every sunset feel like a celebration. Inside, you’ll find an open-concept layout with stainless steel appliances and panoramic water views from the main living area. Elevated on pilons for peace of mind, this home features impact-resistant windows and doors plus brand-new Storm Smart roll-down screens (2024) — so you can enjoy carefree coastal living, even through storm season. The lower level has been transformed into a casual second living space with an open-air kitchen and elevator — perfect for entertaining, guests, or creating separate rental potential. With its flexible layout and unbeatable location, this home is ideal for an investor, snowbird, family, or Airbnb host looking for strong rental appeal. Just over a mile to the beach, close to shopping, dining, Route 41, and only 20 miles to RSW International Airport — this is truly the best of Fort Myers Beach living, without compromise.

789 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of iConnect RE

Selling Office: .

$744,900
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2025025290 MLS
Perfect Investment Opportunity on beautiful San Carlos Island. Property is surrounded by multi million dollar homes on the Bay. Long Term tenants are currently occupying the building. This is a great location with walking distance less than 10 minutes over the bridge to Fort Myers Beach. A new traffic light has been installed at the base of the Beach to make cross over safe. Each unit has its own ground level entry accessible from either the garage or outside. Plenty of storage space and parking area in the oversized garage. New air conditioning system installed after Ian and there was no damage to the raised units. Both units have been remodeled within the last five years and are in great condition. There is an additional unfinished 2 bedroom one bath unit in the rear at ground level for additional rental potential. unit San Carlos Island offers many amenities such as restaurants, Dixie Fish, Doc Fords And the new Fish house within short walking distance. Many great projects are planned for the future.

842 South Street, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Fort Myers Beach Realty
$5,485,000
6 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths ⋅ 225082699 MLS
This is 793 San Carlos Drive—less a house and more a waypoint on the map of a life well-lived. A modern coastal refuge tucked into the salty heartbeat of Fort Myers Beach, where the air smells of sunburnt afternoons and the tide keeps its own kind of time. Built the right way—block and steel from the ground all the way up to the roof. Perfectly positioned for those grand, cinematic sunsets that spill across Matanzas Bay, the kind you watch in silence because words just get in the way. Built for poolside barbeques that run late, for Florida winter nights when conversation drifts like smoke, for slow bike rides to seafood joints where the fish are still telling stories from the Gulf. Inside, two primary suites and four guest rooms, all en-suite, make it the sort of place where family converges, friends linger, and nobody feels like they drew the short straw. It’s a home that doesn’t just host memories; it cooks them slowly, like something that gets better the longer you let it simmer. The kitchen is the soul of it all. Mid-century esque meets modern, a space begging for simple ingredients, good knives, and better company. From here, you can watch the world wander by on the water while you stir, chop, taste, and exist—exactly as you are. From the terrace, the view opens in soft, deliberate layers—first across untouched Grayson Island and its protected bird sanctuary, then out toward the distant shimmer of Fort Myers Beach’s skyline, with the Sanibel Causeway stretching quietly along the eastern edge of the horizon. Up top, the dual primary suites hide away like little sanctuaries, each with wide-open views that remind you why people chase the horizon in the first place. Everything inside has been curated with a sharp, contemporary eye—furnishings that feel effortless, textures that feel intentional. It’s the kind of place you can step into and immediately exhale. Turn the key, and you’re already living the life. With Control4 automation, hidden surround sound, a Tesla charger, Generac generator and a build engineered to shrug off coastal moods, this home blends luxury with durability. A place made for people who appreciate beauty—but also know that the world is imperfect, unpredictable, and worth experiencing anyway. The water keeps its rhythm. The sunsets write their own script. All that’s missing is someone to call it home. Perhaps that’s you. Schedule a showing today.

