Homes for Sale - Hayesville, Ohio

Welcome home to this well-maintained property nestled on a .6777-acre lot at the edge of Hayesville! Enjoy outdoor living from the deck overlooking the spacious backyard. The home features an attached 2-car garage with opener and keypad entry, plus a 1.5-car detached garage with wood floor, 2023 roof, and garage door opener. Inside, you'll find an eat-in kitchen with appliances included, hardwood floors (some currently under carpet), and a finished lower-level family room offering additional living space. The waterproofed basement includes a sump pump, extra oven, freezer, and abundant storage. Additional updates and features include newer windows, 2016 house roof, newer tile shower in the primary bath, central air, furnace with UV bulb and humidifier, gas water heater, whole-house generator, city sewer, and well water. A wonderful combination of comfort, convenience, and small-town living!

26 Harclay Court, Hayesville

Listing Courtesy of: Shannon Hill, shannonhill@remax.net With RE/MAX Showcase

Selling Office: Non-Member.

$399,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5211654 MLS

This 3 suite fully rented all brick Historical Building is a terrific investment. The Kelley Hardware/Odd Fellows Hall is a 2-story brick Italianate style building that stands at the center of Hayesville. It’s adjacent to the restored Village Hall and Opera House. Across the street is a pizza parlor and restaurant plus there is the Village Point Market and a coffee shop. This 1882 building is listed on the National Register of Historic Places, the nation’s list of properties worthy of preservation. It measures 27x60 feet and is of brick bearing wall construction with heavy timber floors. Both floors have exceptionally tall 14-foot ceilings. It is divided into three apartments. The first floor has front and back units that share the original hardware store shelves. Every unit has one bedroom and one bath, but each share the large partially finished basement. Each unit also has a mezzanine level for added space. There is a common hall and laundry in the basement. Every unit has its own central HVAC and electric. The second floor is a single large apartment, accessed by a grand stairway. It has 2 bedrooms and 2 baths. Peepholes in doors testify to its past as a social hall. This unit has a large south-facing balcony. Of special interest are its narrow 10-ft tall windows with restored interior shutters. Each unit has a modern kitchen with custom cabinets, granite countertops and stainless steel appliances, including deluxe refrigerators, self-cleaning ranges and microwaves plus dishwashers. The 120-foot property has a deep drive and a 3-car carport. The property has city water/sewer and cable. With your investment, you will also a receive a tax abatement. This property is less than 10 minutes from shopping, restaurants and freeway. Enjoy the outdoors at Mohican State Park just minutes down the road. THIS IS A MUST SEE INVESTMENT!!!

7 E Main Street, Hayesville

Listing Courtesy of: Dante DiBenedetto, dante2000d@gmail.com With RE/MAX Real Estate Group

$170,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5196943 MLS

Charming and spacious 3-bedroom home in the heart of Hayesville offering over 1,600 square feet of living space. This property features a large kitchen, formal dining room, and generous living room with plenty of natural light. First-floor laundry adds convenience, along with an additional office and workshop area. Upstairs you’ll find three nicely sized bedrooms and a convenient half bath. Covered front porch perfect for relaxing, plus public water and sewer. **Attached 3-car garage** with ample parking, gravel drive, and additional storage space, including an **8,000 lb 4-post vehicle lift** — perfect for car enthusiasts, hobbyists, or extra storage. Affordable opportunity for those looking for small-town living. Located in Hillsdale School District.

87 N Mechanic Street, Hayesville

Listing Courtesy of: Linda J Reibenstein, lreibenstein2001@outlook.com With RE/MAX Edge Realty

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Ward RE.

$242,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5190073 MLS

Welcome to this unique and beautifully built barndominium, tucked away on a quiet dead-end street in a peaceful township near Haysville. Built in 2020, this thoughtfully designed home sits on nearly ¾ of an acre with open land behind it, offering privacy, space, and a modern rural feel. Step inside to an inviting open floor plan that seamlessly connects the kitchen, dining, and family room areas—perfect for both everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen comes fully equipped with all appliances staying, and the space is highlighted by abundant recessed lighting throughout the home. The main level features a large full bathroom with generous storage, along with a spacious laundry and mudroom that also offers additional storage. Upstairs, a versatile loft area includes double closets and provides flexible space for a bedroom, office, or additional living area. The attached garage is built to impress with 16-foot ceilings, a 14-foot insulated commercial garage door, and its own gas heat, making it ideal for vehicles, hobbies, or workshop space. Quality construction continues with 6-inch thick concrete walls between the home and garage, along with a 6-inch thick concrete driveway and garage floor reinforced with rebar and fiber mesh. The property is equipped with 200-amp service and dual inverters for efficient heating and cooling. Step outside to enjoy the covered back porch, a perfect place to relax and take in the quiet surroundings. The property also includes two large freshly painted sheds—one 12×20 with electric and partially finished interior, and another 12×24 for additional storage or workspace. With modern construction, quality materials, and a peaceful setting just minutes from town conveniences, this one-of-a-kind property offers the perfect blend of functionality, efficiency, and country charm.

19 Harclay Court, Hayesville

Listing Courtesy of: Heather L Dimitrov, heatherdimitrov@kw.com With Keller Williams Elevate

Selling Office: RE/MAX Showcase.

