Tucked in the heart of Matlacha — a colorful, historic fishing village and one of Southwest Florida’s most beloved weekend and snowbird destinations — this classic 1950s duplex offers a rare combination: authentic Old Florida character with real, flexible income potential. Anglers, artists, and island seekers have made this stretch of Pine Island a year-round draw, and this property is built to capture it. The layout offers genuine flexibility for a new owner: live in one side and rent the other for steady supplemental income, or lease both units for a fully income-producing investment property. The duplex has demonstrated success running both models — a long-term tenancy on one side alongside active short-term/vacation rental income on the other. The configuration allows the property to adapt as your plans change. This is not another cookie-cutter Florida property. It is a waterfront Matlacha duplex in a destination known for its brightly colored cottages, locally owned restaurants, art galleries, live music, fishing, boating, kayaking, and relaxed island atmosphere. Guests and tenants can experience the charm of village life while remaining conveniently connected to Pine Island, Cape Coral, Fort Myers, and the surrounding Southwest Florida communities. The waterfront setting and dock access add another layer of appeal for boaters, anglers, paddlers, and vacationers searching for an authentic coastal experience. Morning coffee by the water, afternoons exploring Matlacha Pass, and evenings enjoying fresh seafood and live entertainment are all part of the lifestyle this property can help provide. Properties with this much character, direct gulf access, and rental flexibility are increasingly difficult to find in Matlacha. Whether you are searching for a Southwest Florida investment property, a waterfront duplex, a seasonal escape, or a home that can help offset its own expenses, this property deserves serious consideration. Own a piece of historic Matlacha, generate income, and enjoy the laid-back island lifestyle that continues to draw visitors and residents back year after year. Schedule your private showing and explore the possibilities this distinctive waterfront property offers.

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026033202 MLS

Tucked in the heart of Matlacha — a colorful, historic fishing village and one of Southwest Florida’s most beloved weekend and snowbird destinations — this classic 1950s duplex offers a rare combination: authentic Old Florida character with real, flexible income potential. Anglers, artists, and island seekers have made this stretch of Pine Island a year-round draw, and this property is built to capture it. The layout offers genuine flexibility for a new owner: live in one side and rent the other for steady supplemental income, or lease both units for a fully income-producing investment property. The duplex has demonstrated success running both models — a long-term tenancy on one side alongside active short-term/vacation rental income on the other. The configuration allows the property to adapt as your plans change. This is not another cookie-cutter Florida property. It is a waterfront Matlacha duplex in a destination known for its brightly colored cottages, locally owned restaurants, art galleries, live music, fishing, boating, kayaking, and relaxed island atmosphere. Guests and tenants can experience the charm of village life while remaining conveniently connected to Pine Island, Cape Coral, Fort Myers, and the surrounding Southwest Florida communities. The waterfront setting and dock access add another layer of appeal for boaters, anglers, paddlers, and vacationers searching for an authentic coastal experience. Morning coffee by the water, afternoons exploring Matlacha Pass, and evenings enjoying fresh seafood and live entertainment are all part of the lifestyle this property can help provide. Properties with this much character, direct gulf access, and rental flexibility are increasingly difficult to find in Matlacha. Whether you are searching for a Southwest Florida investment property, a waterfront duplex, a seasonal escape, or a home that can help offset its own expenses, this property deserves serious consideration. Own a piece of historic Matlacha, generate income, and enjoy the laid-back island lifestyle that continues to draw visitors and residents back year after year. Schedule your private showing and explore the possibilities this distinctive waterfront property offers.