793 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Potter Trinity
$1,999,000
225070841 MLS
60 Feet of Waterfront Views – A Bayfront Jewel on San Carlos Island! Waterfront royalty awaits on this rare, 60-foot stretch of bayfront paradise—perfectly positioned with no-bridge boating to the Gulf in just five minutes. This extraordinary property offers a blank canvas for creating a single-family estate or even a stunning duplex worthy of its setting. An optional adjacent parcel (922) MLS #225070838 is also available if you desire a larger estate. Builder referrals are on hand, giving you even more opportunity to bring your vision to life. Spend your days boating to a dozen nearby restaurants for lunch or dinner, or simply savor serene sunsets over the bay from your own backyard. Located a short stroll from the pristine, sugary sands of Fort Myers Beach—yet away from the bustle of heavy traffic—this San Carlos Island address combines true island living with the convenience of Lee County’s streamlined building process. Rarely do opportunities of this caliber present themselves. Here, you can design and build a residence that captures the very best of bayfront living, offering privacy, beauty, and the quintessential Southwest Florida lifestyle.

926 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Premiere Plus Realty Company
$2,099,000
225070838 MLS
Bayfront Bliss Meets Coastal Adventure – 60 Feet of Waterfront Views - A Lot Like No Other! Unmatched opportunity awaits with this extraordinary Bayfront/Gulf-access property on San Carlos Island. Offering 60 Feet of Panoramic Waterfront Views and effortless access to the Gulf with no-bridge boating in just five minutes. This rare lot provides a pristine canvas for crafting a spectacular single-family estate or an impressive duplex that celebrates Southwest Florida’s coastal lifestyle. The adjacent parcel (926) MLS #225070841 is also available if you desire a larger footprint or wish to create an expansive dream estate. Builder referrals are on hand, giving you even more opportunity to bring your vision to life. Savor breathtaking sunsets and watch a lively parade of boats from your own backyard, or head out to some of the region’s best fishing grounds. With dozens of waterfront restaurants just a short boat ride away, every outing becomes an adventure. Perfectly positioned within walking distance of the sugary sands of Fort Myers Beach—yet tucked away from the bustle of heavy traffic—this San Carlos Island address combines true island living with the convenience of Lee County’s streamlined permitting and building process. Opportunities of this caliber are exceptionally rare, offering the freedom to design a home that captures the very best of bayfront living and the relaxed, vibrant spirit of Southwest Florida.

922 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Premiere Plus Realty Company
$1,200,000
2025004506 MLS
Sold in two pieces Please see MLS # 224032683

946 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of John R. Wood Properties

Selling Office: .

$524,900
223019019 MLS
These motivated Seller’s just reduced the price over 50K! Now is your opportunity to build your dream home on this prime, Ft. Myers Beach Lot. Enjoy a bike ride, stroll or take your golf cart to local restaurants and shops, while catching the breathtaking sunsets of San Carlos Island. This lot is completely cleared and ready to build. Come and be a part of the revitalization of the vibrant island community of Fort Myers Beach. You have found your very own 'Peace' of Paradise!

947 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of List In MLS Realty, LLC
$348,000
225022295 MLS
Be part of the revitalizatioon of Fort Myers Beach on San Carlos Island. This fabulous deep water lot with gulf access and no bridges to Estero Bay and the Gulf. Seawall redone in last five years. Lot cleared an ready for your new home. Builder introductions available. New development planned directly behind to include a New Marina, condos/hotel and more....jump on the Key West express or dine at Parrot Key. Walk or bike right over the bridge to Fort Myers Beach downtown area and Margaritaville. Great location.

829 Oak Street, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Fort Myers Beach Realty
$569,000
225022280 MLS
Location, location, location . . . this well-priced commercial parcel is located off San Carlos Drive just this side of the bridge It's within walking or biking distance from our beautiful sandy beaches, and surrounded by fine dining like Doc Ford's and Dixie Fish House. Property is zoned C-1. Located behind Diversified Yacht Services with million dollar homes across the street on the Bay.