$999,000

5 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths ⋅ 5147612 MLS

The Vermillion Institute is a grand landmark with a rich history. When built in 1845, it was the largest building in the county and housed a college, predecessor to the College of Wooster. This National Register-listed property was later the local high school and sat empty for years until rescued and completely rebuilt to modern codes about 10 years ago under supervision of the National Park Service. It educated future U. S. Senators, Congressmen, industrialists and people who went on to found other colleges. The building is notable for its solid brick walls, 10 ½ foot ceilings, 72 large windows and fine Greek Revival styling. It has solid cherry woodwork, white oak floors and a grand staircase rising four levels. Its ground floor once was the school chapel and is a large open space perfect for meetings and gatherings, opening onto a broad private patio and indoor garden room with pond and plants. This space has a serving kitchenette. The second or main floor has a grand open kitchen, dining and living area 50 feet long. Its dining room has beautiful historic wallpaper plus there is a bedroom with private bath on this level. The third floor has a two-story grand library with fireplace and plenty of bookshelves. Three bedroom suites, each with private bath, are on this floor. One is used as an upstairs living room and has a wood-burning fireplace. There are two outdoor terraces at this level. The fourth floor has another living room with kitchenette and a very spacious bedroom suite. The fifth floor is a grand office with fine views in all directions. The rehabilitation involved gutting down to the four outside walls and carefully rebuilding the floors and roof to modern standards with plans by a professional engineer. It has all-new plumbing, electrical and modern zoned HVAC systems. Its foundation was underpinned and perimeter drainage system installed. Brick walls were completely repointed. This 7,000+ sq. ft. home is an absolute masterpiece.

150 E Main Street, Hayesville

Listing Courtesy of: Tony E DiBenedetto, tonydee563@gmail.com With RE/MAX Real Estate Group

$179,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5146862 MLS

Full of charm and character, this three-bedroom ranch in the sought-after Hillsdale School District is ready to welcome its next owner. The inviting living room features a cozy fireplace, perfect for relaxing evenings, while the eat-in kitchen offers space for a larger dining table and comes complete with updated appliances. Laundry has been conveniently moved to the first floor and is currently located in one of the bedrooms, making day-to-day living a breeze. The full basement provides additional storage with plenty of potential to make it your own. Basement needs some TLC. Outside, you’ll find a generous backyard, ideal for gardening, play, or entertaining, along with a storage shed and a one car garage. An inground pool is also on the property, it hasn’t been used in several years and will likely need to be filled in or substantial work done to bring it back to life. Property is selling as is. With its desirable location, welcoming layout, and room to personalize, this home is a great opportunity to enjoy both comfort and convenience.

763 County Road 30-A, Hayesville

Listing Courtesy of: Adam P Hanzie, adam@wileshanzie.com With Wiles Hanzie Realty

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Ward RE.

$670,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 5134116 MLS

Welcome to this stunning 25 acre gentleman's farm, nestled down a long, serene lane. This property offers pastures, lake metal pole barn perfect for animals. Also includes metal insulated workshop with 5 overhead doors, water, and wood stove. Enjoy the convenience of city water, city sewer services and generator. Ranch home built in 2000 with open floor plan, cathedral ceiling, living room with full glass walls & doors to sprawling rear deck. Amazing views of the countryside. Gourmet kitchen with island, double oven and cooktop. Walk out basement with 2nd kitchen, 4th bedroom and 3 full bath.

112 W Main Street, Hayesville

Listing Courtesy of: Rob Ward, robcbward@gmail.com With Coldwell Banker Ward RE

Selling Office: Non-Member.

$130,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 225015259 MLS

Welcome to 28 W Main St., a delightful two-story cottage offering small-town charm with big-time value. Built in 1900 and thoughtfully maintained, this 2-bedroom, 1-bath home features 1,148 sq ft of cozy living space on a manageable 0.1653-acre lot. Enjoy the comfort of main-floor laundry and the warmth of a wood-burning stove, complemented by a durable metal roof for peace of mind. The spacious 24x24 two-car detached garage includes a 24x30 lean-to—perfect for a workshop, storage, or creative pursuits. Outdoors, a wrap-around deck invites relaxation, while the garden area is ready for your green thumb. Just a short stroll to downtown Hayesville, this home blends country appeal with in-town convenience. Don't miss this opportunity to own a slice of charm at an affordable price!

28 W Main Street, Hayesville

Listing Courtesy of : Stacey J Wampler ---- Sluss Realty Company

Selling Office: NON MEMBER OFFICE.

$184,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5118953 MLS

Conveniently located downtown Hayesville, near dining, post office, schools and US-30. 1st floor bedroom and laundry/mudroom. Spacious attached 2-car garage, newer metal roof, siding, and insulation. Almost every window in the home has been replaced along with a new Trane furnace installed in 2017! Bath fitter updated bathroom in 2016. Enjoy the updates that the current owner has already done for you and make the rest your own. Hillsdale schools, and ample parking behind the home. Open house Sat., May 3rd 11:00-12:00pm.

20 Mechanic Street, Hayesville

Listing Courtesy of: Amanda Frye, afryecbward@gmail.com With Coldwell Banker Ward RE

Selling Office: Keller Williams Elevate.

$260,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 4506944 MLS

Step inside this beautifully upgraded home with abundant natural light. Your renovated, move in ready home has 3 bedrooms and 1.5 baths and is located in the highly sought after Hillsdale School District. Additionally, the home has a finished lower level with a flex room that would make a great fourth bedroom or office space. An oversized attached two car garage leads to mature shade trees and creates a beautiful backyard to enjoy. The property is situated on a .68 acre lot on a private quiet cul-de-sac. Great location, within close proximity to US-30. This is a must see home. Schedule your private showing today.

24 Harclay Court, Hayesville

Listing Courtesy of: Michael Tyson, miket@sorrellandco.com With Sorrell & Co., Inc.

Selling Office: NextHome Next Stepp, Inc..

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

Homes for Sale - Hayesville, Ohio

Call or Text (614) 683-5116 to schedule a showing on any Hayesville, OH home for sale or to sell your Hayesville Ohio home!