2623 2nd Street, Matlacha

Listing Courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty

$409,000

Experience the Matlacha island lifestyle from this charming historic home featuring direct water access, impact windows, a private garage, and an oversized yard. Located directly across from Matlacha Park and the public boat launch, this property places you just steps from historic downtown Matlacha, waterfront restaurants, art galleries, local shops, fishing, kayaking, and open-water adventures. Inside, the home offers stainless steel appliances, easy-care tile flooring, updated electrical, and a newer Florida room with peaceful views of the surrounding natural scenery. Impact windows add valuable storm protection, energy efficiency, and peace of mind. The oversized yard is a rare find in Matlacha, providing space for outdoor entertaining, gardening, recreational equipment, or future improvements. The garage and additional bonus square footage offer even more flexibility for storage, hobbies, or customization. Whether you are searching for a full-time residence, seasonal Florida escape, weekend fishing retreat, or income-producing rental property, this home offers an exceptional combination of location, waterfront access, character, and opportunity. Homes with direct water access in the heart of Matlacha are difficult to duplicate. Schedule your private showing today and see why this unique island property deserves your attention.

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 2026031165 MLS

Experience the Matlacha island lifestyle from this charming historic home featuring direct water access, impact windows, a private garage, and an oversized yard. Located directly across from Matlacha Park and the public boat launch, this property places you just steps from historic downtown Matlacha, waterfront restaurants, art galleries, local shops, fishing, kayaking, and open-water adventures. Inside, the home offers stainless steel appliances, easy-care tile flooring, updated electrical, and a newer Florida room with peaceful views of the surrounding natural scenery. Impact windows add valuable storm protection, energy efficiency, and peace of mind. The oversized yard is a rare find in Matlacha, providing space for outdoor entertaining, gardening, recreational equipment, or future improvements. The garage and additional bonus square footage offer even more flexibility for storage, hobbies, or customization. Whether you are searching for a full-time residence, seasonal Florida escape, weekend fishing retreat, or income-producing rental property, this home offers an exceptional combination of location, waterfront access, character, and opportunity. Homes with direct water access in the heart of Matlacha are difficult to duplicate. Schedule your private showing today and see why this unique island property deserves your attention.

11242 Matlacha Avenue, Matlacha

Listing Courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty

$445,000

This cleared quarter-acre waterfront lot offers direct Gulf access with no bridges, presenting an exceptional opportunity for builders, investors, or end users seeking a prime boating location. Positioned along the scenic Matlacha Pass, the property includes approximately 200 feet of solid concrete seawall, a beautifully constructed Ipe wood dock, and a 500-square-foot boathouse with a durable Galvalum metal roof—significant improvements already in place to support future construction. The site provides ample room to design and build a custom waterfront residence with space for a pool, outdoor living areas, and expansive water views. With the lot cleared and waterfront infrastructure established, this property allows for efficient planning and development while maximizing the coastal setting. Enjoy spectacular sunrises and sunsets, abundant wildlife, and a vibrant boating and fishing community in an area renowned for world-class fishing. From your dock, enjoy effortless access to Pine Island Sound, Charlotte Harbor, Tarpon Pass, Redfish Pass, and the open Gulf. Whether envisioning a private retreat or a custom waterfront build, this rare offering delivers the ideal foundation for the ultimate Southwest Florida lifestyle.

2026000467 MLS

This cleared quarter-acre waterfront lot offers direct Gulf access with no bridges, presenting an exceptional opportunity for builders, investors, or end users seeking a prime boating location. Positioned along the scenic Matlacha Pass, the property includes approximately 200 feet of solid concrete seawall, a beautifully constructed Ipe wood dock, and a 500-square-foot boathouse with a durable Galvalum metal roof—significant improvements already in place to support future construction. The site provides ample room to design and build a custom waterfront residence with space for a pool, outdoor living areas, and expansive water views. With the lot cleared and waterfront infrastructure established, this property allows for efficient planning and development while maximizing the coastal setting. Enjoy spectacular sunrises and sunsets, abundant wildlife, and a vibrant boating and fishing community in an area renowned for world-class fishing. From your dock, enjoy effortless access to Pine Island Sound, Charlotte Harbor, Tarpon Pass, Redfish Pass, and the open Gulf. Whether envisioning a private retreat or a custom waterfront build, this rare offering delivers the ideal foundation for the ultimate Southwest Florida lifestyle.