752 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Royal Shell Real Estate, Inc.
$450,000
224021333 MLS
ZONED TFC-2 MEANING DUPLEX MULTI FAMILY LIVE IN ONE SIDE AND RENT THE OTHER!!!Remember when your parents or mentors told you to get in on the ground floor and hold? Here is your opportunity to make that happen!! CLEARED AND READY FOR REBUILD!! You can literally take a short bike ride or walk to the beautiful pristine white sands of Fort Myers Beach and the Gulf of Mexico right over the Mantanzas Pass bridge in a few minutes. Drop your chair, lay your blanket out and indulge in the Aqua green water and a cool drink while watching the Pelicans dive for their morning meal. This lot is approximately 1/3 of an acre giving you a clean slate to work with. With the right contractor you could be looking at the sunset through your master bedroom windows in a matter of months. Located just off Fort Myers Beach on San Carlos Island, makes for easy access on and off the island as well as getting into Fort Myers for Shopping, Airport, or Spring Training Baseball . Whatever tickles your fancy!!! This is not going to last long at this price and location, so don't hesitate!! When opportunity knocks, answer the door!!

961 San Carlos Court, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of John R. Wood Properties

Selling Office: .

$2,450,000
225048560 MLS
Welcome to 855 San Carlos Drive, an exceptional waterfront homesite offering an incredible opportunity to build your dream coastal retreat in the Ft Myers Beach area. This rare and generously sized lot features 70 feet of water frontage and stretches 310 feet deep, providing ample space for a luxury residence, pool, and private dock. Enjoy breathtaking sunset views looking west toward Punta Rassa, the Sanibel Causeway Bridge, and the sparkling waters surrounding Fort Myers Beach. With TFC-2 zoning, the property offers rare flexibility—you can build a single-family home, add a guest house, design a duplex. Preliminary drawings for a guest house, once considered by the current owners, are available for inspiration. City Water with the added benefit of a well also. Located in unincorporated Lee County, this homesite benefits from a more streamlined and user-friendly permitting process compared to other local municipalities, helping to minimize construction timelines. Boaters will love the deepwater Gulf access with no bridges—just minutes from the open Gulf of Mexico or the Intracoastal Waterway—making this the perfect spot for sportfishing, island-hopping, or simply relaxing on the water. Surrounded by newer luxury homes, the neighborhood radiates pride of ownership and coastal charm. Beyond the property, you’re less than half a mile from waterfront dining at Doc Ford’s, Dixie Fish Company, and Bonita Bills. A walk over the bridge or nearby trolley stop also offers a quick ride to the vibrant scene of Fort Myers Beach. This is more than just a homesite—it’s an opportunity to embrace the Florida waterfront lifestyle at its finest.

855 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Worthington Realty, Inc.

Selling Office: .

$600,000
224032683 MLS
There is NOT A BETTER DEAL IN ALL OF FORT MYERS BEACH & SAN CARLOS ISLAND AS THIS PROPERTY RIGHT HERE! 60 FT OF BAYFRONT/GULF ACCESS PROPERTY ON SAN CARLOS BAY! The OPPORTUNITY here is UN-MATCHED! With zoning being TFC-2, this gives allowance for a SINGLE FAMILY HOME, DUPLEXE OR ONE MAGNIFICENT SINGLE FAMILY COMPOUND. YOU WILL BE KING OR QUEEN OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD! No matter what is built here, all will have ENDLESS SUNSETS, BOAT TRAFFIC WATCHING, and some of the BEST FISHING in SW Florida from your dock or wrangle a TARPON from just a short boat ride into the GULF OF MEXICO! WHEN OPPORTUNITY KNOCKS, ANSWER THE DOOR! This property is literally within walking distance to the sugary sands of Fort Myers Beach without sitting in all that traffic! San Carlos Island is also part of Lee County and not a part of the Town of Fort Myers Beach which allows for going through the County vs. the Town of Fort Myers Beach for building. DON'T HESITATE ON THIS OFFER!! LOT WAS RECENTLY SPLIT FROM OTHER PARCEL, NEW PID # 24-46-23-L2-00001.0270

946 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of John R. Wood Properties

Selling Office: .

