Market report, updated October 11, 2026

Castaway Key Unrecorded Subdivision Home Values and Market Report

Search in the subdivision of Castaway Key Unrecorded Subdivision

Create your own market report

Report prepared by localrealestateonline.com Coldwell Banker Realty

+1(614)983-3277

Market at a glance

Over the last 12 months, homes sold for 86.4% of list price in 233 days on average.

Average price, last 12 months

What sellers asked vs. what homes actually sold for, by closing month.

List · $1000K Sold · $974K

$1.5M$1M$500K$0K

OctNovDecJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSep

Homes sold per month

Closed sales, last 12 months.

0 O

0 N

0 D

0 J

0 F

0 M

1 A

0 M

0 J

1 J

1 A

0 S

Peak: 1 sale in Apr. Last month: 0.

Where the market stands

All homes in this report, by status.

Buyer's or seller's market?

Months it would take to sell every active home at the pace of the last 6 months.

20.0months of inventory

Seller's, under 4BalancedBuyer's, over 6

Buyers have room to negotiate in this market.

Average price by status

Active$1.01M

Under contract$1.59M

Sold$817K

Average days on market

Active183 days

Under contract331 days

Sold233 days

Browse homes by status

Choose a status to see its numbers, charts and listings.

Active homes

Currently for sale

Homes for sale 10

Average list price $1,008,790

Avg. days on market 183 days

Avg. price per ft² $768 Based on 5 of 10 homes

Avg. living area 2,143 ft² Based on 5 of 10 homes

Avg. beds / baths 3.2 / 3.6

Price vs. living area

Each dot is a home. Hover a dot for its address, click it to see the home.

5 homes didn’t report living area and aren’t shown.

$6M$4M$2M$0

Price vs. living area: 5 homes plotted, up to $6M and 6,000 ft².

0 ft²2,0004,0006,000 ft²

How long homes have been listed

Number of homes by days on market.

1 0–30 days

2 31–90

3 91–180

3 181–365

1 365+

Bedroom mix

Number of homes by bedroom count.

5 homes didn’t report bedrooms and aren’t shown.

3 ≤3 bd

2 4 bd

0 5 bd

0 6 bd

0 7 bd

0 8+ bd

Highest price per ft²

Top 5 homes in this status.

660 Gulf Lane$1,166

4541 Conch Shell Drive$847

4561 Smugglers Drive$701

4460 Smugglers Drive$604

621 Rum Road$523

All active listings

Click a column to sort

Address	Beds	Baths	Living ft²	List price	$ / ft²	Days on market
660 Gulf LaneUpper Captiva, FL 33924	4	5	3,340	$3,895,000	$1,166	238 days
4460 Smugglers DriveUpper Captiva, FL 33924	4	3	2,358	$1,425,000	$604	152 days
4541 Conch Shell DriveUpper Captiva, FL 33924	3	4	1,646	$1,395,000	$847	218 days
621 Rum RoadCaptiva, FL 33924	3	4	2,481	$1,299,000	$523	142 days
4561 Smugglers DriveUpper Captiva, FL 33924	2	2	891	$624,900	$701	23 days
4430 Conch Shell DriveUpper Captiva, FL 33924	—	—	—	$595,000	—	136 days
671 Rum RoadUpper Captiva, FL 33924	—	—	—	$450,000	—	559 days
4471 Cutlass DriveUpper Captiva, FL 33924	—	—	—	$170,000	—	51 days
4531 Conch Shell DriveUpper Captiva, FL 33924	—	—	—	$156,000	—	54 days
4490 Schooner DriveUpper Captiva, FL 33924	—	—	—	$78,000	—	253 days

Under contract homes

Pending and contingent sales

Homes under contract 1

Average list price $1,595,000

Avg. days on market 331 days

Avg. price per ft² $667

Avg. living area 2,388 ft²

Avg. beds / baths 4.0 / 4.0

Price vs. living area

Each dot is a home. Hover a dot for its address, click it to see the home.

$3M$2M$1M$0

Price vs. living area: 1 home plotted, up to $3M and 3,000 ft².

0 ft²1,0002,0003,000 ft²

Days on market before going under contract

Number of homes by days on market.

0 0–30 days

0 31–90

0 91–180

1 181–365

0 365+

Bedroom mix

Number of homes by bedroom count.

0 ≤3 bd

1 4 bd

0 5 bd

0 6 bd

0 7 bd

0 8+ bd

Highest price per ft²

Top 1 home in this status.

4560 Conch Shell Drive$667

All under contract listings

Click a column to sort

Address	Beds	Baths	Living ft²	List price	$ / ft²	Days on market
4560 Conch Shell DriveUpper Captiva, FL 33924	4	4	2,388	$1,595,000	$667	331 days

Sold homes

Closed in the last 12 months

Homes sold 3

Average sold price $816,833

Avg. days to sell 233 days

Sold vs. list price 86.4%

Avg. price per ft² $662 Based on 2 of 3 homes

Avg. living area 1,764 ft² Based on 2 of 3 homes

Price vs. living area

Each dot is a home. Hover a dot for its address, click it to see the home.

1 home didn’t report living area and isn’t shown.

$1.5M$1M$500K$0

Price vs. living area: 2 homes plotted, up to $1.5M and 3,000 ft².

0 ft²1,0002,0003,000 ft²

How long homes took to sell

Number of homes by days on market.

0 0–30 days

0 31–90

1 91–180

2 181–365

0 365+

Bedroom mix

Number of homes by bedroom count.

1 home didn’t report bedrooms and isn’t shown.

2 ≤3 bd

0 4 bd

0 5 bd

0 6 bd

0 7 bd

0 8+ bd

Highest price per ft²

Top 2 homes in this status.

631 Rum Road$719

4511 & 4501 Schooner Drive$605

Sold price vs. list price

How close homes sold to their asking price.

0% sold at or above asking

2 Under 95%

1 95–98%

0 98–100%

0 100–102%

0 Over 102%

All sold listings

Click a column to sort

Address	Beds	Baths	Living ft²	Sold price	Sold / list	$ / ft²	Days to sell
631 Rum RoadUpper Captiva, FL 33924	3	4	1,920	$1,381,500	92.4%	$719	332 days
4511 & 4501 Schooner DriveUpper Captiva, FL 33924	3	4	1,608	$974,000	97.4%	$605	148 days
4431 Schooner DriveUpper Captiva, FL 33924	—	—	—	$95,000	69.3%	—	219 days

Questions about this market?

These numbers move every month. For what they mean for your home, or for a home you have your eye on, get in touch.

localrealestateonline.com Coldwell Banker Realty

Call +1(614)983-3277

Next steps

Free and instant. We can follow up with a detailed valuation.

City

Subdivision

Price

Max List Price

Beds

Baths

Property Type Home Commercial Land

Advanced Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity program of the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database. Real estate listings from the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the IDX logo and are provided by the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database. Information is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in. Copyright© 2026 Dayton Area Board of Realtors®