2639 Second Street, Matlacha

Listing Courtesy of John R. Wood Properties

Selling Office: .

$665,000

Waterfront Boater’s Paradise with No Rental Restrictions! What sets this home apart? Rare, extensive permitted upgrades! In 2023: new AC, metal roof, flooring, insulation, plumbing, impact windows/doors, electric meter, and custom stucco paneling. In 2022: Alpha Foundations helical pilings and a brand-new seawall—true peace of mind for waterfront living. Nestled between Pine Island and Cape Coral in the vibrant village of Matlacha, this fully upgraded two-story home offers 2,300+ sq. ft. of coastal charm. The concrete lower level and wood-frame upper level feature 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a private pool, and a garage—ideal as a primary residence or a top-performing rental. Enjoy direct Gulf access with a boat lift, captain’s walk, and dock with water hookup. Take in unforgettable sunrises and sunsets from the top balcony and stroll to Matlacha’s iconic shops, seafood markets, and waterfront dining. With no HOA and no rental restrictions, you have the freedom to enjoy or invest—your slice of paradise is waiting. Schedule your showing today!

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 225005676 MLS

Waterfront Boater’s Paradise with No Rental Restrictions! What sets this home apart? Rare, extensive permitted upgrades! In 2023: new AC, metal roof, flooring, insulation, plumbing, impact windows/doors, electric meter, and custom stucco paneling. In 2022: Alpha Foundations helical pilings and a brand-new seawall—true peace of mind for waterfront living. Nestled between Pine Island and Cape Coral in the vibrant village of Matlacha, this fully upgraded two-story home offers 2,300+ sq. ft. of coastal charm. The concrete lower level and wood-frame upper level feature 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a private pool, and a garage—ideal as a primary residence or a top-performing rental. Enjoy direct Gulf access with a boat lift, captain’s walk, and dock with water hookup. Take in unforgettable sunrises and sunsets from the top balcony and stroll to Matlacha’s iconic shops, seafood markets, and waterfront dining. With no HOA and no rental restrictions, you have the freedom to enjoy or invest—your slice of paradise is waiting. Schedule your showing today!

2597 Third Street, Matlacha

Listing Courtesy of Royal Shell Real Estate, Inc.

Selling Office: .

$340,000

Discover the charm of Majestic Matlacha! This cleared, quarter-acre vacant lot offers direct Gulf access with no bridges, ensuring smooth sailing to some of Florida’s most iconic waters. Featuring approximately 200 feet of sturdy concrete seawall along the picturesque Matlacha Pass, this property provides the perfect foundation for your custom waterfront retreat. Envision your dream home complete with a pool, surrounded by stunning tropical vistas. Enjoy breathtaking sunrises and sunsets, abundant wildlife, and a welcoming community of boaters and anglers in a location celebrated for world-class fishing. With easy boat access to Pine Island Sound, Charlotte Harbor, Tarpon Pass, Redfish Pass, and the open Gulf, this is your opportunity to embrace the ultimate Florida lifestyle. Don’t miss your chance to make this slice of paradise your own!

225000323 MLS

Discover the charm of Majestic Matlacha! This cleared, quarter-acre vacant lot offers direct Gulf access with no bridges, ensuring smooth sailing to some of Florida’s most iconic waters. Featuring approximately 200 feet of sturdy concrete seawall along the picturesque Matlacha Pass, this property provides the perfect foundation for your custom waterfront retreat. Envision your dream home complete with a pool, surrounded by stunning tropical vistas. Enjoy breathtaking sunrises and sunsets, abundant wildlife, and a welcoming community of boaters and anglers in a location celebrated for world-class fishing. With easy boat access to Pine Island Sound, Charlotte Harbor, Tarpon Pass, Redfish Pass, and the open Gulf, this is your opportunity to embrace the ultimate Florida lifestyle. Don’t miss your chance to make this slice of paradise your own!

2638 Second Street, Matlacha

Listing Courtesy of John R. Wood Properties

Selling Office: .