$2,250,000
224102787 MLS
Have you ever wanted the sense of relative isolation...but, still be connected to the mainland? Here at this particular parcel, you experience the island life at it's finest! You have 180 degree water views of the San Carlos Bay to the Gorgeous Gulf of Mexico and then down the channel to Hurricane Pass. This optical indulgence will never have interference in your line of sight giving you never ending sunsets, plenty of sea life to enjoy and let's not forget watching the Charter sea captains coming in with their daily haul of todays catch! This lot sits on a Deep Water Access channel to the Gulf of Mexico with over 80 FT. of Bay Frontage and can accommodate LG. Sea vessels or down your Flats Boat and anything in between. "Living at the end of a Peninsula, is essentially living on the farthest part of a landmass, surrounded by water, and implies a location with a distinct edge." DON'T YOU WANT THE EDGE ON EVERYONE ELSE? This is a fantastic opportunity to build an impressive, jaw dropping single family home or with the current TFC-2 zoning allowing Duplex properties as well. What is left on the property was spared by Hurricane Ian and can be torn down or brought back to life. The pool is structurally sound and ready to be revamped to you liking, the seawall is reinforced with 12" concrete stringers with electric run to go to the dock. This property is going to be brought back to life and that person is going to be crowned the KING or Queen of San Carlos Island, WILL IT BE YOU... OPPORTUNITY IS KNOCKING AND YOU NEED TO LISTEN! You will be the envy of all your friends with some of the best fishing in SW Florida right off your dock, just a short boat ride to BOW TO THE KING and catch the world famous Tarpon or just lay back in your pool and let the beautiful Florida sunshine take your worries away.

908 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of John R. Wood Properties

Selling Office: .

$500,000
224093568 MLS
Seize the chance to own a piece of paradise on San Carlos Island, located at the foot of the iconic Matanzas Bridge on Fort Myers Beach. This prime lot offers an opportunity to build a two story home with a roof viewing area that allows both sunrise and sunset views. This part of San Carlos Island offers an unbeatable combination of relaxation and financial growth, making it the perfect spot to build your dream beach home or an investment property. Enjoy breathtaking water views, the laid-back island lifestyle, and the convenience of nearby shopping, dining, and entertainment—all just minutes away from your doorstep. This ideal location is in high demand and ready for your vision. Whether you're dreaming of a beachside retreat or a profitable rental, the possibilities are endless. Your dream can become a reality. Don’t miss out on this exceptional opportunity to build in the heart of San Carlos Island—where paradise meets investment potential.

919 North Street, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Premiere Plus Realty Company

Selling Office: .

$600,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 224073771 MLS
Welcome to your dream vacation retreat on San Carlos Island! This elevated 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers a perfect blend of coastal charm and potential. It is ideal for those seeking a vacation getaway or an investment opportunity in vacation rentals. Step into a space mostly pieced back together from Hurricane Ian, awaiting your personal touch to complete its transformation. The sprawling lot has plenty of space to add a pool, and the home offers ample parking for cars, boats, or a motorhome. Located on San Carlos Island, this property offers proximity to local attractions, dining, and the pristine beaches of Fort Myers and Sanibel. Whether you want to settle into island life or capitalize on rental income, this home promises endless possibilities. Don't miss out on this opportunity to make it your own!

942 Prescott Street, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of John R. Wood Properties

Selling Office: .

