Market report, updated October 8, 2026

Siesta Isles Home Values and Market Report

Search in the subdivision of Siesta Isles

Create your own market report

Report prepared by localrealestateonline.com Coldwell Banker Realty

+1(614)983-3277

Market at a glance

Over the last 12 months, homes sold for 91.3% of list price in 150 days on average.

Average price, last 12 months

What sellers asked vs. what homes actually sold for, by closing month.

List · $725K Sold · $700K

$3.7M$2.7M$1.7M$700K

OctNovDecJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSep

Homes sold per month

Closed sales, last 12 months.

2 O

1 N

4 D

1 J

2 F

6 M

1 A

3 M

4 J

1 A

1 S

Peak: 6 sales in Mar. Last month: 1.

Where the market stands

All homes in this report, by status.

Buyer's or seller's market?

Months it would take to sell every active home at the pace of the last 6 months.

3.9months of inventory

Seller's, under 4BalancedBuyer's, over 6

Homes are selling quickly, which favors sellers in this market.

Average price by status

Active$1.85M

Under contract$1.95M

Sold$1.43M

Average days on market

Active115 days

Under contract156 days

Sold150 days

Browse homes by status

Choose a status to see its numbers, charts and listings.

Active homes

Currently for sale

Homes for sale 9

Average list price $1,854,000

Avg. days on market 115 days

Avg. price per ft² $840 Based on 5 of 9 homes

Avg. living area 3,076 ft² Based on 5 of 9 homes

Avg. beds / baths 3.6 / 3.4

Price vs. living area

Each dot is a home. Hover a dot for its address.

4 homes didn’t report living area and aren’t shown.

$6M$4M$2M$0

0 ft²2,0004,0006,000 ft²

How long homes have been listed

Number of homes by days on market.

1 0–30 days

3 31–90

3 91–180

2 181–365

0 365+

Bedroom mix

Number of homes by bedroom count.

4 homes didn’t report bedrooms and aren’t shown.

2 ≤3 bd

3 4 bd

0 5 bd

0 6 bd

0 7 bd

0 8+ bd

Highest price per ft²

Top 5 homes in this status.

5572 Shadow Lawn Drive$1,361

813 Idlewild Way$912

829 Idlewild Way$852

5541 Cape Aqua Drive$683

5451 Shadow Lawn Drive$395

All active listings

Click a column to sort

Address	Beds	Baths	Living ft²	List price	$ / ft²	Days on market
5572 Shadow Lawn DriveSiesta Key, FL 34242	4	5	3,523	$4,795,000	$1,361	126 days
813 Idlewild WaySiesta Key, FL 34242	4	3	4,161	$3,795,000	$912	127 days
829 Idlewild WaySiesta Key, FL 34242	4	4	3,696	$3,150,000	$852	28 days
5541 Cape Aqua DriveSiesta Key, FL 34242	3	2	1,828	$1,250,000	$683	35 days
5451 Shadow Lawn DriveSiesta Key, FL 34242	3	3	2,172	$859,000	$395	91 days
18164 Cutlass DriveFort Myers Beach, FL 33931	—	—	—	$799,000	—	275 days
18291 Cutlass DriveFort Myers Beach, FL 33931	—	—	—	$700,000	—	48 days
12070 Siesta DriveFort Myers Beach, FL 33931	—	—	—	$689,000	—	274 days
12110/12112 Siesta DriveFort Myers Beach, FL 33931	—	—	—	$649,000	—	34 days

Under contract homes

Pending and contingent sales

Homes under contract 2

Average list price $1,949,999

Avg. days on market 156 days

Avg. price per ft² $762

Avg. living area 2,718 ft²

Avg. beds / baths 3.5 / 3.5

Price vs. living area

Each dot is a home. Hover a dot for its address.

$3M$2M$1M$0

0 ft²2,0004,0006,000 ft²

Days on market before going under contract

Number of homes by days on market.

0 0–30 days

0 31–90

1 91–180

1 181–365

0 365+

Bedroom mix

Number of homes by bedroom count.

1 ≤3 bd

1 4 bd

0 5 bd

0 6 bd

0 7 bd

0 8+ bd

Highest price per ft²

Top 2 homes in this status.

5507 Contento Drive$894

927 Contento Street$630

All under contract listings

Click a column to sort

Address	Beds	Baths	Living ft²	List price	$ / ft²	Days on market
927 Contento StreetSiesta Key, FL 34242	4	4	3,649	$2,300,000	$630	108 days
5507 Contento DriveSiesta Key, FL 34242	3	3	1,788	$1,599,999	$894	205 days

Sold homes

Closed in the last 12 months

Homes sold 29

Average sold price $1,427,362

Avg. days to sell 150 days

Sold vs. list price 91.3%

Avg. price per ft² $588 Based on 23 of 29 homes

Avg. living area 2,591 ft² Based on 23 of 29 homes

Price vs. living area

Each dot is a home. Hover a dot for its address.

6 homes didn’t report living area and aren’t shown.

$6M$4M$2M$0

0 ft²2,0004,0006,000 ft²

How long homes took to sell

Number of homes by days on market.

7 0–30 days

6 31–90

7 91–180

5 181–365

4 365+

Bedroom mix

Number of homes by bedroom count.

6 homes didn’t report bedrooms and aren’t shown.

13 ≤3 bd

5 4 bd

4 5 bd

1 6 bd

0 7 bd

0 8+ bd

Highest price per ft²

Top 7 homes in this status.

5362 Shadow Lawn Drive$1,045

819 Paradise Way$888

18435 Deep Passage Lane$779

5215 Cape Leyte Drive$690

1038 Contento Street$676

5348 Shadow Lawn Drive$666

5560 Shadow Lawn Drive$635

Sold price vs. list price

How close homes sold to their asking price.

10% sold at or above asking

21 Under 95%

5 95–98%

0 98–100%

3 100–102%

0 Over 102%

All sold listings

Click a column to sort

Address	Beds	Baths	Living ft²	Sold price	Sold / list	$ / ft²	Days to sell
5362 Shadow Lawn DriveSiesta Key, FL 34242	3	5	4,294	$4,490,000	90.7%	$1,045	163 days
18276 Cutlass DriveFort Myers Beach, FL 33931	6	7	5,767	$2,850,000	81.4%	$494	135 days
819 Paradise WaySiesta Key, FL 34242	3	3	2,505	$2,225,000	96.9%	$888	10 days
951 Contento St.Siesta Key, FL 34242	3	3	2,882	$1,750,000	92.6%	$607	107 days
18468 Cutlass DriveFort Myers Beach, FL 33931	5	4	3,114	$1,700,000	91.9%	$545	380 days
5353 Cape Leyte DriveSiesta Key, FL 34242	—	—	—	$1,650,000	94.3%	—	24 days
5348 Shadow Lawn DriveSiesta Key, FL 34242	3	3	2,477	$1,650,000	91.9%	$666	24 days
5448 Azure WaySiesta Key, FL 34242	—	—	—	$1,600,000	91.4%	—	100 days
18484 Deep Passage LaneFort Myers Beach, FL 33931	4	4	3,228	$1,595,000	88.9%	$494	78 days
822 Paradise WaySiesta Key, FL 34242	—	—	—	$1,575,000	100.0%	—	3 days

Questions about this market?

These numbers move every month. For what they mean for your home, or for a home you have your eye on, get in touch.

localrealestateonline.com Coldwell Banker Realty

Call +1(614)983-3277

Next steps

Free and instant. We can follow up with a detailed valuation.

City

Subdivision

Price

Max List Price

Beds

Baths

Property Type Home Commercial Land

Advanced Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.