$540,000

Welcome to the Matlacha Tiny Village – Where COASTAL CHARM meets BIG Opportunity! This extraordinary property features THREE charming, Amish built TINY HOMES, each uniquely designed to capture the artistic and vibrant spirit of Matlacha. Each tiny home features a well-appointed kitchenette with induction cooktop, refrigerator, microwave and coffee maker, providing all the comforts of home. These charming units are highly sought after, renting for $225+ per night during peak season and $129-$149 per night off-season, making them an outstanding year-round income opportunity! Perfectly situated on a prime GULF ACCESS waterfront lot with OVERSIZE DOCK (up to a 32’ boat) and kayak launch, six guest parking spots, utilities and room for two or three more tiny/RV homes. The property offers dockside fishing, serene sunrises and direct access to the Gulf of Mexico’s world-renowned fishing and waterways. Nestled in the heart of Matlacha, this one-of-a-kind property perfectly embodies the area’s artistic and laid-back vibe. Matlacha is a tiny, Old Florida fishing village with iconic galleries, restaurants and boutiques. The property’s prime waterfront location offers direct access to the Gulf of Mexico, making it an outdoor enthusiast’s paradise for fishing, kayaking or simply enjoying breathtaking sunsets. Perfectly suited for nightly, short-term or monthly vacation rentals. This is a great entrepreneurial venture for the innovative spirit looking to capitalize on the growing trend of sustainable, minimalist living while providing a truly unique experience for visitors. A property like this is truly one of a kind, combining unparalleled income potential with the unique opportunity to be on the ground floor of Matlacha’s pivotal and inspiring revitalization. Whether you’re an innovative entrepreneur, savvy investor, seasoned VRBO owner or dreamer seeking a slice of paradise, the Matlacha Tiny Village is your canvas to create something remarkable. This business opportunity can be turnkey, with an established website, active social media presence, etc. making it ready to generate income again immediately. Create a SOCIAL MEDIA SENSATION by transforming this property into a must-visit destination for eco-conscious travelers and tiny home enthusiasts. With its sustainable design, minimalist charm, and prime location in vibrant Matlacha, this property is poised to capture the hearts of tourists and influencers alike. Showcase its unique appeal through captivating content and turn it into the next viral hotspot for authentic, unforgettable experiences. This is a legally, non-conforming, grandfathered RV Park with a future land use designation of commercial C-1, offering abundant opportunities for future development and growth. This location offers exceptional visibility and exposure, ensuring your property stands out and attracts attention. Walking distance to Matlacha Community Center, Park, Art Center, Public Parking, Boat Launch, Restaurants & Shops. Call us!

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 224097651 MLS

Welcome to the Matlacha Tiny Village – Where COASTAL CHARM meets BIG Opportunity! This extraordinary property features THREE charming, Amish built TINY HOMES, each uniquely designed to capture the artistic and vibrant spirit of Matlacha. Each tiny home features a well-appointed kitchenette with induction cooktop, refrigerator, microwave and coffee maker, providing all the comforts of home. These charming units are highly sought after, renting for $225+ per night during peak season and $129-$149 per night off-season, making them an outstanding year-round income opportunity! Perfectly situated on a prime GULF ACCESS waterfront lot with OVERSIZE DOCK (up to a 32’ boat) and kayak launch, six guest parking spots, utilities and room for two or three more tiny/RV homes. The property offers dockside fishing, serene sunrises and direct access to the Gulf of Mexico’s world-renowned fishing and waterways. Nestled in the heart of Matlacha, this one-of-a-kind property perfectly embodies the area’s artistic and laid-back vibe. Matlacha is a tiny, Old Florida fishing village with iconic galleries, restaurants and boutiques. The property’s prime waterfront location offers direct access to the Gulf of Mexico, making it an outdoor enthusiast’s paradise for fishing, kayaking or simply enjoying breathtaking sunsets. Perfectly suited for nightly, short-term or monthly vacation rentals. This is a great entrepreneurial venture for the innovative spirit looking to capitalize on the growing trend of sustainable, minimalist living while providing a truly unique experience for visitors. A property like this is truly one of a kind, combining unparalleled income potential with the unique opportunity to be on the ground floor of Matlacha’s pivotal and inspiring revitalization. Whether you’re an innovative entrepreneur, savvy investor, seasoned VRBO owner or dreamer seeking a slice of paradise, the Matlacha Tiny Village is your canvas to create something remarkable. This business opportunity can be turnkey, with an established website, active social media presence, etc. making it ready to generate income again immediately. Create a SOCIAL MEDIA SENSATION by transforming this property into a must-visit destination for eco-conscious travelers and tiny home enthusiasts. With its sustainable design, minimalist charm, and prime location in vibrant Matlacha, this property is poised to capture the hearts of tourists and influencers alike. Showcase its unique appeal through captivating content and turn it into the next viral hotspot for authentic, unforgettable experiences. This is a legally, non-conforming, grandfathered RV Park with a future land use designation of commercial C-1, offering abundant opportunities for future development and growth. This location offers exceptional visibility and exposure, ensuring your property stands out and attracts attention. Walking distance to Matlacha Community Center, Park, Art Center, Public Parking, Boat Launch, Restaurants & Shops. Call us!