$1,550,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 224065233 MLS
Welcome to this newly constructed (2023) four-bedroom, three-bathroom pool home on San Carlos Island on Fort Myers Beach. Located in an upscale, no-HOA neighborhood, this custom-built, three-story property offers rental potential of $260,000+ annually. Flooded with natural light from hurricane-impact windows, the open-concept interior features vaulted ceilings, a gourmet kitchen, and seamless indoor-outdoor living. A major bonus: this home has never had flood damage, a rare advantage in Southwest Florida Coastal properties. Enjoy the custom heated pool, covered lanai, and second-story balcony for stunning sunsets. Just a short trip to the beach and local dining, this home is perfect as a primary residence or high-income vacation rental.

836 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Premiere Plus Realty Company

Selling Office: .

$1,800,000
224032675 MLS
There is NOT A BETTER DEAL IN ALL OF FORT MYERS BEACH & SAN CARLOS ISLAND AS THIS PROPERTY RIGHT HERE! 60FT OF BAYFRONT/GULF ACCESS PROPERTY ON SAN CARLOS BAY! The OPPORTUNITY here is UN-MATCHED! With zoning being TFC-2, this gives allowance for a SINGLE FAMILY HOME, DUPLEXE OR ONE MAGNIFICENT SINGLE FAMILY COMPOUND. YOU WILL BE KING OR QUEEN OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD! No matter what is built here, all will have ENDLESS SUNSETS, BOAT TRAFFIC WATCHING, and some of the BEST FISHING in SW Florida from your dock or wrangle a TARPON just a short boat ride into the GULF OF MEXICO! WHEN OPPORTUNITY KNOCKS, ANSWER THE DOOR! This property is literally within walking distance to the sugary sands of Fort Myers Beach without sitting in all that traffic! San Carlos Island is also part of Lee County and not a part of the Town of Fort Myers Beach which allows for going through the County vs. the Town of Fort Myers Beach for building. DON'T HESITATE ON THIS OFFER!! LOT WAS RECENTLY SPLIT FROM OTHER PARCEL, NEW PID # 24-46-23-L2-00001.0280

944 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of John R. Wood Properties

Selling Office: .

$2,300,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 224027380 MLS
There is NOT A BETTER DEAL IN ALL OF FORT MYERS BEACH & SAN CARLOS ISLAND AS THIS PROPERTY RIGHT HERE! OVER 80" OF BAYFRONT/GULF ACCESS PROPERTY ON SAN CARLOS BAY! The OPPORTUNITY here is UN-MATCHED! With zoning being TFC-2, this gives allowance for A SINGLE FAMILY HOME, DUPLEX OR ONE MAGNIFICENT SINGLE FAMILY COMPOUND. YOU WILL BE KING OR QUEEN OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD! The single family home on this property had damage from Hurricane Ian, but, structually sound and ready to remodel or be leveled. The dock is in good condition, may need new motors on the lift and some repair. No matter what is built here, all will have ENDLESS SUNSETS, BOAT TRAFFIC WATCHING, and some of the BEST FISHING in SW Florida from your dock or wrangle a TARPON just a short boat ride into the GULF OF MEXICO! WHEN OPPORTUNITY KNOCKS, ANSWER THE DOOR! This property is literally within walking distance to the sugary sands of Fort Myers Beach without sitting in all that traffic! San Carlos Island is also part of Lee County and not a part of the Town of Fort Myers Beach which allows for going through the County vs. the Town of Fort Myers Beach for building. DON'T HESITATE ON THIS OFFER

948 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of John R. Wood Properties

Selling Office: .

$2,250,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 224012891 MLS
This Elevated BOATERS DREAM HOME is what waterfront living in Florida is all about! The Open Concept floor plan with panoramic BAY VIEWS. 3 CAR GARAGE offers tons of storage space while the main living spreads over 2400 sqft. There are 3 large bedrooms up with 4th bedroom in the lower area and 3 full bathrooms. The lower outdoor living space with partial bar/kitchen facing the back bay with a sunset each night will take your breath away. Large dock with a sitting area and covered boat lift. Take a quick boat ride and dine in one of the many waterfront restaurants. This HOME was just remodeled in 2024 from top to bottom and has never been lived in. The property is lined with mature palm trees and maintained landscaping. A short walk to the BEACH and DOWNTOWN Fort Myers Beach yet a quick connection to the mainland is what makes this a highly desired location. Potential Gross Rental Income of $300k.

789 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of John R. Wood Properties

Selling Office: .

$450,000
3 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 223090237 MLS
This property consists of two units. 2 bed/1 bath on one side and 1 bed/1 bath on the opposite side. Each unit having their own entrance and common space. Great investment opportunity and endless options for the first floor of this home as well. Walking distance to the beach and close to shops and restaurants, including the new Margaritaville Resort. Come and be a part of the revitalization of the vibrant island community of Fort Myers Beach. You have found your very own 'Peace' of Paradise!

859-861 South Street, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Turnkey Realty LLC

Selling Office: .

$3,174,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 223079212 MLS
This Elevated BOATERS DREAM HOME on an OVERSIZED LOT is what waterfront living in Florida is all about! The Open Concept floor plan with panoramic BAY VIEWS is laid out for entertaining. The air conditioned 6 CAR GARAGE offers 2770 sqft of storage space while the main living spreads over 2850 sqft with oversized covered patios. There are THREE large bedrooms with full bathrooms. The most spectacular outdoor living space facing your very own captains walk leading to not just one but TWO DEEPWATER BOAT LIFTS will take your breath away. Take a quick boat ride and dine in one of the many waterfront restaurants. Enjoy your morning coffee on the oversized covered front porch catching the morning sun while the prime WESTERN EXPOSURE allows you to end the day with a glass of wine watching the SUN SET over Sanibel Island. This MOVE IN READY HOME was remodeled in 2021 and surrounded by mature palm trees and pristine and immaculately maintained landscaping additional to a NEW SALTWATER POOL AND SPA. A short walk to the BEACH and DOWNTOWN Fort Myers Beach yet a quick connection to the mainland are what makes this a highly desired location. Potential Gross Rental Income of $300k in 2025 onward.

757 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Premiere Plus Realty Company

Selling Office: .

$1,250,000
223010429 MLS
RARE OPPORTUNITY to own this Bayfront property! Offering direct GULF ACCESS from San Carlos Bay and located at the Estero Pass, this .53 acre lot offers a unique opportunity to build your dream home on the north end of San Carlos Island and within view of North Ft. Myers Beach. Be in open water in the Gulf of Mexico with no bridges in less than 10 minutes! You’ll enjoy the PERFECT Southwest Florida waterfront lifestyle with spectacular open water views, as well as all year long crimson sunsets. One mile to the all-new Margaritaville Beach Resort and future Fort Myers Beach rebuilt entertainment district. Original home has been leveled and property is being sold for land value only. Don’t miss your chance to own this RARE slice of paradise!

900 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Realty World J. PAVICH R.E.

Selling Office: .

$375,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 223054998 MLS
Thanks to Hurricane Ian, now is your chance to create your very own 'Peace' of Paradise! This prime, Ft. Myers Beach property sits on an oversized, corner lot on the edge of San Carlos Island. Enjoy a stroll to local restaurants, while catching the breathtaking sunsets of the Island. Master living quarters downstairs, and two, one bedroom efficiencies upstairs, the income opportunity for this property is endless. Come and be a part of the revitalization of the vibrant island community of Fort Myers Beach..

976 San Carlos Court, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Turnkey Realty LLC

Selling Office: .

$1,750,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 223041498 MLS
Enjoy fantastic Sunset views overlooking San Carlos Bay and the Gulf of Mexica. A true boater’s paradise! This is a unique opportunity to make this Bayfront Pool home with sweeping Gulf views your own or tear it down and build something larger. This property has deep water access with no bridges and is about 10 min idle to the open Gulf of Mexico. Walking distance to the beach, shopping, restaurants and easy access of San Carlos Island or you can take the FREE shuttle out to the beach. Home was damaged by Hurricane Ian, but structural engineer has confirmed its sound.