4661 Pine Island Road NW, Matlacha

Listing Courtesy of Encore Realty Services Inc

Selling Office: .

$360,000

This CLEARED, VACANT and BUILDABLE lot with 50’ of CONCRETE SEAWALL is located on a QUIET, DEAD-END Street just a short TWO BLOCK walk to the HEART OF MATLACHA. Matlacha is a charming fishing village is known for its artistic flair, seafood restaurants and island boutique shopping. Capture dolphins and manatees swimming right from the backyard of your Florida dream home. This area is known for its spectacular boating. Just a short boat ride down the canal leads you to the Pine Island Sound and the Gulf of Mexico. Prefer to island hop? Take the boat and head to islands only accessible by boat! Pack a lunch for Picnic Island. Enjoy the views at Cayo Costa and world class fishing on North Captiva. Savor a cheeseburger in paradise at Cabbage Key. With world-renowned fishing throughout the area, cast a fishing line from the backyard and it might just bring in a snook, snapper or red fish to name a few. Boca Grande, the TARPON FISHING CAPITAL of the WORLD is minutes away by boat. Cape Coral and downtown Fort Myers are just a short drive away. A dream home awaits you here in Matlacha ready to allow you to watch the colors bounce with the evening sunsets and enjoy the Florida lifestyle.

224026394 MLS

This CLEARED, VACANT and BUILDABLE lot with 50’ of CONCRETE SEAWALL is located on a QUIET, DEAD-END Street just a short TWO BLOCK walk to the HEART OF MATLACHA. Matlacha is a charming fishing village is known for its artistic flair, seafood restaurants and island boutique shopping. Capture dolphins and manatees swimming right from the backyard of your Florida dream home. This area is known for its spectacular boating. Just a short boat ride down the canal leads you to the Pine Island Sound and the Gulf of Mexico. Prefer to island hop? Take the boat and head to islands only accessible by boat! Pack a lunch for Picnic Island. Enjoy the views at Cayo Costa and world class fishing on North Captiva. Savor a cheeseburger in paradise at Cabbage Key. With world-renowned fishing throughout the area, cast a fishing line from the backyard and it might just bring in a snook, snapper or red fish to name a few. Boca Grande, the TARPON FISHING CAPITAL of the WORLD is minutes away by boat. Cape Coral and downtown Fort Myers are just a short drive away. A dream home awaits you here in Matlacha ready to allow you to watch the colors bounce with the evening sunsets and enjoy the Florida lifestyle.

2621 1st Street, Matlacha

Listing Courtesy of Keller Williams Island Life RE

Selling Office: .

$410,000

Great Matlacha Home!

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 224021219 MLS

Great Matlacha Home!

11226 Matlacha Avenue, Matlacha

Listing Courtesy of John R. Wood Properties

Selling Office: .