789 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Cornerstone Coastal Properties

Selling Office: .

$610,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 223023929 MLS
This is the cutest house on the street! The property endured damages in Hurricane Ian. The home offered “as is,” has been deemed structurally sound by an engineer. A new metal roof was installed in Aug 2023 per the owners. Enjoy watching sunsets from southwest facing patios off the great room and master bedroom with views of Sanibel and Bowditch Point. This property is a rare find with a huge lot that affords room for a giant pool area and entertainment area. Take a short walk to walk to Doc Ford’s, Dixie Fish House, and Bonita Bill’s. The beach, Times Square, and Margaritaville are only a mile away. This unique location also offers quick access to Fort Myers and Sanibel without the wait in island traffic. Own a piece of SW Florida in a safe, quiet neighborhood, and enjoy everything this property has to offer at a bargain price.

921 North Street, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of Premiere Plus Realty Company

Selling Office: .

$1,900,000
223017008 MLS
Welcome to your luxurious waterfront oasis in San Carlos on the Gulf! This breathtaking piece of land boasts panoramic water views that will take your breath away, and comes with the potential to restore the private dock to its former glory. Nestled in a tranquil and secluded location, this land offers an exclusive and private retreat that feels worlds away from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Yet, it's conveniently located close to all the amenities you need, ensuring you'll never have to sacrifice convenience for luxury. Whether you're a boating enthusiast, a nature lover, or simply someone who enjoys the finer things in life, this property offers the perfect blend of elegance and relaxation. Enjoy the serenity of the calm Gulf waters, or venture out to nearby Fort Myers Beach for an exciting day of sun, sand, and surf. This is the perfect location to build your dream home, a luxurious vacation retreat, or even an investment property that offers unparalleled beauty and exclusivity. Don't miss your chance to own a piece of waterfront paradise in San Carlos on the Gulf- contact us today to learn more about this exceptional opportunity!

936 San Carlos Drive, Fort Myers Beach

Courtesy of EXIT Select Realty

Selling Office: .

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

San Carlos On The Gulf - Fort Myers Beach, FL Homes for Sale

Are you looking to buy or sell a home in San Carlos On The Gulf Fort Myers Beach Florida? Call or Text (239) 880-8850 to schedule a showing on any San Carlos On The Gulf Fort Myers Beach, FL home for sale or to sell your San Carlos On The Gulf Fort Myers Beach Florida home! As Realtors specializing in the San Carlos On The Gulf Fort Myers Beach area, we can take care of all of your San Carlos On The Gulf Fort Myers Beach FL real estate needs including buying pre-existing homes, new construction homes, condominiums, land, commercial and multi-family homes in San Carlos On The Gulf Fort Myers Beach Florida. We can also help you find distressed properties in San Carlos On The Gulf Fort Myers Beach including HUD Homes, Short Sales and REO Bank Foreclosures. If you need help financing a home in San Carlos On The Gulf Fort Myers Beach, we have access to some of the best lenders that service the San Carlos On The Gulf Fort Myers Beach Florida area, including lenders that offer credit repair to buy a home and work with home builders in and near the San Carlos On The Gulf Fort Myers Beach area to help you build your home while building up your credit. If you are going to buy or sell a home in San Carlos On The Gulf Fort Myers Beach Ohio, then be sure to Call or Text (239) 880-8850 Today! We are a real estate team specializing in the San Carlos On The Gulf Fort Myers Beach, FL area! Displayed are homes for sale in San Carlos On The Gulf Fort Myers Beach, FL, a Subdivision located in Fort Myers Beach Florida. These San Carlos On The Gulf Fort Myers Beach Listings are updated every 15 minutes from the Fort Myers Beach MLS.